China's shameful execution poses new challenges
Beijing continues to regard human rights with contempt
By George Eaton Published 29 December 2009 11:17
The shameful execution of Akmal Shaikh by China puts ministers and human rights groups in uncharted territory. The world's greatest user of capital punishment had not executed a European citizen since 1951. Attempting to win over a government that, unlike the United States, does not regard human rights as a legitimate concept represented a formidable challenge for all involved.
As did attempting to engage with a judicial system that remains cloaked in secrecy. So opaque is Chinese justice that it remains unclear whether Shaikh was killed by lethal injection or by firing squad.
Some bloggers have suggested that the British government did not do enough to persuade China to grant clemency. Iain Dale writes: "I am sorry, but Ivan Lewis is not a name to strike fear into the hearts of the Chinese government." That may be so, but we do know that Britain made 27 representations to China over the case and that Gordon Brown personally raised the case with Wen Jiabao.
Meanwhile, in an extraordinary intervention, Leo McKinstry, writing in the Daily Mail, favourably contrasts Beijing's "tough action" with Britain's "enfeebled" approach to drug smuggling.
He writes:
In contrast to New Labour's policy of appeasement and surrender, the Chinese government acts vigorously to defend its people from the misery caused by the drugs trade.
My regret is not over tough action by Beijing, but the fact that we in this country do not possess the moral clarity or strength of purpose to deal ruthlessly with drug peddlers [sic] and other enemies of our society.
He dismisses the evidence that Shaikh's apparent mental illness allowed him to be duped into smuggling heroin as "excuse-making". I won't pretend, and few should, to have the knowledge required to make a medical as well as a moral judgement on the case. But in his medical report on Shaikh, Dr Peter Schaapveld, a London-based clinical and forensic psychologist, concluded with "99 per cent certainty" that he was either bipolar or schizophrenic.
Combined with the standard arguments against the death penalty, such evidence represented an unassailable case for a stay of execution.
Gordon Brown and David Cameron deserve credit for unambiguously condemning China's behaviour in their respective statements this morning. Let us hope they will not be given cause to do so again.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists




















46 comments
@Jason,
Here is a lesson you drug dealers should learn from this comedy:
In the 21st century, it's not a safe business to sell drugs in China, even with a "bi-polar disorder" excuse. So, keep your business in the holy Great Britain.
School children in UK know that Opium war with China is very shameful.
Continue that "mental illness" spin... Repeat that a gazillion times may be it would become true.
After Copenhagan, we Chinese don't give a hoot about the partial Western media.
I read in Guardian, that there is no previous prove of his "mental illness". It all obviously started only after they found the heroin. Now, what should I think of that? I tell you: he was a british man bringing 4kg drugs to China. The end.
Now the scum is executed, the Chinese should send back the 4kg heroin to the drug-selling country United Kingdom, otherwise how can these bipolar-disordered offsprings of Opium dealers make enough money to run Olympics in 2012?
We are not fooled by the Chinese secret police posing as people on this site. We do not, in our OPEN society are not easily duped. It's a good job China is no longer communist and can no longer be regarded as such by international comrades. They bring shame on communism with their Stalinistic oppression.
We do not murder our own people. We have a free press. We do not retrict information coming into our country in order to CONTROL our people's minds. We do not try to bring down websites alll over the world because they push an idea of communism which does not fit their fascist state capitalist totalatarian model. They executed decency, freedom and the spirit of Marxism years ago. Why are we surprised at yet another display of heartlessness from a cold, secretive and capitalist bourgoise. SHAME on you all. Let's see what else the secret police drones have to say.
there was a report on the BBC News last night about the near-extinction of black bears in russia. they are being murdered and their body parts sent to ... China. china is the world's most corrupt state: godless, cruel, totalitarian. pity future generations when china is the world's superpower. the US may be at times worthy of contempt, but at least it is a democracy, it has wonderful universities and newspapers, it has world class intellectuals, it has a spirit of free debate... long may the US rule over us rather than the diabolical Chinese...
Gone quiet now haven't you! Propaganda of your sort died with Goebells and Stalin. Sitting at your government desks doing the bidding of your power mad masters. Look around you. Look into your hearts. Recall T Square. Does this reflect the spirit of your revolution? Your bully boys are no different to the imperial bully boys of your overthrown emperor. YOU are an instrument of the ruling oppressing class. At least stop pretending not to be a government worker. Go take a break and see if you can wash the blood off your handsand look yourself in the mirror.
Gee. Catching this so and so drug dealer before he facilitates the ruin of the Chinese youth speaks volumes for the Chinese government. This man is in his 50's for goodness sake, and he's managed to address life functionally at some level and now he won't function at any level. Try smuggling China's treasured porcelain out of the country and when caught you are immediately taken into a sideroom, given a trial of sorts and then executed, bang, bang. And well they should. Guess what, no smuggling for that would-be smuggler and a fine example for others. The message of a reality such as this is effective and curbs the enthusiasm for like deeds. Very effective. Forget about the mental illness drama. England has to put up a verbal blah blah - it looks good to the rest of the muslim community - and China knows it's politics and tongue in cheek. Don't screw with China!!!!!!!!!!!
Come back secret police. We are now missing your comical attempts to justify your masters' barbarism.
China is still living in its barbaric past and I suspect it always will.
MissClarity. Am excellent handle for a Chinese government propagandist. Veiled threats and seig heil rhetoric. Stick to terrorising your own tired and oppressed people. You are imperial oppressors wearing but different masks. MissClarity. More like government ape or fascist apologist.
phowell
The West hadn't even apologized for colonialism, let alone reparations. What made you think Blair will answer (dearly, that is) for his actions in Iraq? They can continue their political grand standings all they want. I won't hold my breath.
MC. From communists to Nazis. How ironic.
The decision to execute Mr. Shaikh by the Chinese Government was a just one. All countries throughout the world should adopt such a policy for drug smuggling and acts of terrorism. The UK Government have become a laughing stock throughout the world for their lenient policies and political correctness.
I can't believe that any right minded person would fall for the Mental Illness excuse given by this drug mule. He was fit enough to travel around the world on his own.
Good riddance and it's a shame our own goverment are so soft.
I am bowing out. Happy propagandising. Here is another lesson for you lot. In the 21st century barbarians are lone cancers killing goodness. You are deluded if you think you are just. The rest of the civilised world rejects you. Murder is a dangerous business. Much worse than peddling drugs. Bye.
@Jason,
In the 21st century, drug trade may be goodness in your Great Britain, but not in the rest of the world. So, as I advised you earlier, keep your drug business in the UK. You are not welcome in other countries.
It is you who are not welcome because everybody recognises the brutality of your regime. How much do they pay faceless robots like you to peddle your propaganda. Please don't speak of morality. It was your abscestors that addicted many of mine to opium. The opium dens were not run by us and neither did we profit from them. Your government are hypocrites and you are nothing but a brainwashed fool. I pity you. Now please crawl back under your rock. As a communist I deplore you and on behalf of the workers of the world exile you to your delusions and oppressive practices which are contrary to being good and honorable. As for nit being welcome in YOUR country I consider that a compliment. Now off you go and torture someone for speaking their mind.
My wife just pointed out to me that the issue is that you put people to death for just about anything. Your attitude towards mental illness, whoever you are, characterises you as either a fascist or the mouthpiece of heartless tyrants. This aside, whatever the crime, capital punishment is always beloved of closed totalatarian societies. Are you actually able to argue with a straight face, that your 'tough' line makes your society better? You just work by making your people afraid. Isn't that what your revolution was meant to end? well done on that one. I really am going now because you are merely amusing me and I have better things to do like NOT be tortured for being pro democracy.
The point is not the crime of smuggling drugs in the point is the fact that the Chinese think it is fine to execute people willy-nilly and also think it ok not to take into consideration mitigating circumstances. What makes me laugh is that anyone here is expected to imagine that any of the people other than me are anything but drones employed by the Chinese government to peddle their propaganda. What would have been wrong with a long prison term once the special circumstances were taken into consideration. All the UK bashing is because the UK are not sitting and taking this outrage. Nobody in particular - do your family know what you do? Invade left wing British websites with your weird propaganda. The state probably paid for you to learn your English in one of our universities; since you don't have any of your own - due to the fact that they encourage freedom of thought and speech. Don't preach to us about decency. Tibet, T Square, Internet restrictions. Just go to bed propagandists, no REAL British people think you are right to do what you did. The only voices FOR your point of view are the sinister secret computer police writing on here.
I just got an email with no subject and no content and no sender sent to an address I have quoted here. I wonder who that is! Could it be the Chinese bully boys I wonder. Aww. Bless em. Does it hurt when people disagree and see through your 1940s propaganda charade?
Debord and Jason,
If I were Chinese spy, tell me where to collect my pay!
It's you two that remind us how phony some British are. I don't care if you don't kill your own people? You sure kill a lot of foreigners all over the world!
@Debord
Your depress & pain are obvious & understandable, as you have just lost a fellow drug smuggler today.
But, hey, things have the brighter side. You can still sell the evils like communism & heroin in your own Great Great Britain. And the amazing thing is, there will be some mentally ill Brits falling for your scheme. Isn't that wonderful? I cheer for you as long as you keep them inside the UK. Fair deal?
Maybe, if he were your son, most commenters here would show an ounce of compassion/humanity/integrity?
It is a simple and perhaps naive notion, but the fundamental problem with the Chinese Government alongside Western Governments is their complete inability to remain human where there is Power in it for them. The world will either burn up or get blown up before people realise that stalinistic faux-communism AND capitalism just DON'T work when they are put in place to organise living beings.
I am pretty anti people making a living out of feeding off of someone else's addiction without a care for what it could do to them - but killing such people off with no regard for the circumstances is no better. Preaching about it when your clothes are made in terrible conditions by Eastern 9 year olds is also no better.
The Chinese Gov't show the same disreagrd for humanity in this morning's execution as the West does in its faceless 'war on terror' and its brainless, capitalist lust for commodity.
The freedoms we have in the west just make us complacent, the freedoms the Chinese don't have make them ignorant and oppressed. Doens't take a genius to work out that we need to work out another way of doing things...? Preferably, we could do so *before* we kill any more people?
This man was carrying no less than four Kgs of heroïne in a country where he was not obliged to go.
I do not approve death penalty in any respect but the emotion displayed by the Prime Minister should be measured with regard to the one he manifests when ordering daily killings of civilians in Afghanistan and the one he should have suffered when participating as a Chancellor in a Cabinet which waged an illegal war which killed hundreds of thousands of civilians.
Respect of life should be consistent even for a clergyman's son.
@Nobodyinparticular
A sensible person with an ounce of compassion/humanity/integrity would feel shameful if his/her son is a drug smuggler. That's the simple & common sense in the rest of the world, apparently not in the UK.
Mr Nobodyinparticular. Do not assume to know who makes my clothes as I will try not to assume I know who is REALLY paying your wages. I know my politics and I know the world is not a simple place and I am not here to defend the west as I am not a big fan of what capitalism does to people, including drug abuse, and for the other writers here to think that because we believe that the Chinese government's recation is inhumane that we all approve of peddling and trafficking drugs. This is like saying that everyone in China does not believe in freedom. As for the west and their adventures in the middle east their are plenty here that disagree with it as much as anyone else but we are allowed to say so.
Akmal Shaikh did not cause the Opium Wars. It was wrong for China to punish a mentally ill man for what happened in the nineteenth century. I have many Chinese friends, but right now I'm very angry at the Chinese government.
Miki, nobody said the guy was executed for anything in the 19th century. If there was, it was your media trying to mislead you, again. He was put to death for drug trafficking. Any mental disease argument is last minute ploy to save him or embarrass the Chinese.
Attention, drug dealer Debord!
Another of your fellow got caught in Taiwan.
http://www.monstersandcritics.com/news/asiapacific/news/article_1521984....
Spend some of your tax money to send in a decent lawyer for him, please. Oh, and don't forget to book a business flight to welcome him back to the UK as a national hero, after he serves his prison term.
To clarify, Debord, I can assure you I receive no wages at all, from no Government or employer of any kind, and I am rather hungry for it, and am lacking said wages out of nothing but pleasant idleness.
Even if the I wanted to be a Chinese spy, they would not employ me.
I can barely handle walking in a straight line, I could not be any kind of spy, unless we are talking spying on a Baker or a Librarian.
The clothes comment wasn't aimed at you, it was merely means of identifying the hypocrisies of most Brit's in their plugging of Western Democracy.
I can tell you aren't a capitalist (and did not imply you were) as you should have been able to tell from my post. I merely suggested that nobody should kill anybody. No killing, of anyone, should take place. Killing=bad.
Capitalism=bad
Totalitarianism=bad
=let's find something different and better.
I was on your side.
We are allowed to say pretty much whatever we want, but my complaint is that we very very rarely do anything about it. I am a shining example. Boredom, as you yourself (or rather, the real Debord) said, is always counter-revolutionary. And our nation is bored and desensitised, for the most part (largely, we don't even vote, let alone anything more sognificant).
But like I said, not aimed at you, not really aimed at anybody, just floating thoughts.
If I am peddling any kind of propoganda, it is that of books written by your own pseudonym.
Goodnight, don't be got by the Spectacle...
@xzws
....You're a bit sick. Nobody has much time for you.
OH MY GOD china just murder an innocent man..
BAW BAW BAW BAW
and look at him
he's not even sane..
Stupid leftish European
and George is a FAG
@Nobodyinparticular
Did I hit your weak spot? I am sorry, but is the truth so hard for you to swallow?
This bipolar defence is hogwash. Do you see a disproportionate bipolar population in the drug trade? NO! The majority are productive citizens. Wake up, you naive broken hearts!
Goooooodness me, sorry for not randomly wanting to shoot people. I am back off to The Guardian, you're all a bit loopy over here. Liberals I can handle, but wanking off to the suffering of others, @xzws.... well, you must be very lonely.
Night.
For the hell of it, I agree whole heartedly agree with @Nobodyinparticular (in all senses of that phrase).
He/She is of course right, down with the Chinese Republic and their oppresive ignorance and joy-killings, down with hypocritical western capitalism... and let's all embrace some love and smiles and laughter, eh?
Until then, I am back over to The Guardian; You're all a bit loopy over here.
Nobodyinparticular,
Until all the Western governments apply the same compassion to every foreign country instead of your selective ones, then I can agree with you. Otherwise, tough.
Growing up in HK, I never like what Britain stands for. Don't get me wrong, I don't hate British. I hate that there never was democracy in 150 years of British rule. Then after they left, they tried to fool people in the world we had democracy before the Chinese came. How dishonest!
I personally don't buy anything British. What the heck do they produce anyway? Cars? There are much better ones in the market. And not as overpriced too.
I too grew up in Hong Kong. The Brits there thought they were so darn special. Most of them lived away from the Chinese, up the hill. Some lived there for a few generations but managed not to know a darn word of Chinese. Talk about amazing.
In Macao, the Portugese integrated much better with locals. intermarraiage was very common. Many spoke perfect Chinese.
Shame on the British.
Bipolar is a mood disorder which affects emotional control and expression. It does not mean you cant think fairly well most of the time. You are not mad. Maybe sad or silly at times.
Jeez, Jason, can you please take a chill pill? This inflammatory language just turns into China-bashing and gets us no-where. One could argue that the Chinese have never bombed a million Iraqis into oblivion.
The death penalty is appalling wherever it is. I prefer today's Independent leader article for its balance and refusal to let anyone off the hook:
http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/leading-articles/leading-article-wh...
China once upon a time thought Capitalism was backward.
They will soon wake up to the fact that state sanctioned murder is not on.
And before anyone throws Iraq at me,
a)It's a different argument
b)I agree that it was also wrong and should be condemned, and Blair made to answer for his actions.
KK
I sincerely hope the independent board will make him answer for his actions in Iraq. He now longer has the influence he once did to silence his critics, e.g. Dr David Kelly.
As for colonialism - I dont think there will ever be an apology for that - I think "it wasnt on our shift" would be the response.