The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Meet Miliband's new guru: Tim Soutphommasane

The young Australian shaping Labour's thinking on patriotism.

Australian writer and thinker Tim Soutphommasane.
Australian writer and thinker Tim Soutphommasane is emerging as an important influence on the Labour leadership. Sketch: Dan Murrell.

In tomorrow's New Statesman, I profile Tim Soutphommasane, the young Australian intellectual shaping the Labour leadership's thinking on patriotism. I interviewed Soutphommasane (pronounced Soot-pom-ma-sarn) in Wesminster in June after he addressed an intimate Commons seminar organised by Jon Cruddas and attended by several senior Labour figures, including David Miliband. A few days later, he met with Ed Miliband.

Soutphommasane's thesis, elaborated in his book Reclaiming Patriotism: Nation-Building for Australian Progressives, is that the left must promote a common national identity if it is first to win and then retain power. "One of the reasons why you need to have a cohesive, collective identity in any liberal democratic society is that you need to have a sense of fellow feeling in order to redistribute resources."  Since societies have become more diverse, he said, "You can't take it for granted that citizens will have an identity in common or will be willing to contribute to the common good, and so you have to work hard to ensure that people feel like they belong to a community."

Yet too often, for fear of appearing "racist" or "xenophobic", the left has vacated the field and allowed the right to define national identity in starkly conservative terms.  He told me:

There can be more than one kind of patriotism. For a lot of people, patriotism is, by definition, an exclusive and a very nasty sentiment, when there can in fact be a very appreciative and generous love of country, one in which you can criticise your own country when you think it’s in the wrong. That’s the kind of political community, I think, that the left should try and work towards – one that’s mature, one that’s reflective and one that’s more deliberative.

Still only 29, Soutphommasane, who is of Lao-Chinese descent, is currently a columnist for Australian paper the Age, a lecturer at Monash University (he holds a PhD from Oxford) and the author of two forthcoming books, The Virtuous Citizen: Patriotism in a Multicultural Society and Don't Go Back To Where You Came From: Why Multiculturalism Works. He has also served as an adviser to Australian foreign minister Bob Carr and believes that Labour has much to learn from the successes and failures of its Australian brethren. The Rudd-Gillard governments, he said, "have great achievements to their name – the apology to the indigenous people, the establishment of a carbon pricing scheme, the creation of the National Disability Insurance Scheme, a massive school-building programme – but they’ve lacked a nation-building story, they’ve lacked a nation-building project."

For Miliband and Labour, he argued, "the task of rebuilding and reshaping the British economy after the financial crisis and after austerity is something that could be a patriotic project". It is this insight that has excited Cruddas, who told me that Soutphommasane’s concept of "nation-building" could act as a "framing device" for the policy review he is leading. "Labour only successfully appeals when it actually owns an alternative national story based around what a country could be," he said. "And that’s why we invited Tim into our policy review. Through the idea of ‘rebuilding Britain’ you could counterpose a sense of national obligational duty to one of managed decline."

In the early months of the coalition government, David Cameron and George Osborne sought to couch austerity in patriotic terms, employing the wartime-like slogan "we're all in this together". But the government's reckless reform of the NHS ("the closest thing the English have to a religion," in the words of Nigel Lawson) and its abolition of the 50p tax rate, an important symbol of solidarity, have deprived it of any claim to be acting in the national interest. The path is now clear for Labour to present itself as the truly patriotic party. Under the rubric of "national reconstruction" (to use Soutphommasane’s phrase), Labour could champion policies such as a National Investment Bank, a school-building programme, and a "solidarity tax" on the wealthy.

The response to Danny Boyle's Olympics opening ceremony revealed an unfulfilled appetite for a patriotism of the left that dispenses with imperial nostalgia and offers a progressive vision of Britain's past and its future. With its representation of the suffragettes, the Jarrow marchers, Windrush immigrants, the NHS and the CND, the ceremony presented a people’s history of Britain that the left instinctively understood and applauded. Afterwards, Toby Young wrote that he felt as if he had just watched "a £27m party political broadcast for the Labour Party".

I asked Soutphommasane how Miliband’s party could harness a new wave of liberal patriotism. "Sometimes political parties can let these moments do the work for them," he said. "But the patriotic goodwill generated by the Olympics does provide an opportunity for Labour. It is almost as though Boyle has managed to pave the way for a new chapter of British nation-building."

In 1945, it was Clement Attlee's promise of a "new Jerusalem" that propelled him into Downing Street over the war lion Winston Churchill. Nearly seventy years later, a patriotic vow to "rebuild Britain" could do the same for Miliband.

Pick up this week's New Statesman, out tomorrow, to read the full profile of Tim Soutphommasane.

12 comments

treborc's picture

Come down to my home and discuss the facts of life, the Guru I suspect will be gone in a few months.

Cruddas soft left, well he's so soft he's a mate of Purnell the Progress right wing guru on welfare.

New labour is alive and well but now called Newer Labour

Margaret M Dunlop's picture

Patriotism, pride in being British is latent in England, Scotland, Wales and Ireland. This is a different situation from the position in Australia where almost everyone is from somewhere else and there are the indigenous people. Many of the commentators on the thinking of Soutphommesane do not seem to have picked up that for Jon Cruddas, these ideas are just a "framing device" for the project he is leading of trying to have his party elected.

Red Rain's picture

Why don't we just admit that the political doctrine of Multiculturalism has been a monumental monstrous failure? "National Investment Bank" I'm all for that... "A school-building programme" Didn't we try that? But we ended up with cold poorly performing Stalinist monstrosities and as for the "solidarity tax" on the wealthy. I haven't a clue what that's all about but it sounds catchy..

chasboz's picture

Attlee won not just because he repeated a slogan, but he also had policies to back up the slogan, Labour had meaning. New Labour had plenty of slogans born of plenty of marketing, but it was a party without any policies beyond those it had taken from Thatcherism, namely to hand as much of the state to private interests as possible. How can one be patriotic, feel any connection to something one does not own, one cannot control or even to quote Morrissey "Doesn't care if I lived or died"? Thus my Patriotism is to England, Socialism and Republicanism.

mike cobley's picture

@A.Cole - "The left cannot be patriotic about the UK as we are a wealthy, successful capitalist democracy..."

Seriously? I think what you meant to write was - "The right dont know the meaning of patriotism since the UK is just another failing democracy to plunder."

Yr welcome.

The Manual Bat's picture

Yet another pointless Meaningless Message Merchant?? I give up...

StephenKMackSD's picture

Beware the imported propagandist who will deliver the answer! Viewing this from the U.S. I'd say that New Labor and the New Democrats have a lot in common: they both deserted the traditions they came from, in order to attain power, and devil take that tradition. Tony Blair and Bill Clinton. They almost looked like the real thing. Power is everything, even if you are simply a Neo-liberal shadow pretending to be 'Left'. What is patriotism? A form of tribalism in all it's heedless, uncritical conformity? Or a commitment to the the spirit of law, exercised with a view to develop and encourage civic republican virtue in one's fellow citizens, by your actions and words? Or is that a hopelessly idealistic construction? Our connection as citizens is real, even if we deny that reality, with highly garnished chatter.

Red Shift's picture

But the boundaries of the nation are being eroded by communication technologies, migration, Euro centric administrations!

So it has to be explained why be patriotic towards Britain, rather than Ireland, or even Europe.

We are all Fragmented subjects with conflicting allegiances, even the well heeled attending county cricket matches and the British readers of Horse and Hound.

A. Cole's picture

I am sure Tim will be able to enlighten us on the benefits of multiculturalism...seeing how the Aborigines benefitted in Australia after having their way of life destroyed and their children taken into care!

The left cannot be patriotic about the UK as we are a wealthy, successful capitalist democracy.....and the left hate us for this!!!

dewithiel's picture

Pedants corner: as far as I know, the former premier of New South Wales Senator Bob Carr is still the Australian foreign minister; and you get a DPhil from Oxford, not a PhD.

Des Demona's picture

I thought that was the guy with the 7/11 store in The Simpsons?

Herbert's picture

Oh no, not another 'guru'. What exactly is it politicians do if they can't at least think for themselves?

'... he believes that Labour has much to learn from the successes and failures of its Australian brethren.' Odd that, as the Australians imagined they had much to learn from Blair's old pal McTernan.

'Presenters at Sydney's top-rating talkback station 2GB have accused Julia Gillard's chief spin doctor, John McTernan, of bullying and abusive language.'

Latest tweets