Return to: Home | Blogs | Public Accounts

The Tories make their choice

Fascism over moderation in Europe

So now we know for sure. The Conservative Party of David Cameron and William Hague is willing to expel a moderate MEP, Edward McMillan-Scott, for speaking out against the leader of the Tories' new group in Europe, a leader whose past is seen as so anti-Semitic that leading Jewish rabbis from around Europe have expressed grave concern.

We knew that Hague had defended Michal Kaminski at a meeting of the International Institute for Strategic Studies. We knew that the Tory blogosphere and Conservative commentators had -- as one voice -- leapt to Kaminski's defence at the earliest possible opportunity. We knew that the Yorkshire Post had come under pressure from Conservative Party officials to allow Kaminski space in the paper to respond to McMillan-Scott's objections. (I even knew that both Daniel Hannan, the NHS-hating Cameron ally, and other so-far-unnamed officials at Tory Central Office -- I will return to this on some other occasion -- sought to smear me after I helped break the Kaminski story.)

But expulsion? Not even the most openly racist Tory MPs have faced that. And for unpatriotically blasting our health service on US television, Hannan was awarded a legal affairs job in Europe by the party leadership.

As the Foreign Secretary, David Miliband, has said, this is the true face of Cameron's Tories. "Mr McMillan-Scott has been expelled for standing up against the new far-right conservative extremists and their associates in the European Parliament."

So, the question remains: why are the Conservatives so desperate to silence McMillan-Scott and Kaminski's critics, while turning a blind eye to backbench racists and promoting right-wing cranks?

 

 

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

7 comments from readers

Veritas
17 September 2009 at 13:08

The fact is that McMillan-Scott wasn't expelled for his views but for his disloyalty to the Conservative Party. It was, in short, a disciplinary matter. He was determined that he wanted to continue as a Vice President of the Parliament come Hell or High Water and ignored the fact that the ECR Group had been formed on the basis of an agreement that Michal Kaminski would be the group's nominee for the VP position and the leadership would go to a Briton. Even worse, McMillan-Scott, along with all the other Conservative Candidates had signed a pledge prior to his Election, to support the new fledgling ECR Grouping - instead he tried his utmost to drive a coach and horses through it!

Veritas
17 September 2009 at 13:08

The fact is that McMillan-Scott wasn't expelled for his views but for his disloyalty to the Conservative Party. It was, in short, a disciplinary matter. He was determined that he wanted to continue as a Vice President of the Parliament come Hell or High Water and ignored the fact that the ECR Group had been formed on the basis of an agreement that Michal Kaminski would be the group's nominee for the VP position and the leadership would go to a Briton. Even worse, McMillan-Scott, along with all the other Conservative Candidates had signed a pledge prior to his Election, to support the new fledgling ECR Grouping - instead he tried his utmost to drive a coach and horses through it!

Roger Helmer MEP
17 September 2009 at 13:27

Kaminski is so "anti-semitic" that a couple of weeks ago he was invited to Tel Aviv by the Israeli government and lionised by the Israeli Foreign Ministry. Wake up, James. Don't you recognise an anti-eurosceptic smear campaign even when it bites your ankle?

Mehdi Hasan
17 September 2009 at 14:11

Roger,

Thanks for your comment on the NS Free Speech blogs. But to pretend that being pro-Israeli means you are automatically pro-Jewish or that support for Israel inoculates you from accusations of anti-Semitism is absurd. Have you seen the BNP website recently? It's very pro-Israeli. Next you'll be suggesting Griffin is a philo-Semite and inviting him to join your grouping of loons and nutters in the European Parliament.


17 September 2009 at 14:19

Mr Kaminski is on record as a strong supporter of the Lisbon Treaty. The UK Conservatives fought the last European election denouncing the Lisbon Treaty .

How curious then that all of them (with the honourable exception of Mr Macmillan-Scott) should be so happy to have Mr Kamiski as the leader of their political group in the European Parliament.

Andrew Smith
17 September 2009 at 17:09

The main fault of MacMillan-Scott was to keep the EU issue alive in British politics while the Tory leadership is desperate to keep it silent. Anti-semitism is a poor relation to the anti-democracy which is the EU and all who support it, such as David Cameron and his party.

Andrew Smith
17 September 2009 at 17:10

The main fault of MacMillan-Scott was to keep the EU issue alive in British politics while the Tory leadership is desperate to keep it silent. Anti-semitism is a poor relation to the anti-democracy which is the EU and all who support it, such as David Cameron and his party.

Post your comment

(Your email address will not be published)

Recent Posts

Clegg wins PMQs

25 November 2009 12:48

Tackling domestic violence against women and girls

25 November 2009 07:39

The New Israel Fund

24 November 2009 18:11

Thought for the day

24 November 2009 12:00

Chilcot inquiry: who benefits?

24 November 2009 11:11

Iraq inquiry: when did UK sign up for regime change?

23 November 2009 15:59

Past Entries

Follow this blog

Newsletter

Enter your email address here to receive updates from the team

Vote!

Will the Iraq inquiry be a 'whitewash'?

Suggest a question

View comments

© New Statesman 1913 - 2009

Tracker