Hopes dashed as progressive alliance is buried for another generation
Labour MPs show that they are not fit for office. But Tory troubles do not end here.
By James Macintyre Published 11 May 2010 18:45
This comes from the scrum outside parliament, where the media have gathered to witness the end of the Labour government and the crowning of the media-friendly Tory leader, David Cameron.
I have already expressed my views about the Labour MPs who helped that process by publicly choosing opposition and what they perceive to be their own interests over those of the country.
"We want to keep our seats," one says. As a result of that, and the willingness of the Lib Dems to prop up a Tory government diametrically opposed to its core values (a willingness I am the first to admit I badly underestimated), the dream of a reunification of the Labour and Liberal movements lies in tatters.
Instead, Labour will enter opposition and a leadership contest that is for another day.
However, with major divisions in all three parties brought about by this extraordinary election, Cameron's leadership should not celebrate too hard yet. I just bumped into a senior Eurosceptic Tory MP who is opposed to a coalition and told me he had just told Cameron as much. He also expressed deep concerns about how the two parties could agree on Europe. Indeed.
Well, that and many other things are their shared problems now.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Jobs
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists

















62 comments
@Beak. I am sick and tired of people blaming all of the current economic situation on either Gordon Brown or the Labour Party.
Sorry but is the current economic situation a Global one or not? Is Britain the only country with a large debt or economic problems?
I know! Lets all be like Beak and get macho and stuff about cuts!
Forget that the UK owns over $200 billion in US debt that should be sold.
People are going to die because of the coming cuts. Beak, I hope a member of your family is not one of them.
the libdems have always been tories disguised as comedians.
Well, well, well, I trust "Beak2 refers to his teaching job at Eton? If it isn't impolite, may I just point out that we live in a class-ridden society, with the highest level of inequality in Western Europe?
Hazel, in the light of Lib Dem actions, and the lack of support for either the Green party or any left alternative, I suggest that we do something to change the Labour Party, rather than just carping about its many failures.
Labour, for all its dirty policies over the last 13 years, is the only party on the left of our political spectrum with consistent support from organised labour. It is also a party that has reinvented itself more than once over the years, and can do again.
As a matter of urgency we need to organise to defend our people from the hideous effects the coming savage cuts will have. Without Labour, all hope of defence is stillborn.
As the economic orthodoxy of the last 30 years has been destroyed by events, it is possible to build a viable alternative. Those New Labour free-marketeers are now intellectually a busted flush.
We can bring Labour back to its libertarian and egalitarian traditions,and it seems to me that these are more relevant today than ever.
"@Beak. I am sick and tired of people blaming all of the current economic situation on either Gordon Brown or the Labour Party. economic problems?"
Is that right Jeremiah? Everyone knows there has been a global recession but Britain should have been best placed to handle it. Brown promised he had put an end to boom and bust and oversaw a period of economic growth that he was quite happy to take the credit for. But guess what? Despite all this, he spent and spent money he simply didn't have. We were the first in recession and the last out. We have one of the biggest deficits when we should have one of the smallest. Prudence? What a complete joke. He ran up the credit card knowing full well he didn't have the money to pay it back.
You go on to talks about "macho cuts" It wouldn't have mattered who won the election these cuts were coming. Even Gordon "Tory cuts v Labour investment" Brown would have had to do it. No one is going to enjoy the cuts but they are needed thanks to the wasteful years of Brown propping up the public sector and false economy.
For you to suggest Brown can not shoulder any of the blame is laughable. Their poor result in the election confimed that the public didn't believe him either.
@Beak. I am not saying that Brown or Labour are not in any way responsible for the situation.
The neo-liberal economic policies pursued by every Government since 1976 are to blame.
You should be aware that the UK's overeliance on financial services made it more exposed to the economic situation than other states.
Of course there has to be cuts! But what cuts and where? Should we dump Trident - £100 billion over several years, sell our US foreign debt -over $200 billion.
Or sack thousands of teachers and nurses?
Hi James. Nice article.
So can you tell Mehdi Hasan to stop ranting and raving that the Lib Dems "sold out"?
If Labour sunk the alliance talks, the Lib Dems had no other option. A Tory minority government would've led to a second election and a Tory majority government.
It has already been noted on the government website that ID cards are for the chop. First step in the restoration of civil liberties.
The state of the world at the moment trident is critical to our defence. Scrapping it would be folly. Start the cuts with the non jobs that should never have been created in the first place . It will be tough but unavoidable.
Not 'progressive alliance' it would just be a left alliance. No more no less
The problem with the 'dream of a reunification' is that it has always been the dream of the right of the Labour Party, the part that thirty years ago tried to achieve this end by forming the SDP. A coalition/partnership of Labour and Lib Dems would be used by the Lib Dems to try to take over or absorb the Labour Party, and in particular to break the relationship between the Labour Party and the Trade Union movement. It is not merely MPs supposedly looking after their own interests who are suspicious of the Lib Dems and their long term aspiration to replace the Labour Party. For some of us, the Labour Party is the only one with a heart.
I too would have hugely preferred a Labour-Lib Dem government to a Tory-Lib Dem one. But I'm sorry,in the (often northern)cities where Lib Dems have run councils, they have shown themselves to be very far from the 'progressive' party you believe to be. When you say you "badly underestimated" their willingness to jump in to bed with the Tories, were you forgetting about Leeds, Birmingham etc. where they have done precisely that? Were you forgetting about Sheffield or Camden or Liverpool where Tories are persona non grata so the Lib Dems generally default to a "Tory" role? A huge number of truly progressive people already knew this (which is why the great Lib Dem "surge" didn't hold): perhaps you have been too stuck in the Westminster village to see (& understand) what actually goes on out there on the ground?
Labour is still only marginally less radioactive than Chernobyl – who’d want to join a coalition with a party that includes two of the biggest thugs on the planet: John Reed and David Blunket [of ID card fame]. But why the surprise - it’s all entirely in character and utterly predictable, especially these two wreckers because neither are interested in progressive politics; far from it - both are Blair ex Home Secretary’s and regressive to the core. Far from saving the Labour party, it’s people like these who are going to consign it to oblivion. Shame about everybody else.
James I don't know what you've been smoking but the Lab-Lib coalition was a fantasy pursued by people who didn't appreciate that it stood zero chance of governing properly.
The idea that it would have been an effective progressive is a joke.
Labour lost the election by losing its overall majority and moving into second place, and clinging onto office by the most contrived coalition ever would be almost anti-democratic. The Labour MPs you talk of recognise this, and that is why they wish to recoup and recover in opposition.
What is it with all this "progressive" stuff?
You mean left-wing when you say that.
In my eyes that is certainly not progressive. More like regressive.
emilia is spot on here. the LibDem campaign in my area was along the lines of 'tories can't win here, vote lib dem' endearing itself itself to any centre-right people in the area. a lib-lab coalition would alienate these voters.
beak is right in saying it wouldn't be a progressive alliance, but it definitely wouldn't be a left alliance.
it wouldn't really be anything but a compromise. which is exactly what the lib-con alliance will be.
can it last?
It is the perfect time to regroup.
For Mr Clegg and his party to enter into any coalition absent reform of the means by which Parliamentary members are elected is shocking in its denial of principles.
The hard truth is that Britain does not have a true democracy – and it never shall have until every vote is equal. As long as Labour and the Conservatives practice the politics of privilege and entitlement, no democratic reform will occur – and the delusion of same will endure.
From over here in the U.S., one wonders where is the leader of principle when he is needed? as David Owen demonstrated in the turmoil that followed Labour’s lunacy under Michael Foot.
All that’s happened across the pond this election is fascinating, but it is the fascination that comes when a great nation loses its way amid the clamoring masses, when it votes for the moment and not the future.
George Mitrovich
San Diego
The Lib Dems will pay dearly for sitting in a Conservative Government.
Lib Dem MPs particularly those in Lib Dems / Tory marginals rely on Labour voters to vote for them.
Those voters did not vote Lib Dem last Thursday to have Cameron as PM.
However long this parliament lasts and however successful this Government is the Lib Dems will suffer at the ballot box.
They should suffer for foisting these odious tories on us!
@jeremiah - you are absolutely right. The Lib Dems will, I hope, pay the price they deserve. I am completely disgusted.
Well said Graeme, well said!
This looks like political suicide for the LibDems. I cannot see the alliance lasting - what's the betting there'll be another general election within the year.
The dream ticket mentioned above is the dream of the right - part of the ruling elite. PR could see the opening up of a real resurgence of the left in British politics. It's a long time over due.
I hope the Lib Dems get what they deserve - political self-destruction. They are an insult to all those people who voted for them as an alternative to the two main parties, and the Tories.
The Labour Party will come back stronger - We'll keep the red flag flying here!
definitely political suicide.
lib dems have capitalised (in terms of votes) on marginal seats this election but still not prevailed.
i'm certainly hoping for a resurgence of the left.
clement attlee anyone?
At the end of the day you have to hope that Cameron and Clegg do work this out and make a success of it, for that would be to the good of the country. I can't see how but that's my absurd hope because I'm idealistic and want to see this country get back on its feet in the way Gordon had started to head us. Gordon left with dignity and we as a party need to lick our wounds, regroup and come back to fight another day. It's a sign of the times that all three parties have come from left to centre and right to centre, it's a more middle ground centreland than ever before. That's good in a democracy even though I never thought the Tories would join with the Liberals, a most unlikely alliance but one that we must accept has been formed. It's worrying beyond belief that Cameron seemingly has a clear mandate on wrecking our economy and creating mass unemployment with their plans on cost efficiency; people will pay the price and turn to a party they can believe in if we hold our dignity and fight the battle on constructive ground. The Tories have an immense battle with a not too wacking majority, especially once disgruntled backbenchers start showing their contempt for what has been agreed by two leaders who didn't consult their kind. The bigger problem will be the mayhem in by-elections caused by differing Liberal and Tory councils who have no local mandate and will never subscribe to the new face on this ill thought alliance. Traditional liberals will never trust their party when this double act falls apart. That's how we'll rebuild the seats and with a new leader, Milliband I feel is the one, people will regain the faith. We shouldn't oppose in obstinacy, the stakes are too high. Clegg and his merry (and not so merry) men will real in horror when the media hype this as a Cameron and Tory win, that will be too bitter a pill for them to swallow and slowly the marriage will turn to divorce. I say this but I hope I've got it wrong for all I care is that this Country doesn't go the way of Greece. Don't forget how we came second in this election when the media had us in third place! Right, now where's the Anadin?
Double Dip Recession Ahoy! Hey Nick Clegg! Pass the hemlock, would you?
jeremiah - you better get used to it
@beak. With a Tory Government i'm sure we will all get used to economic incompetence, mass unemployment, a double dip recession and increased inequality.
I don't know about you beak but i'm looking forward to it!
Mind you I suppose we've still got to wait and hear just what a 'progressive' coalition has in fact been formed, Cameron hardly had the welcome which I recall when Blair swept to power after 18 years on the dark side! Tonight I think the prize for most honourable goes to Gordon Brown, can't help but feel he walked away in disgust......knowing what we can expect as the newly weds go to bed reading their A to Z's on 'how to fix the economy'!
Compromise is always crucial in politics but we have something called "values". These are a little out of kilter with those sold by Clegg in his Spectator ad to tories and this difference in values between Clegg (but not all LDs)and us is the reason why Clegg chose to go with the tories, as he repeatedly sign-posted he would. Coalition, yes; compromise, yes; allaince yes, but not at any cost. WE did not go whoring after position without power.
THOSE WEEZELES OLD MAN STAW AND BLUNKET ARE TO BLAME . ITS STRAW AND BLUNKET YOU CAN THANK FOR GIVEING US A TORIE GOVENMENT . WHY DONT THOSE TRATORS F... OFF AN JOIN CAMRONS CONSERVITIVES , IM SURE HED GIVE THOSE TWO SCUM A CABNET SEAT .STRAW AND BLUKET ARE NO DIFFRENT TO LIKE UNION SCABS .
@karen. No you went whoring only for power. Oh and by the way prepare to pay the price of a beating in the marginals come the next election!
Blame me. I voted LibDem
gordon brown and new labour were a social and financial disaster from start to finish,what ever follows was of there making,tony blair only cared about what was going into his wallet and the rest of new labour were to busy watching porno films.
there all a bunch of war criminals.
@jeremiah
"With a Tory Government i'm sure we will all get used to economic incompetence, mass unemployment, a double dip recession and increased inequality."
Isn't that roughly what we've had the last few years? I think everyone's used to it already!
"I don't know about you beak but i'm looking forward to it!"
Do you live in this country???
Oh and congratulations to the new progressive coalition between David Cameroon and Nick Clegg!
Hey Beak! When unemployment hits over 3 Million, we have a Sterling crisis and a double dip recession you will be clamouring for the halcyon days of good old Gord!
Hey Greg! Yes I live in this country and I am looking forward to this coalition of public school cretins crashing and burning!
So we're told that the population voted for a hung parliament (how?) and that overwhelmingly want PR. Then there is outrage when FPTP produces a hung parliament and the negotiations that are part and parcel of PR.... and finally instead of the greater choice of political parties to vote for, we now have two instead of three.... the sooner we bring some ideology back into politics, the sooner we can put this madness back in the box. Roll on a left wing Lab/Green coalition government - values and philosophy matter!
Labour didn't want to deal with the Lib Dems. Therefore, Cameron was going to end up as PM anyway.
STRAW , ANDY WHO? AND IM ALWAYS AROUND WHEN THERES PARTY DECENT BLUNKET WILL BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR GIVEING US A TORIE GOVENMENT . STRAW , BLUNKET AND THE NO HOPER ANY WHY ? WELL TARGET THEIR SEATS AND VOTE CON TACTICALY IN THOSE SEATS IF WE HAVE TO TO GET THOSE TRATORS OUT THEY ARE SCUM.THEY JAMES ARE TO BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR A TORIE GOVENMENT AND NO GRAND PROGRESSIVE COALITION . PS AN ALSO A SECOND RATE SYESTEM OF pr CALLED THE ALTERNITIVE VOTE SYESTEM . IT MAINTAINS THE TWO PARTY SYESTEM JUST THE SAME ASK THE KIWIS LABOUR AND THE TORIES ARE STILL THE LARGEST PARTYS BYE FAR IN THAT COUNTRY .ITS A SECOND RATE pr SYESTEM CLEGGS SELLING TO THE PUBLIC JAMES.
james i hope the gardian is happy they dclared for the lib dems , your party dident did they james ? .
I'm old enough to remember tee shirts with the slogan, "don't blame me I voted Labour" How about, "don't blame me I'm one of the disenfranchised progressive majority" - not much of a ring to it. Perhaps just, "don't blame me the politicians stitched me up" with a nice black flag motif.
@ Greg. I deal day in and day out with helping victims of the GLOBAL recession we WERE recovering from. People who have been assisted positively by the effective anti-recessionary measures introduced by Labour. People have been able to effect financial recovery and remain in their homes unlike the awful Tory days of yesteryear. Labour has done a great deal of very positive work on welfare reform aimed at helping those in need. You seem to have a poor memory because it was the Tories who championed mass unemployment and now we are again in danger of seeing how Tory policy of 'cost efficiency' savings will force many front line decent hard working public servants back onto the dole with consequent rises in inflation forcing mortages back up. You congratulate this dubious duo; I hope for your sake you don't face the same perils that many will: belive me a change in fortune can happen to any of us a lot quicker than perhaps u'd care to think! Don't be smug at other people's expense and in any event I'd not put too much faith in Cameron and Clegg holding it together all that long, they are a mismatch made in hell! And you may care to remember that when it comes to recession the Tories fared none to well or does your memory not stretch back that far?
Do women still constitute 52% of the population? Where are they?
good to see tories and lib dems close to each other . lets hope it is forever.the only progressive party is the labour party .
After this I honestly can't see how the Liberal Democrats can possibly recover.
They are now an appendage to the Conservative Party.
In the next election people will just wonder, what is the point in voting Lib Dem when they could just vote Tory and be done with it.
In seats where they face Tories it'll be seen as irrelevant to vote Lib Dem when they have spent the last parliament in their Government.
In seats were they face Labour they will be seen as sell-outs and a quasi-faction of the Tory Party.
I can honestly see them splitting and the more right-wing members joining the Conservatives and the SDP faction joining Labour or going off on there own.
This coalition is good for Labour.
This is a disaster for them.
P.S:- I agree with many posters here, we need to regroup, refocus and refresh the party. Select a strong leader, i'm leaning towards David Milliband personally but i'll wait till the contest before deciding.
I should add this, this coalition will fall apart sooner or later and when it does Labour will be ready.
We didn't sell out.
The Liberal Democrats are a disgrace.
P.P.S:- That was from me, I was entering my email address.
Clegg and the Liberals should know that a political tightrope frequently gets tangled into a NOOSE. Then, suddenly back to a tight rope- a very tight rope.
We WILL remember.
Just wait until PMQ's.
Thats when the real damage will start to be done, when people see our new Deputy PM sitting next to Cameron and the Tories howling at Labour.
Imagine what their voters will think watching those clips on the news.
Show your style and charm,The popular is what you want, right?
girl , Juniors , Accessories ,
Style Expert: ===== http://www.ongoin.com =====
We’re always mindful of fashion that’s in it for the long haul – those pieces you grab and go without fail every time, that, like a good friend, just couldn’t be more reliable.
Though a trendy handbag is a fun choice for, say, an evening out, an everyday bag that meets your everyday needs is a wardrobe must.
We’re eyeing neutral bags that move from month to month with ease, that suit every possibility with style and that make your life much easier with a host of functional details.
Check them out:===== http://www.ongoin.com =====
“ Echocardiography action ” FREE sHIPPING!!!(^.^)
sdfsdf
Jeremiah seems to forget that that is where hisste Gord has taken us. Time to get to grips with this mess.
Post new comment