The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Sacked for joking about the Queen

A musical response to the absurd sacking of the radio DJ Tom Binns

As we prepare to enter 2010 here's a candidate for most absurd sacking of the year. The radio DJ Tom Binns has been dismissed after interrupting the Queen's Christmas message on air, saying: "Two words: bor-ring."

The humourless directors of BRMB, a Birmingham radio station, took fright after a handful of listeners complained. That the station had not planned to broadcast any of the speech (it mistakenly picked up a feed) was not, apparently, grounds for leniency.

Binns's sacking is indicative of the post-Sachsgate climate of fear and of the extraordinary deference the media continue to show to the royal family. We have grown used to the subservience adopted by the BBC when reporting on the monarchy and, depressingly, this attitude now seems to infect the commercial sector, too.

Binns's swangsong was distinguished by at least one decent gag. As he segued into Wham's "Last Christmas" he quipped, "From one queen to another . . ."

Had the voice of Elizabeth Windsor invaded my broadcast (in my student days I anchored a show, Clash, Fuse and Amplify, on Radio Warwick), I would have retaliated with something far stronger.

So, as an antidote to the apologists of the airwaves, here are two of the finest republican songs, the Stone Roses' "Elizabeth My Dear" and the Smiths' "The Queen Is Dead". Enjoy.

 

Follow the New Statesman team on Twitter

 

 

8 comments

markcrossley's picture

The Sovereigns Christmas Day message goes back many decades and is traditional for the UK and commonwealth media to communicate this to their audience as widely as possible to the Queens subjects.

As with anything TV and Radio stations have the choice whether this is broadcasted or not and also whether we even listen to it at all but it is popular with millions of people though and most media organisations are respectful towards the Royal Family and this was a minority hiccup.

Everything we do these days is examined under a microscope more than ever and there are two sides to every story and how we interpret what each side communicates to the public as in this instance but we all have to be careful as to what is politically correct, acceptable and timings on how to behave even if this does not beach any laws which are made by Royal Approval signed by Her Majesty in the name of the Crown we have to be mindful of our actions and especially in the media how it is portrayed not to offend others.

The Queen should intervene in this instance and refer it to the Press Complaints Authority via her staff to ensure something like this does not occur again and have the matter looked into more thoroughly, I am unaware of anything of this nature occurring previously and it would be good if the Royal Household Press Department could issue a statement on this incident and look at measures to prevent such an occurrence arising in future broadcasts.

The choice of whether to use Mr Binns in future broadcasts is a tricky one, to a certain extent how this is portrayed does not do Mr Binns or the radio station much credibility however like the Jonathan Ross and Russell Brand scandal He should have been suspended pending a full investigation, forced to make a written statement and apology on the radio stations website and be given clearer guidelines of what is acceptable and better checks within the station seem more appropriate to prevent this from occurring again on this or other stations.

He should not be sacked but be given a written warning instead and the radio station needs to be mindful they could be subject to unfair dismissal for sacking him despite this issue being of public interest and involving the Monarch.

As I understand it the person in question is a comedian and it poses issues yet again that as the society we live in gets progressively worse guidelines need to be issued somehow about what is and is not acceptable on a number of subjects by those like Mr Binns who attempt to humour us and where we draw the line and it’s a fine line.

What one finds funny another may not however in this instance perhaps this could be put down to a “communication error” and their paths do not have to depart after all the number of complaints appears to be minimal but it does involve the Head of State, if this was done in another country that the Queen is not sovereign but involved another monarch would the consequences be a lot worse than loosing his job I ponder?

We need to be careful how we talk about the Royal Family and vice versa and Christmas would not be Christmas if we did not have the Monarchs Christmas message would it now so either listen to it or choose not to but lets not have a repeat of what occurred in this case.

These comments are made as an overview having never heard the man before or the station mentioned and what I have read as prise on a number of different websites about the story.

Daniele1's picture

As far as I am concerned a Head of State is someone duly elected by the people of a country.Someone who happens to be a Head of State through an accident of birth not only should not be expecting deference and subservience from the media, it should not even expect respect.The day people in this country become citizens rather than subjects, they might become free to mock their bloody queen as freely as they mock the guy who is doing the real job of managing the country and who has been chosen by the people.

Param's picture

He should be promoted to Court Jester

majoredude's picture

Great Smiths' Video.We should be a Republic but vested interests stop that happening.Oh how i wish we lived in a world without these straights and creeps,they are dead heads holding back the surge for freedom.

John Hedges's picture

No cries in this case about 'the excesses of the PC brigade', eh?

Virginia's picture

It just shows how cringing British society remains. That is one of the reasons it is going down the chute. Get rid of the monarchy and grow up. Stop it with all the subservience and bowing and become part of the real world where leaders are elected and people earn respect via deeds not accident of birth.

Gary's picture

Two words best describe this commentary: Bor-ing!

Latest tweets