The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Clegg is still misleading voters over tuition fees

The Deputy PM is wrong to claim that there was "no money around" for the pledge.

Liberal Democrat leader Nick Clegg. Photograph: Getty Images.
Nick Clegg apologised for promising not to increase tuition fees in a televised broadcast last night. Photograph: Getty Images.

Nick Clegg's apology for breaking the Lib Dems' tuition fees pledge (or rather, for adopting it in the first place) was an attempt at candour, so it's unfortunate that he's still misleading voters over why it was abandoned. Clegg's explanation was that there was "no money around" but, to take only the most recent example, we learned yesterday that the banks paid out £13bn in bonuses last year. In some parts of the economy, at least, there is plenty of money around - the pledge could have been met through progressive taxation. In addition, even in these austere times, the government spent £693bn in 2011, a small fraction of which could have been used to freeze fees. It would be more honest to say that there was money around but the Lib Dems chose not to spend it on universities (we now know that they didn't even push for the pledge to be kept during the coalition negotiations).

What makes Clegg's statement even more disingenuous is that, in the short-term, the decision to raise tuition fees won't save the government any money. Indeed, for the reminder of this parliament at least, the reforms will cost it more, not less. The new fees only came into effect this year, which means repayments won't begin until 2015 for a three-year course. In the intervening period, the government will be forced to pay out huge amounts in maintenance loans and tuition-fee loans. Clegg wants you to believe that the decision to triple fees from £3,000 to £9,000 was a deficit reduction measure but, as the numbers show, it was nothing of the sort.

8 comments

Ophidian's picture

At least with the like of Cameron and Osborne and cronies you know we are gonna be cleaned out. However with the like of Clegg and Danny Alexander nothing is worse than saying something else but doing the same.

ged on's picture

Clegg and his party are currently polling at 8%, They are toast, come the election. Tories are scum and if you collude with them, then you are the same. I find it hilarious that he is being ridiculed, but I feel sorry for his kids.

Worldismad's picture

It has not worked! The grass roots have been calling for this in the vain hope it would help them. Too late and they are forgetting all the other extreme right policies they have nodded through. This hollow and certainly not meant apology is even more of a disaster for them. Even more councillors will have to give up their fat allowances and join the JSA merry go round. Many councillors pick up more than someone working full time on minimum wage.

Anonymous202's picture

Candour, surely.

kenelmist's picture

What a plonker.

Barrie J's picture

The man is a Tory.

Sid Cumberland's picture

What a perverse way of saying students are better of thanks to Lib Dem efforts!

Herbert's picture

It's just that they'll be a lot worse off when they stop being students. And more and more are realising that.

Latest tweets