Who will succeed David Cameron as Tory leader?
Matthew d’Ancona speculates in GQ.
By James Macintyre Published 05 July 2010 15:08The ConservativeHome website has got hold of a copy of August's GQ, in which Matthew d'Ancona, a commentator who is close to the Tory leadership, speculates on the runners and riders who might succeed David Cameron.
The piece comes at a mildly vulnerable time for Cameron, as his failure to win the election outright is demonstrated every day by moves that the Tory right considers consessions to the Lib Dems (the latest of these being over next year's controversial AV referendum) and the Prime Minister is unlikely to be thrilled at it.
Here are some extracts:
- George Osborne (8/1 according to Ladbrokes): "The more Osborne behaves like a man who expects no further promotion, the more focused he seems in his absolute determination to slash the deficit and take the political heat, the more he looks like a potential leader. I have long thought he is up to the job, but am struck by how many MPs have come around to that view since he became Chancellor."
- Michael Gove (5/1): "He would have a strong claim to be the candidate of the Tory modernisers in the post-Cameron world, but has credibility on the right, too, as the architect of the government's radical plan for 'free' schools liberated from the dead hand of town-hall control."
- Boris Johnson (5/1): "His public distaste for the coalition talks was a barely coded signal to party and public alike, as was his invitation to Cameron to use London under Mayor Boris as a model for the new government's spending cuts strategy. These minor provocations -- always carefully surrounded by rich praise for Cameron -- certainly infuriate the PM and the Chancellor. The question is when and how Boris makes his move. As another former MP for Henley, Michael Heseltine, used to say of his own chances against Thatcher, he has one bullet in his revolver. As soon as Boris heads back to the Commons -- especially if he decides not to seek a second term as mayor, or stands down midterm to fight for a seat -- his every move will be interpreted feverishly as a Churchillian step towards the top job. So timing is all."
- Jeremy Hunt (20/1): "Something tells me that the man to watch is Jeremy Hunt, the new Culture Secretary, a man so ambitious he squeaks when he walks. He manages to be charmingly moderate and yet not a member of the Cameroon gang. He is telegenic, gaining in presence by the month, and fizzing with ideas. If Hunt can build up a back-bench following in the next few years, he will hard to beat."
To this, I would only add that one should still consider David Davis to be in the running; Liam Fox is likely to fancy it; and of course, if Westminster weren't victim to insane ageism, Kenneth Clarke would still be recognised as the Tory politician with the most reach to the electorate (would he have won outright in May?).
Interestingly, d'Ancona also appears to entertain the possibility that Boris Johnson, perhaps Cameron's most dangerously ambitious rival, will not stand for a second term as London mayor. As I have long suspected, despite recent speculation to the contrary. Let the debate begin.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Jobs
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists

















20 comments
I don't know and don't ccare who replaces Cameron. But if past history is anything to go by it'll be his own Tories that'll destroy him, the knives were out the day he walked into No 10.
Read my lips...
Chris Kelly
Easy. Its got to be Nick.
swatantra - that made me laugh!
oh come on it has to be gove..............cameron will be gone within months, and with gove theyd never win again, and think of the fun for comedians everywhere
How about Nick Clegg?
Frankly, the Tory record on picking able and honest leaders is so poor that it really won't make much difference who leads them when Cameron gets what is coming to him. For the Left, it must be encouraging that Boris Johnson seems to be the front runner at the moment. He knows less about what it is to live in this country outside London than Cameron and the rest of the Bollie Quaffers.
On the expectation that there won't be a new Tory leader for some time, I'd be watching out for Rory Stewart,the newly elected Penrith MP and former deputy governor in Iraq. In fact I'd be quite surprised if he didn't make it to at least Foreign Secretary.
swatantra's comment made me chuckle too but it does make you wonder though doesnt it?
A pointless exercise. Past experience proves the most improbable contenders have won. And looking across the field, many leaders have been disasters (IDS, Hague, Clegg, Blair, Brown). It has also been said, and rightly, than being talked of a future leader is a poisoned chalice.
@Graeme
Blair a disaster? Perhaps in real terms, but in political terms, the most successful politician of his generation, easy.
The Tories tried to make Cameron the heir to Blair, but he's just can't reach the voters in the same way, no matter how much he tries to 'fake it'. Osbourne is less likely to pull in the urban population. The Tory party will likely go for a leader with Middle Class routes. Its all very cynical stuff these days.
sorry my spelling is awful ^
David Davis has marooned himself on the back benches. It's his own fault. But for that daft by election stunt, he would now be Home Secretary.
David Cameron PM is our hero and he not going anywhere soon! Therefore who succeeds David Cameron as Tory Leader is not important! I say... Boris Johnson would be the perfect man for the job.
Talking about Boris, I have been doing 'the Boris Johnson Jig':
"Change the light bulb,
change the light bulb,
start the motorbike,
start the motorbike,"
Also after a few 'sniffereds' I have been teaching my friends at my social club to 'shake [their] funky stuff [for London]!
Jeremy Hunt, how can anyone take him seriously, he's incredibly lightweight and his head bobs like a puppet when he speaks.
Ben Howlett will be the next leader, he is due to win the Conservative Future elections and then will be an MP in 2015 elections, 2020 he will be PM. Amazing candidate, trust me.
It's really odd that this comes out now. I think Cameron will be safe for the foreseeable future, he'll bobble along espousing the virtues of coalition and demonising the centre-left for the mess we are in (typical Tory line). Then about the time of the AV referendum and the Scottish/Welsh devolved elections the honeymoon will vanish and he'll be in big trouble.
I think if Cameron is ousted, it will be for not responding strong enough to Lib-Dem attacks at each of those votes. The Tories will be unnerved by the likely outcomes and demand a tough response (again typical Tories) and then if he fails he'll be gone by 2012. I can imagine the reaction to the image of Mr Clegg being interim PM being one of fury in the Tory right and if Johnson is not available then it'll be Osbourne or Gove. Which would most likely spook the Lib-Dems into running from the new Thatcherites. Then again he may last 5 years and be too badly damaged by rumours of revolts like Brown that he slips off into obscurity after Labour wins election
^^ Note; The Tories and Lib-Dems in both Scotland and Wales are not in any form of pact and in Scotland especially are looking down the abyss. Both are at real risk, something Labour can take advantage of more than the SNP who are still attacking Labour about cuts more than anyone else.
Jeremy Hunt? You've got to be kidding me. I think about 80% of Tory MPs are in possession of greater leadership qualities. His unnerving rapid blinking surpasses even Ed Balls levels.
The next Tory leader is probably not a cabinet minister at present. If I was into betting I'd put money on a current junior minister, someone like Justine Greening, perhaps.
Post new comment