France also introduced a financial non-transactions tax last month

It's not just a 0.2 per cent Robin Hood tax which Hollande introduced.

French president Francois Hollande goes for a walk. Photograph: Getty Images
French president Francois Hollande goes for a walk. Photograph: Getty Images

France's recent deficit-busting raft of tax rises included a few measures specifically targeted at the financial markets. Not only was the country's Tobin tax implemented at double the expected rate, from 0.1 per cent of the value of financial transactions to 0.2 per cent, but a new tax specifically aimed at high-frequency trading was introduced.

The Tax Policy Center's Steven Rosenthal explains how it works:

The high frequency tax applies to traders that (1) use computer algorithms to determine the price, quantity, and timing of their orders (2) use a device to process these orders automatically, and (3) transmit, modify, or cancel their orders within half a second (the half a second has been set by draft administrative guidance). The high frequency tax is .01% on the amount of stock orders modified or cancelled that exceeds 80% of all orders transmitted in a month (under the draft administrative guidance). In effect, France now may tax orders that are not filled. It has created a “non-transaction” tax.

The move is interesting not just because it is the first time you can be taxed for not making a financial transaction, but also because it uses the tax system to achieve a goal which many would argue should be done through regulation or criminal legislation instead. The act of deliberately placing false orders in an attempt to manipulate the market is pretty clearly something which has no place in a healthy financial system, and yet the French authorities declined to attempt to ban the act.

Instead, they rendered it pointless by making it impossible to profit from. It's easier to enforce, harder to evade, and will make a bit of money for the government to boot. Seems win-win.

5 comments

Eddy S's picture

hollande doesn't have a clue. you only hear about crap high frequency algo trading systems, i.e. the one's without blockage strategies to prevent a widow maker situation.

algo trading is still new stuff and they will eventually get much better. traditional traders fear the phd mathematicians and try to spread silly rumours because they can see their job disappearing. however algo trading provides essential liquidity and good algo systems needs to have absolute blockage control.

hugh markey's picture

From virtual trading to slo-mo trading. Gee, what a hand brake turn! Talk about cleaning out the Augean Stables. Man, how those dung beetles needed exterminating.

It was SO easy! And Olympic year too!

Hercules

steve 3's picture

Superb move!

Newton's picture

High frequency trading so easily could have been made illegal. No. A corrupted government taxes pensioners, investors, consumers, jobs, business and the economy with FTT.

The bank tax that does not tax banks. But it's what the people were told they wanted.

Banks now have total control over market making activity in shares now that their competition has been eliminated. Investors can expect to be gouged by banks on each shares transaction. Banks are exempt from the tax on shares.

Scurra's picture

One of those simple and obvious solutions that I really hope works out.

Latest tweets