Welcome to the New Statesman website. Please sign in or register to participate in the conversation.

Harman and Cameron clash on explosive issue of cancer care

Stand-in leader accuses PM of “dodging” questions over rights to see a specialist in two weeks.

From the House of Commons

The explosive issue of cancer care dominated Prime Minister's Questions today, with Harriet Harman asking about the government's white paper on the NHS, published this week, and focusing on the question of whether patients will keep their right to see a cancer specialist within two weeks.

David Cameron claimed that, after 13 years of Labour government, we have "not the best" cancer treatment results in Europe.

Harman claimed that the Prime Minister was "dodging the question". In reply, Cameron asked Harman if it was now Labour policy to cut spending on the NHS, at which point John Bercow, the Speaker, intervened to remark that it was for the leader of the opposition to ask questions, not answer them.

The heated exchanges followed an initial sombre question from Harman about the Northern Ireland riots. Cameron praised the "restraint" of the police forces.

Later, there were several mentions from the Tories of Peter Mandelson's memoirs, but again the Speaker intervened, ruling that this was not "government business".

At the end of the session, referring to the Labour front bench, Cameron said: "We have a new problem in British politics: it's called 'deficit deniers' and I'm looking at a whole row of them."

Subscription offer: Get 12 issues for just £12 PLUS a free copy of "The Idea of Justice" by Amartya Sen.

1 comment

Richard's picture

I have not heard one Labour MP or party member deny there is a deficit.

The dividing line is how much and how fast to reduce it.

The 12bn increase of the structural deficit comes from the now questioned independent OBR reducing the growth forcast (Twice). This due entirely to the circumstances that prevailed aftr the election ie soveriegn dept crisis.
The coalition have been well drilled and have rehearsed the mantra like responses to difficult questions but they ring hollow if they repeat them in the face of the truth.
The "there is no money left" jibe also has lost its potency especially since the person who broke the confidence (the humourless D Laws) is no longer with us.
Maybe the next time MP's complain about being delayed expenses IPSA should remind them there is no money left and lets see how long they are prepared to accept it.

Post new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Latest tweets