Star Spangled Staggers

US politics from outside the beltway

Syndicate contentRSS

Fox buries story of Romney dismissing nearly half of American voters

CNN and MSNBC found it newsworthy, so why didn't Fox?

Fox News

When video of Mitt Romney dismissing 47 percent of American voters surfaced this afternoon, many media outlets found the surprising video newsworthy. Fox News, however, buried the remarks until forced to cover Romney's follow-up press conference late in the evening.

Today at 4pm EDT, Mother Jones released secretly-taped footage of the Republican presidential candidate speaking at a private fundraiser, where Romney declared to donors that his job is "not to worry about" the 47 percent of Americans who pay no income taxes, since they will "vote for the president no matter what." He described these voters as people who "believe they are victims" and believe they are entitled to "housing" and "food," among other things.

He said:

There are 47 percent of the people who will vote for the president no matter what. All right, there are 47 percent who are with him, who are dependent upon government, who believe that they are victims, who believe the government has a responsibility to care for them, who believe that they are entitled to health care, to food, to housing, to you-name-it. That that's an entitlement. And the government should give it to them. And they will vote for this president no matter what.

And I mean the president starts off with 48, 49 -- he starts off with a huge number. These are people who pay no income tax. Forty-seven percent of Americans pay no income tax. So our message of low taxes doesn't connect. So he'll be out there talking about tax cuts for the rich. I mean, that's what they sell every four years.

And so, my job is not to worry about those people. I'll never convince them they should take personal responsibility and care for their lives.

CNN found this newsworthy, as did MSNBC. Fox News, however, ignored the story from 4pm, when the video was released, until after 10 pm, when Romney addressed the video in a press conference.

Even then, in a segment during On the Record, Fox declined to show the actual footage of Romney at the fundraiser, or even quote from his statements. Instead, only Romney's press conference defending his remarks was aired.

This omission is in keeping with the network's apparent efforts to help elect Romney.

This post originally appeared on mediamatters.org and is reproduced here with their permission. Media Matters for America is a web-based, not-for-profit, 501(c)(3) progressive research and information center dedicated to comprehensively monitoring, analysing, and correcting conservative misinformation in the US media. You can find it on Twitter as @mmfa.

 

14 comments

John Cheese's picture

Ha, ha, two White House advance staffers now caught up the Columbian prostition scandal... any guess on how many of old media TV outfits will bury this? Barky's clueless interview on Letterman...so far, not a good week for him.

jankaas's picture

"Fox buries story of Romney..."

his own running mate Ryan has gone one better and buried Romney by calling him "inarticulate".

you could not make this shit up, the GOP failing 101 Politics in such hilarious fasion. whatever next?

Notbuyingit's picture

@Emily

Valid point miss, more importantly the question should be is there any truth to what Romney said at the same time your article highlights the claims coming from the right that paints you & the majority in the typical media as leftist propaganda masquerading as unbiased impartial & balanced reporting.

Left or right regardless of were any of us stand on the issues facing us, I believe political stands should be a whole lot clearer from either side.

John Cheese's picture

Now media selective story telling is important? Kind of late to the party, don't you think...

jankaas's picture

typical behaviour of the Lefty Liberal Media. Fox is again playing footsoldier to communists, socialists, fascists, and all other nasty-ists.
they should have done the right thing and denied there was anything to see, ever. they should have insisted it was all invented by the Muslim terrorist Hussein Obamalama and that Romney is God's True Chosen One.
(yes, the Christian God, not that funny Islamic one)

Joker's picture

Huh?

jankaas's picture

was taking the piss.....

Kreditanstalt's picture

You're inventing conspiracies where only disingenuity exists. But I suspect that much of the 47% do get their news from television...
Romney will do nothing to change the truth that he spoke. Neither will the incumbent, because both of them are necessarily focused on the short-term.

Ironically, this crisis is being portrayed as one of capitalism when in fact it is the social welfare state that is being proven unworkable. What is needed is DE-regulation: privatisation of expensive government services, elimination of most taxes and a host of petty regulations together with the abolition of central banking and fractional reserve lending.

Dark Heart of Toryland's picture

If you're so very keen on de-regulation, low taxes and the dismantling of government services, why don't you go and live somewhere which is largely free from the oppressive hand of government - such as Afghanistan, Somalia, Haiti or Yemen. I'm sure you'd be very happy.

Kreditanstalt's picture

I've heard that sort of reductio-ad-absurdum many, many times. But it still doesn't get the hands of the masses out of our pockets.

I have a better idea. The otherwise-odious Romney said, correctly, that many people are now reliant on government services, tax monies and regulations which are paid for by savers, wealth generators, investors and risk-takers. Instead, I ask, why don't they just pay for these themselves?

Then they wouldn't have to carry on with this silly class-warfare stuff...

jankaas's picture

"I ask, why don't they just pay for these themselves?"

which seems perhaps like a reasonable question. the problem is though that the only relevant answer is; "pay with what?"
what do you suggest Kreditanstalt?

Kreditanstalt's picture

That has to be solved by those wanting the services.

As it stands governments punish success. The discourage capital formation - saving. They punish profitmaking - "profiteering" - and extoll consumption, spending, borrowing and dependency. They rope entire populations into paying into collective, involuntary mass insurance schemes: public health insurance, monopoly government services of all kinds, national insurance, superannuation (in Australia). And the redistributive taxation system is nothing but theft-by-majority-rule.

On the other hand, social welfare systems make failure easy and breed an "I'm-a-victim"/"that villain has too much money" mentality.

Many have said that, although we are not far removed from a dog-eat-dog state of nature, we have the blessing of government to thank for that removal!

Not exactly: you have the blessing of funds obtained by majority diktat: the "violence inherent in the system."

I'm just saying that this is immoral and unethical. Everyone should be proud to have the liberty to try to stand on his own two feet - regardless of whether "someone has more" or "it's not fair"...

jankaas's picture

"That has to be solved by those wanting the services."

that's a total cop out. you have no idea either how to resolve the reality that many Americans are dirt poor and because of that unable to lift themselves out of poverty.

instead you ramble on about scroungers, thieves and loafers as if that truely captures what's going on with people trapped in poverty. most underwhelming Kredit.

John Cheese's picture

Katrina/New Orleans was a perfect example...Democratic stronghold for years- entitlements up the wazoo, yet, when the storm disaster hit, levee funds were gone- stolen, diverted, city powers were disorganized & general chaos broke out. The Dem Governor was useless & the Mayor known for "Chocolate City" had not a clue.
Helpless citizens. This should have been the most secure & organized city in the US- per Dem ideals & handout money. Fat chance... Contrast that with the actions of Repub Gov Barber & Mississippi.

Latest tweets