Email exposure: Kaminski and anti-Semitism

Time to set the record straight

Just when you think the uproar over the Conservative Party's relationship with Michal Kaminski has fizzled out, it is set alight again by claims from the Tory-supporting right.

Into my inbox today came a press release from Total Politics, the outfit funded by the controversial Tory fundraiser Michael Ashcroft, advertising an interview by the Tory candidate Iain Dale with Michal Kaminski, chair of the new Conservatives and Reformists group in the European Parliament, which includes the 24 Tory MEPs.

Referring to a story I wrote, which I see is reproduced here by the European Jewish Congress, which provided some of the quotes, the release says Kaminski "accuses the New Statesman of shoddy journalism over its recent story attributing comments to Rabbi Schudrich [Chief Rabbi of Poland], which he says he never made",

In the interview itself, Kaminski says that the chief rabbi "has nothing against me and does not regard me as an anti-Semite".

So, did I make up the quotation? It is time to reproduce the email in full:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

From: Michael Schudrich [mailto:xxxx]
Sent: 27 July 2009 18:21
To: James Macintyre
Subject: Re: Quote request

 

Dear James,

 

I do not comment on political decisions. However, it is clear that Mr Kaminski was a member of NOP, a group that is openly far right and neo-nazi. Anyone who would want to align himself with a person who was an active member of NOP and the Committee to Defend the Good Name of Jedwabne (which was established to deny historical facts of the massacre at Jedwabne) needs to understand with what and by whom he is being represented.

 

Michael Schudrich

 

While we're at it, here is the email from Rabbi Marcus, one of London's most influential rabbis:

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

From: Rabbi Marcus [xxxx]
Sent: 28 July 2009 15:43
To: James Macintyre
Subject: RE: Quote request

 

Dear James,

I would be happy to say the following-

Any politician of any political party should have the moral courage to clearly distance themselves from those who espouse and promote anti Semitism, racism or any attitude that fosters intolerance.

Regards,

Rabbi Marcus.

Here, finally, is the quotation from the European Jewish Congress:

We remain extremely vigilant. We have communicated [our concerns about] this to the president of the EPP [Wilfried Martens] and the new elected parliament president [Jerzy Buzek, the former Polish prime minister].

We know [politicians such as Kaminski] to make racist comments even in parliamentary gatherings. We are alarmed at the fact that they are given a venue to be outspoken. I would call on the British Jewish community to contact David Cameron over this.

It should be noted meanwhile that, in an interview with the Jewish Chronicle today, Kaminski "stands by" his attack on Poland's apology over the 1941 Jewish massacre at Jedwabne.

Now, I know the Conservative Party's press officers have been doing all they can to persuade Jewish leaders to retract their statements. I know at least one Tory press officer has been attempting dishonestly to smear me personally as a result of this story: a seperate tale for another time. And I know Daniel Hannan, the Tory MEP, has been pretending the Jewish statements only come from "Labour". But, given these emails above, can we now just accept that the quotes speak for themselves?

 

15 comments

Aidan Snee's picture

You may recall we spoke yesterday at the cambridge union, and true to my word I have read the emails above which you recommended. You seemed to suggest that the Rabbi of Poland had percifically said that Michael Kaminski was himself a racist, the truth is that a organisation he belonged to in his youth was unfortunatly hijacked many years after he left and that is what the Rabbi was refering to. Mr Kaminski was described by the said Rabbi as a friend of isreals. If you wish to respond to my comment i would very much appreciated as with anyone else who wishes to query what i say. aidans34@yahoo.co.uk

mark gardner's picture

Still no sign of this email that the Polish Chief Rabbi sent New Statesman - I am sure that if the email did not exist, the New Statesman would have trumpeted it by now as 'Tory Lie!!'.

No such trumpeting however - so, why no sign of the email from NS? Could it be that the email actually supports the Tory interpretation of it? That's where the smart money would be.

explodingbadger1's picture

@Mark Gardner

If you read the article you can see Michael Schudrichs email. You know he IS the chief rabbi ?

The smart money wouldn't be anywhere near you mate.

unseen's picture

In the Dale interview, he says:

"Rabbi Schudrich made a statement about the allegations in this magazine. He sent them a statement and they ignored it."

Has the NS received any further communication from the Rabbi and have you printed it?

Hercules Grytpype-Thynne's picture

Mr Gardner,
I note that your name is identical to that of the Director of Communications at the Community Security Trust.
Are you by any chance related?

davidt.harryblog's picture

Hang on - I thought that the New Statesman admired genocidal antisemites?

Wasn't that the gist of the Ken Livingstone interview with Meshaal?

Please get your line straight, thanks.

tim's picture

The Conservatives should stop this attempt to defend Michal Kaminski and their support for him in Europe. His views are well known and documented. Smearing those who report on it is not a defence and is doing greater damage to them, than admitting they are wrong.

Trying to hide what Kaminski stands for just raises questions as to why they are going to such lenghts to discredit well sourced and documented evidence

Ben's picture

So, you have three quotes to 'support' you.

The first dodges the point - Kaminsky WAS a member of a group that IS anti-semitic - but the point is that he was a member in the past, when it is claimed it was not anti-semitic.

The second is a carefully worded 'no comment' that makes no mention of Kaminski at all.

And you've edited the third one so we don't know if it supports you or not.

You really are going to have to try harder than this. You might even be right - but this contains no evidence either way. I

mark gardner's picture

I apologise, I should have been far more explicit:

I did not mean the email that's in the above article - I meant the other email, or whatever other communication it is, that we are informed Rabbi Schudrich sent to NS saying he had been misrepresented.

This is how James McIntyre references it in the above article:

"accuses the New Statesman of shoddy journalism over its recent story attributing comments to Rabbi Schudrich [Chief Rabbi of Poland], which he says he never made",

Where is this communication in which Rabbi Schudrich says "he never made" (or similar)??

Presumably it does exist: or is that there is nothing in writing?

Jack's picture

Come on James, you are making yourself look a fool and a servile government attack dog. Partisan rubbish.

Mookie Blaylock's picture

If these emails are true, Rabbi Schudrich should go public and apologize to Kaminski who bears no responsibility for skinheads that invaded NOP sometime in early 90ies. Between 85 and 87 that party could not be openly this or openly that because no political party could function openly period.

Rabbi Schudrich line on Jedwabne reads like another smear by association. Kaminski made a point, seemingly controversial to the left, about the nature of collective guilt in such cases. But where exactly does he "deny historical facts of the massacre"? The line about Kaminski being involved with some committee and that committee being establised to deny facts, etc., is subjective and too tenuous anyway. Anybody can be accused of anything that way. Also, Kaminski couldn`t not get involved with Jedwabne residents when the affair broke - he was their MP at the time.This was not like Obama and rev. Wright.

Avi Rosenberg's picture

I’d be more easily convinced of Michał Kamiński’s innocence if he didn’t look like Herman Göring’s lovechild.

jagged's picture

Come on, Ian Dale has the email - so do you. Put it up and let the readers decide for themselves what happened.

derrinzikks's picture

Obviously he's a rotter.

But so is the leader of Hamas, and you can't even claim political expediency for printing a soft interview with him the other month:

http://www.newstatesman.com/middle-east/2009/09/israel-palestinian-hamas

Consistency much?

missy's picture

Do you write stories about anything other than yourself these days james?

Latest tweets