Registered user login:

TheFaithColumn

The Faith Column

Every week a different believer gives the inside track on their religion or philosophy.

The Faith Column Homepage

Will they tolerate me if I wear shorts?

  • Posted by Becer Gul
  • 05 August 2008

Becer Gul gives her views on the current government in Turkey, which some claim has an hidden Islamic agenda.

Ever since Ataturk became the leader of Turkey and established a secular country, the Alevi people were able to speak out openly and say: “Yes we are Alevis. We have our own practices and, indeed, we pay taxes like everyone else.”

For years we have been asking for more rights but the government just ignored us. However, as a lot of Alevis began to migrate to European countries, they came to know of their human rights and that there are other people out there who can support them. Today there are lots of new Alevi centres in Turkey, where before there weren't.

In regards to the current AKP government in the country, for the Alevis there are both negatives and positives. I am a secularist. I don't like the hijab because I think in this type of Islam there is no tolerance. Will they tolerate me if I wear shorts or if I go swimming or even if I go out with my bare head?

I know they will force women to cover-up. In Turkey most men make their wives to cover their heads. Further, the number of women covering-up is on the increase. And they are not just content with covering them up. They are covering the woman and keeping them in the house. We are looking at a future where the woman's place will be at home because this is a male-dominated religion. These people do not want women to do anything. They are taking advantage of their religion in order to keep the woman inside.

However it is not just the Sunnis. There are even extremists among Alevis, specifically those who grew up in mixed societies. If you live in a place which is homogenous in terms of religion, such as my town of Tunceli where close to 90 percent are Alevis, then there is more tolerance for other people. Personally I have lots of Sunni and Alevi friends but I don't like extremists on both sides.

Some people say that if a person is not an Alevi, then they are not going to marry them or even talk to them for that matter. So there are also extremist Alevis.

In Turkey people respect my Alevi side more then my Kurdish. When people ask my mum about who she is, she will tell them that she is an Alevi. This is because her Alevi side has a stronger effect on her personality then being Kurdish.

One more thing about the Alevis is that they are very keen on education. This includes girls education. Amongst the Sunnis families however, girls are covered-up and placed under pressure. But in Alevi culture there are greater gender rights. A women has more voice then in a Sunni society. Male dominance still exists, partially because of the effects of the Ottoman empire.

If someone has a naked head they don't think she wants sex – its normal.

*The author of this article is writing under a pseudonym

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

4 comments from readers

www.beyazrenkler.org
08 August 2008 at 16:42

The Gulf War in 1990-91 was a critical catalyst for Turkey's reentry into the Middle East. Against the advice of many of his advisers and of the Turkish military, President Turgut Özal threw Turkey's full support behind the U.S. military campaign to drive Iraq out of Kuwait. He enforced United Nations sanctions by cutting off the flow of Iraq's oil exports through Turkish pipelines, deployed 100,000 troops along the Iraqi-Turkish border, and allowed the United States to fly sorties into Iraq from Turkish bases. Özal saw the war as an opportunity to demonstrate Turkey's continued strategic importance and cement closer defense ties with the United States. He hoped that Turkey's support would strengthen its "strategic partnership" with the United States and enhance its prospects of joining the European Community (as the eu was then called).

Özal's hopes proved illusory on both counts. The strategic partnership with the United States never materialized, and Turkey's chances at membership in the European Community hardly improved. Economically, Turkey paid a high price for its support of the U.S. military campaign: it lost billions of dollars in pipeline fees and trade. Politically, it was left facing a major escalation of its Kurdish problem. The establishment of a de facto Kurdish state in northern Iraq under Western protection gave new impetus to Kurdish nationalism and provided a logistical base for attacks on Turkish territory by the Kurdistan Workers' Party, the violent Kurdish separatist group known as the pkk. For many Turks, the war was, as the veteran Turkey watcher Ian Lesser has noted, "the place where the trouble started."

shaybani
12 August 2008 at 23:37

Wearing shorts is hardly a major issue. The attributing of divinity to a human being, Ali (may God be pleased with him) that Alevis do is idolatry renders them non-Muslim.

Not even sure if this is an issue- may Alevis dont consider themselves Muslims and though they are sometime consdered an offshoot of Shiaism mainstream shias reject them

Not sure why the NS is so hung up on promoting non-Muslim heretical groups as Muslims/true Islam

shaybani
12 August 2008 at 23:41

"In regards to the current AKP government in the country, for the Alevis there are both negatives and positives. I am a secularist. I don't like the hijab because I think in this type of Islam there is no tolerance. Will they tolerate me if I wear shorts or if I go swimming or even if I go out with my bare head?"

So you oppose other peoples right to dress how they wish why demanding they respect yours?

"I know they will force women to cover-up. In Turkey most men make their wives to cover their heads. "

How do you know this? And what you say about men forcing their wives is just anti-Muslim lies. I could quite easily say that non-Muslim men force their wives to dress in revealing clothes and when the wives say "No i want to dress like this" just claim they are brainwashed as non-Muslims do with hijab wearing Muslim women

"Further, the number of women covering-up is on the increase. And they are not just content with covering them up. They are covering the woman and keeping them in the house. We are looking at a future where the woman's place will be at home because this is a male-dominated religion. These people do not want women to do anything. They are taking advantage of their religion in order to keep the woman inside. "

So why is there such a strong campaign to allow women in hijab to be able to study at univeristy

Honestly this article is rubbish

adam
20 August 2008 at 00:12

One can easily conclude how simple-minded and intolerant the writer of this article is by just reading it.

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before your comment is displayed on the website

You may enter up to 2000 characters (about 300-350 words)

Characters left:

We want to encourage people to comment on our content and to exchange views with other readers and hope this will be done on a courteous basis. However, if you encounter posts which are offensive please let us know by emailing comments@newstatesman.co.uk and we will take swift action where necessary.

Recent Posts

Compassion during the crisis

  • By Matthew Jee
  • 19 November 2008

The church in the crunch

  • By Simon Barrow
  • 18 November 2008

White Poppies

  • By Symon Hill
  • 07 November 2008

Quakers and the UN

  • By Chris Walker
  • 06 November 2008

Walking the talk

  • By Eoin McCarthy
  • 05 November 2008

Quakers for prison reform

  • By Helen Drewery
  • 04 November 2008

Seeking, not finding

  • By Ben Dandelion
  • 03 November 2008