The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

The return of the shah, sans jewels

Martyr-making and arrests in Iran only create more problems for Khamenei

An Iranian opposition supporter covers his face with a bloodstained hand during clashes with security forces in Tehran on 27 December 2009. Photograph: Getty Images

The wave of arrests that erupted in Iran yesterday marks the latest move by a government determined to silence growing opposition despite the spiralling political crisis in which it finds itself.

However, it seems that the arrests, along with the killing on Sunday of eight protesters, including a nephew of the Reform presidential candidate, Mir Hossein Mousavi, will instead make martyrs out of mere men. The developments are also catalysing a movement that increasingly sees the regime of the Islamic Republic's supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, in the light of the former, much-hated shah.

Ali Mousavi's death is especially significant, given that the violent crackdown on Sunday's protests in Tehran coincided with the Shia holiday of Ashura, a mourning event that remembers Iman Husayn, a grandson of the Prophet Muhammad martyred in the year 680. Mousavi's body has since been seized, a move that analysts in Tehran have suggested is an attempt to prevent demonstrations from forming around his funeral.

Fatemeh Haghighatjoo, a former member of Iran's parliament who is currently a visiting scholar at the University of Massachusetts, told the New York Times:

Ashura is a very symbolic day in our culture and it revives the notion that the innocent were killed by a villain.

Similarly, Juan Cole, president of the Global Americana Institute, remarked:

For the regime to create a member of the Mousavi family as martyr on Ashura was most unwise. Shiite Islam even more than traditional Catholicism thrives on the blood of martyrs.

The arrests have only served to further villianise the regime. At least seven leading opposition activists have been arrested, including the opposition politician Ebrahim Yazdi, a foreign minister after the revolution, and three aides to Mousavi, prompting bloggers to label yesterday the "Iranian Night of the Long Knives".

More critically, Ayatollah Khamenei's legitimacy, already damaged by his support for Prime Minister Ahmadinejad's re-election in June, has been hardest hit by the government's decision to repress. Although he still commands the loyalty of the Revolutionary Guard, new hatred for him has sprung up among Iranian elites and the opposition is now more unlikely than ever to back down.

Writing on his website, the Iranian film-maker Moshen Makhamalbaf was one of those who denounced Khamenei for Sunday's violence by comparing him to the the shah (translation taken from the New York Times):

I am so sorry that I fought against the shah when I was 17. He left the country when he realised that people no longer wanted him. But you are resisting until everyone else leaves the country.

4 comments

Rahmin's picture

People in Irand dont and didnt hate the shah. The progoanda is still going on against him.

We are ashamed that we sent him to exile and now this.

khosrow's picture

today when in Tehran people speak of the Shah they say "the regretted one" and in fact they do regret him.

alimostofi's picture

MM is wrong. The Shahanshah left Iran because he was sure that once Khomeini is recognized for not putting Iran's interests above his own ideology, then the people would support the culture of Iran as paramount and support a Constitutional Monarchy as opposed to any non-cultural ideology. The left wing in Iran now has acknowledged that the culture of Iran is paramount, and no extreme ideology, be it political or religious can be allowed to rule over the people of this ancient land where the Declaration of Human Rights was born some 2500 years ago.

The Shahanshah had the most powerful army in the Middle East and he could have killed all the Islamist radicals then, but he did not. To date he is respected for that.

Brenda Goh, please refrain from using such phrases as "much hated shah". It is as if one used the phrase "much hated queen" if one were writing about the Queen of UK.

The people of Iran are actually motivated by the ancient spirit of Iran enshrined in the Zend Avesta, and detest the horrible Shia rituals. That is the root of the opposition to the Islamic rulers regular rituals.

H M's picture

These people don't regret the Shah:
http://tinyurl.com/y93g5cs
http://tinyurl.com/yzfhtbf

Latest tweets