Race to the Labour leadership: here’s a little idea
What about seeing how the pretenders do against Cameron on the floor of the Commons?
By James Macintyre Published 13 June 2010 18:28The many hustings that are taking place for the Labour leadership contenders provide excellent arenas for the party and those associated with it to see how the candidates perform, and, more importantly, what they stand for. But there is another test for whoever would be opposition leader: how, and how well, they take on the government. So here's a little idea, probably no more than a bit of Sunday-evening fun.
There are, I think, seven sessons of Prime Minister's Questions between now and the summer recess. There are five contenders for the Labour leadership. Why not allow Harriet Harman, the acting leader, to take this week's and the last before parliament rises, and have each of the five stand in against David Cameron in between now and then?
The only danger is that Cameron would deliberately allow weaker candidates to do better, as what we journalists call a kind of "reverse-spin". As Alastair Campbell's diaries confirm, he and Tony Blair deliberately put it about that it was Michael Portillo they feared for the Tory leadership, when in fact it was Kenneth Clarke. So, you could see Cameron apparently being knocked for six by Diane Abbott. Then again, he probably won't want to be seen to be bested. Anyway, just a thought.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Jobs
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists

















7 comments
Dear James, you seem to be unnaturally fixated by this Cameron chap. He isnt even the Governments star performer at the dispatch box, so why bother?
Still, am visualising Dianne Abbott taking him to the cleaners...
looking at old videos of Denis skinner would be better
Great idea. 6 questions a week at PMQ's. 5 candidates and one for the pot, Hariett's.
Cameron could do a double bluff, or even a double double bluff. Are you thinking what we're thinking.
Great idea!
David Cameron could be Simon Cowell, Liam Fox as Louis Walsh, Louise Bagshawe as Cheryl Cole and Theresa May as Dannii Minogue.
The Westminster X Factor!
Lame idea
id deeply enjoy that, hilarious idea! abbott and burnham against cammy cam, the others, a bit more dull. but that would be brilliant!
A bit of fun, but I am not interested in a performer. Blair was great in that game but, you know what, people got sick of him, and his own performance grew into the megalomaniac fantasies that led to Iraq. I am not sure any of the candidates are any good but the best would be the most honest, and the least likely to "perform".
Post new comment