The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

A giant leap forward for Muslim women

World's first female muftis to be appointed next year

While I was in the United Arab Emirates recently, the newspapers were dominated by a single subject -- the inaugural Abu Dhabi Grand Prix. One of the first news items to clear F1 off the front page was a remarkable story which, to my surprise, does not appear to have been picked up anywhere in the British media. And that is that the emirate of Dubai has announced it intends to appoint what, it appears, will be the world's first state-sanctioned female muftis (interpreters or expounders of sharia law) next year.

Justifying the move, the Grand Mufti of Dubai, Dr Ahmed al-Haddad, said:

Evidence points to the fact that women, too, can order acts of virtue and ban acts of vice just like a man can. And of course she can do that only with acquired scholarship and training, which is what female contemporaries of the Prophet have done as well as the women who came after them.

In many Muslim countries women are already involved with the issuing of fatwas, or legal rulings, but frequently these are confined to "female issues". Dr al-Haddad, however, argues that "a woman who is learned and trained in issuing fatwas is not limited in her role to issuing fatwas that relate to women only, but rather she is qualified to issue on matters of worship, jurisprudence, morality and behaviour".

This will be noted particularly in Egypt, where Soad Saleh, professor of comparative jurisprudence at Cairo's famed al-Azhar University, has been campaigning for ten years for a female mufti to be appointed. Long a prominent authority on religion, Saleh says Egypt's Grand Mufti was enthusiastic when she first mentioned it, but that nothing has happened since.

Saleh was careful to make the following point when asked about the cause of the delay: "These are social attitudes that date back a long, long time, which we must not attribute to Islam. Because Islam, which honoured women and gave them all their rights, can never be guilty of them."

This line -- that it is man-made rules that need to change, not religion -- is strengthened by the UAE being the first place where these first muftis will be appointed. For, however true the image of the Emirates as an easygoing boom state may be for expats, it is still a highly traditional society which observes a conservative form of Islam. If Malaysia or Indonesia, for instance, had been the first to train female muftis, the move could have been dismissed as the deviant product of overly (and openly) liberal Muslim elites. Not so in the Arabian Gulf.

If the Grand Mufti of Dubai was accused of being a liberal or a reformist, he would probably be mightily offended and would repudiate such descriptions in the strongest terms. Islam needs no "liberalising" or "reforming", he would say. He is merely clearing away the clutter and accretion of male-dominated tradition and culture.

This is an important pointer for the future, as western critics of Islam tend to assume that women's rights in Muslim countries can only be safeguarded and increased through secular means, by pushing religion aside. But in Islamic states, it is much more likely that women's emancipation will come from within their religion, from enlightened individuals such as Dr al-Haddad.

Those who say this is not enough, or ask why it has taken so long for Islam to accept women in such positions, should perhaps turn their thoughts to the Catholic Church. It has, after all, been around for over 600 years longer than Islam; and it is still nowhere near letting women into the priesthood. The reason for this is that, crucially, Christ's disciples were all men, whereas, as Dr al-Haddad points out, Muslims can look to several examples of women in positions of religious and political authority in and around the time of the Prophet. Let us hope that more, like him, choose to do so.

6 comments

swatantra's picture

This is one up on the Catholic Church. But words must be matched by deeds. This progressive move is but one small step but many will disagree and stick to their own traditional Islam.

syedmakki's picture

Posters seem to be getting the role of a Scholar confused with that of Clergy. Islam has no clergy that is clear. Islam has had many many female scholars. Some of Whom like Ayesha (RA) are regarded as authorities in jurisprudence.

That a female Mufti has been appointed is not an attempt to circumvent Qurani injunctions. It more a recognition of the importance of the Prophet Muhammad (saw) pronoucements on women and men to acquire knowledge, and to consider acquiring knowledge as an obligation and further pronoucements that even if you are in possession of one verse of knowledge that the possessor should convey it. these are generic sayings and as such are not limited to anyone sex.

I welcome the decision of the UAE courts and hope that this will be followed in other jurisdictions. In Pakistan there seats reserved for female MP's and yet women fare very badly in the tribalistic environment and with many many awful cultural tradition which are more hindhu than Islamic. I hope the Judiciary there will also begin appointing female judges to address the concerns of those women who suffer at the hands of such un-Islamic practices

masad92's picture

If the Nag Hamadi Scrolls, or Gnostic Gospels are to be believed (which the Catholic Church emphatically does not) Mary Magdelene was not only the "Beloved Disciple" of Jesus, not John (and probably his wife - read James Tabor's "The Jesus Dynasty" for more details), but also the leader of the Apostles, not Peter, because of her closeness to Jesus and leadership abilities. Apparently, this has been covered up by a misoginystic Church for millennia. On the contrary, Islam brought women's rights to one of the most backward areas of the world in the early 7th century, long before many of those rights were "given" to women in a supposedly "enlightened" and more modern Europe in the 20th century. Unfortunately, after these rights were revealed in the Qur'an and seen in Prophet Muhammad's example, after he died equally misogenystic Muslims relapsed into the culturally backward jahiliyyah (time of ignorance) of the pre-Islamic period in which they were originally and effectively took away many of those rights in many parts of the Muslim world. So, it's good to see this happening not only in the UAE but also elsewhere in the Muslim world, which has seen women as leaders of their countries, like Turkey, Pakistan, and Bangladesh, which is something we've yet to see in the U.S.

Ayesha's picture

Good news, that some Muslims are trying to find ways round Quran 4:34, "Men are managers of the affairs of women because Allah has made the one superior to the other."

Will these women be allowed to lead men or minister to women only?

Overall I'd rather be a woman in a conservative Catholic country than a woman in almost any Muslim country.

ed3's picture

I've often thought that a siege mentality focuses us on those aspects of our past cultural experience that lets us distinguish ourselves from those without for the purpose of maintaining our sense of self-efficacy. Given the patriarchal state of affairs in the past, it it not too surprising that quite a few 'Islamic' states have remained patriarchal in the face of an imperialistic western 'other'. But given a relatively egalitarian relationship with outsiders, they would be more focused on the egalitarian aspects of their cultures.

Hadija's picture

I agree with the arguement that women rights especially in the moslem world will come faster through Islam itself.Islam grants women more rights than any other religion. Unfortunately, both men and women are not aware of these rights.For example how many people know that a muslim woman should be allowed to work and that the money she earns is her own or that a women must be rewarded by her husband for breastfeedind a child. The few men who understand Islam tend either not to tell the truth about women rights in Islam or to mix islam with oppressive traditions and pick only aspects that enable them to dominate women. The solution is not to change Islam but to correctly translate the Koran and Hadith in as many languages as there exist so that all people can understand it. As long as Islam is still paged to the Arabic language, it will remain the dominance of a few Islamic schoolars and women rights will continue to be misinterpreted and misunderstood. The problem is not Islam, it is the people who misinterpret it and misapply it to serve their selfish interests

Latest tweets