Steven Baxter

Patrolling the murkier waters of the mainstream media

Syndicate contentRSS

Wanted: Experienced interns. And I’m not joking

Journalism is now like working for the St John Ambulance, but without the chance to put a sling on s

Jobhunting isn't fun. There are many un-fun things about it, from the circulatory rejection email to the bottomless pit into which all applications seem to fall, never to be mentioned again. But perhaps the worst feeling of all is the one I've had a couple of times this week: finding a really decent job advertised that looks perfect for me, then discovering that the salary is £0.00 per annum.

Nowadays, in the media and other industries, you don't have to incentivise potential workers with old-fashioned money; any advert will bring a hundred eager candidates stretching right around the building. Bosses can pick and choose -- and they can pay nothing. Some so-called "internships" demand that candidates have extensive experience and skills and will be required to complete a challenging series of tasks to help make money for the company -- just not for themselves.

It sums up the state of the industry. On the one hand, a few experienced workers cling to permanent positions as if their lives depend on it; which quite often, they do, if they've got bills to pay and families to support. On the other, there's a huge churn of casual employees who have no working rights and who are therefore ripe for exploitation. Step out of line, and your boss could advertise for your position and get flooded with applications overnight, some of which would come from people who'd work for nothing. What choice have you got? It's this culture of fear that brings about compliance from workers who would stretch their ethical boundaries to keep their positions. It's a lose-lose situation for everyone.

It's easy to blame the thousands of graduates from media and journalism courses up and down the country and say it's somehow their fault for wanting to do what they want to do; but I can't, because I was, and am, one of them. I don't know if there really was a golden age when there were vast fortunes to be made and people had jobs for life; there probably wasn't, and those of us struggling to find work now probably knew that pretty well when we signed up. That said, there just aren't the jobs anymore as there once were, and, if there are jobs, you'll have to sweat to get them. True, some people do bafflingly walk into newspapers or magazines without any discernible talent and go on to make a fortune out of it, but I don't begrudge them their bit of luck either: they've played the fruit machine and won. Deep down we'd all fancy a bit of that luck, and I'm no different.

I've got nothing against work experience or genuine internships either; it's how a lot of us (me included) managed to get a breakthrough in the workplace, and it's vital for gaining an insight into a career path. But we're not talking about work experience; we're talking about working up to the standard of a paid worker, having the same tasks as a paid worker, but not being paid; doing a hobby in a workplace. Journalism is now like working for the St John Ambulance, but without the chance to put a sling on someone. The industry is essentially saying: "Look, you know you're desperate, we know you're desperate, so what's it going to be?"

Well, we all know what it's going to be. Already, the type of people who can make it in the industry has changed, and it will change even more. People from poorer backgrounds just aren't going to be able to chuck six months or a year of their lives away for nothing; those from wealthier backgrounds are. I don't think journalism was ever an especially diverse profession, but at least there were chances. Now, what chance do people have, when rents are rising, prices are flying and wages are non-existent?

There are many dispiriting things about being unemployable in this coalition world of dwindling opportunities and guttering hope. It's probably worse for the young people who feel there's no future, the masses of men and women with great qualifications, great skills and absolutely zero chance of getting anywhere because of when they happen to have arrived in the jobs market. I don't blame some of them for working for nothing in the hope it will get them somewhere. But I am not so sure it will get any of us anywhere.

14 comments

Brendy's picture

Does this mean the New Statesman has started to pay it's own battalion of desperate interns?

AdamMAli's picture

Candour.

Well, I'm suitably put off.

unemployedhack's picture

I did some unpaid "work experience" as a young journalist while at university - but when I left uni I went into a paid job. I say paid, the money was awful, but the recognition was that I was selling my labour. If you are writing articles, taking photos, editing, reporting, feature-writing, or mopping the floors you are working and so should be paid. The National Union of Journalists is doing its bit to support and get cashback for interns: http://www.nuj.org.uk/innerPagenuj.html?docid=1754
I would encourage all young journalists to join. There should be no discussion - a day's pay for a day's work.
http://unemployedhack.wordpress.com/

Sir Michael's picture

Mr Baxter... due to our compassionate governments "war on laziness" (or as it should be called, the re-introduction of slavery) every single industry will soon be like this.

When they start those work programs (which already have many UK businesses eager to get involved) they will be effectively employing people for nothing. Well not quite for nothing, the taxpayer will have to pay the "wages" (benefits) for the "employee" so the company doesn't have to, but still, the issue is the same.

People in all industries are going to be competing for jobs against people who will be compelled to provide their labor for free.

Tommy Danger's picture

If you like to write, why don't you write a book instead, and try and get a deal with a publisher? At least you'll be in control and maintain you're self respect. I don't work in the media sector, but an important point about job hunting is to be flexible and broad sighted.
Good luck.

Eileen2's picture

It's the same in the graphic design industry; everybody wants charity work and you can't get an internship without experience. Why don't the graduate journalists and graphic designers get together and create their own newspapers and magazines and set up in competition with the cheating so-and-so-s?

Nodbod's picture

Internships should be made illegal immediately. I fully appreciate that it sorts the wheat from the chaff (working class from upper middle and upper class) but if an organisation need a job doing then they should pay the rate. Not minimum wage either, a proper wage for a proper job. However the mob currently in government are hardly likely to endorse this view. They are the ultimate "look after your own" and if they can lever the lower classes out of the professions, they wil do. Unfortunately the previous lot were as bad with their "era of the volunteer." I just want to know what Tony B, Cherie B, P Manglebum or any of the other hangers on have ever done without an explicit reward at the end of it. But it's OK for you peasants to do it!

I'd make nepotism illegal too, but that's probably a step too far, these days.

Chris's picture

I'm surprised the NS bosses let you write this considering their own policy regarding unpaid interns.

swatantra's picture

There is some work available in Trade Journals like 'Constuction in Bulgaria', if you are not too fussy, and like writing about widgets.

Intern's picture

I interned at the NS in 2010, I received travel expenses (zones 1-2 only) and nothing else by way of pay, even lunch.

My main job (along with several other highly educated and enthusiastic interns) was to copy and paste articles from trade magazines onto the NS website - passing them off as the NS's own. There was not even the slightest pretense that a job might be on offer at the end of the internship - not least because several of the junior workers at the magazine were themselves desperately trying to acquire better roles within the company.

During my time at the NS, I learnt next to nothing, though at one point I did have the opportunity to go and get Jason Cowley's (editor) lunch, he didn't thank me afterwards.

I would strongly advise anyone thinking of applying to intern at the magazine not to; the staff were nearly all lovely but overall the experience was worthless.

Chris4's picture

You can't have a job at the New Statesman. They're reserved for posh rich people like Jemima Khan

Freeman2's picture

In my youth I applied for a job as a trainee reporter where the news editor was Kelvin Mackenzie's father. He ignored me so I wrote again. He gave me an interview and offered me a job - a paid job. That's the way it was. Why should it be any different now?

Matt's picture

@ Tommy Danger

As it happens, Steven has written a book and got it published:

http://www.lulu.com/product/paperback/musings-of-a-monkey/16347565

...available in all good bookshops, or hopefully some of them, etc etc (am I allowed to say that here? I'm not a shill, just one of his Twitter followers).

I don't know much about getting a book published but I know this much: writing one takes a long time, and then if you're fortunate enough to get it published you don't make any money out of it.

The publishing industry is being squeezed as hard as anything. Some published and experienced novelists are being offerd advances of as little as 2 grand.

So whatever writing a book does for Steven's self-esteem I doubt it's going to make a life changing difference to his bank balance. The only people who can afford to put their life into writing a book are the same ones who can afford to do the internships.

Ona's picture

Its dangerous to think there was a golden age. I graduated into Thatcherite Britain - it was hard then and it is hard now. I worked in the voluntary sector and we had an army of volunteers working alongside us - we just didn't call them interns. Being in work didn't mean I could buy a home - I retrained into something else and was 35 before I could afford a flat in London with my partner. Coming into the employment pool at a time of a recession is scaring for life.

Latest tweets