Refugees are being driven to despair in Calais
With so many still suffering on our doorstep, what's the point of World Refugee Day?
By Rebecca Omonira-Oyekanmi Published 22 June 2012 8:57
An Iraqi Kurd peeps out from under a pile of blankets on a wet pavement in Calais. “OK you journalist,” he says sleepily. “Tell me where are the human rights in Europe? There is nothing. It’s all a lie.” Suddenly he is awake, arms waving, shouting angrily about the policeman who kicked him awake at 6am and asked to see his papers (the same one who arrested him the day before, and the week before that: “he sees me every day”), and the people who spit at him in the streets.
Other homeless asylum seekers and migrants nod in agreement, and confirm his story. The police in Calais operate a policy of daily harassment; they target the dishevelled, dark-skinned migrants wandering the streets in the small port town. The police destroy the meagre tents they build, chase them out of derelict squats where they seek shelter, and despite seeing them every day constantly harass them for identification papers. These papers are usually official letters from the French government ordering them to leave France, or ID to show they have entered the asylum process. Regardless of what the paper says, they all are treated the same by the police; like criminals.
They can have no peace here, says Celine Dallery, a local nurse. “It is written on their heads – immigrant. They are judged. The police arrest them because they use the squats, but they have nowhere else to live.”
This is why the fanfare around World Refugee Day rings hollow. Yes, it is important to celebrate the accomplishments of host countries that provide protection and the refugees who build new lives; but what does it all mean if we still degrade others seeking asylum?
Where are the human rights in Europe? Shortly after the Second World War, all of Europe promised 'never again'. The opening preamble to the European Convention on Human Rights was drawn up to reaffirm the continent’s “profound belief in those fundamental freedoms which are the foundation of justice and peace in the world … best maintained … by a common understanding and observance of the human rights upon which they depend.”
So why, little more than 60 years after Europe promised, are refugees being racially abused in Greece, living in destitution in Italy, assaulted by the police in France and imprisoned in the UK? The European Union’s common asylum and immigration system espouses the importance of humanitarian protection, but its member states systematically flout the rules. In Calais the tragic consequences of Europe’s flagrant disregard for the rights of those seeking sanctuary on its shores are played out.
The one hundred-odd asylum seekers gathered in the unassuming port town have tales of horror from across Europe; one spoke of destitution in Italy, another of violent attacks in Greece, prolonged imprisonment in Hungary, and deportation back to warzones by the British. They are from Eritrea, Sudan, Afghanistan, Iraq, Iran, Syria, Libya and Egypt. As they said over and over, “You already know about my country”. In other words, they are refugees.
25-year-old Manjit Singh says he is stopped by the French police two or three times a day. He bitterly regrets selling his farm in Bangladesh to find work in the UK. Since leaving home, apart from a brief spell working at a convenience store in Birmingham, he has either been destitute or locked up in prison or immigration centres in Slovakia, Austria and England. “I don’t want to spend my life here. Nobody likes to sleep on the streets. Sometimes I feel angry. I made a mistake, I sold my land, I don’t like life in Europe. People talk about human rights but there is nothing.” The last time I see Manjit he is being dropped off by the police after being caught clinging to the underbelly of truck bound for England. I ask if he is OK; his face crumbles in despair.
A 20-year-old Eritrean man wearing an assortment of charity clothes is visibly worn down by his precarious life in Calais. When we met more than a year ago, he was bright-eyed and full of hope about a new life in England. He left Eritrea, where English is the second language, to escape a lifetime providing free labour in the government army. Now his eyes are stained red, the conviction drained from his face, all hope of reaching England lost. He has applied for asylum in France instead. So far he has waited eight months for a response; meanwhile, he lives in limbo, his life on hold at the mercy of European bureaucracy. And he is not exempt from police harassment. “I’m tired,” he says, his expression empty. “If there was no problem in my country, I would prefer to live there.”
When months of suffering turn into years, the faith that drives refugees to pin all hopes on European hospitality switches to despair. Lily Boilet, an activist and campaigner from Isbergues, a small village in northern France, says: “They can become depressed, alcoholic, and we can’t help them. Five years on the streets is not good. Even when they get papers, they can become crazy.” Last year she was forced to commit a sub-Saharan African refugee to a mental clinic. He had started hearing voices; they told him black clothes were bad, white were good. He only possessed dark clothes so walked around naked desperately afraid.
It is a tall task to end the bloodshed in the Middle East or bring peace to warring tribes in Sudan, but the countries of Europe must not drive refugees to even greater despair. Instead, the European Union must strive to create and enforce a fair, coherent, and humane asylum system, fulfilling liberal aspirations set out many years ago.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists





















21 comments
Why aren't you doing more to prevent there being refugess in the first place-birth control, including legal and readily available abortion? If you have 4-8 children in a society that can barely provide for the children it has, you're only throwing fuel on the bonfire when the population goes up. A nation that can't feed what it breeds is a disaster; look at relatively backwards societies in Europe like Portugal, Italy and Ireland. They're bad now but image if they had the birth rates they once had one hundred years ago; they'd be disaster areas.
You want to stop them reaching Calais? Help their countries control their numbers being born.
I have every sympathy for genuine refugees. But how can Manjit Singh be classed as such? He sold his farm in Bangladesh to seek illegal work in the UK? There is a huge difference between refugees and economic migrants.I suspect many of the people in the Calais jungle are the same . In any event aren't they there mostly because they don't want to seek refugee status in France - an option which would be open to them if they were genuine refugees?
Isn't it about time the USA sent France a 'Statue of Liberty'. It's time they returned the favour.
Plymouth Brethren
Object lesson in illegal migration, do not come to the UK , and try to enter illegaly without a job after selling your farm. I think all people ought put in to the Country as taxpayers before they can draw benefit, claim NHS status and get a free house and benefits, of course if they do that they will not be claiming a free house etc etc etc.
We cannot afford to pay our own pensions that match Europe, as most of their contributions were invested at low rates of return, by the various biscuit barrel parties, three of ,that have feasted well themselves and denied their voters a basic humanitarian pension.
Arrrrrrr poor little duckies , my heart bleeds. Stay that side of the channel, i hear now a socialist is in charge, it's gonna be one big party. Let the good times roll, well until the bar bill arrives that is, then you can move on to the next gullible country.
Yes, we can do more for these people. I think more Iraqi Kurds would return to where they were brought up, if the Kurds had a clear country boundary of their own. Saddam Hussein didn't want them, the Turks don't want them, let them have the regions of North Iraq and East Turkey and help them to settle in peace. Problem solved.
Afghan Asylum Seekers Gang-Rape British Journalism Student
August 29, 2008 by Lance
This is part of the Muslim culture, to warmly greet infidels by gang-raping them?
The alleged perpetrators of this heinous crime were not terrorists. They were just run-of-the-mill Islamofascist animals. Whether goats, women, sheep or camels…it’s all the same to these prehistoric relics, especially if the women are infidels, then they get further brutalization.
Enemy appeasers had better either get their heads dislodged from their asses or get used to such treatment, or worse. Appeasers, like the EU and American liberals, have all but bent over and spread their ass cheeks, just asking for Muslims to screw them rather than fight them the way brave and wise Americans do.
I guess she just forgot to bring her marshmallows and Kumbaya sheet music along. This surely would have given her more “hope“:
[Muslim] Asylum Seekers Held After British Journalism Student Gang-Raped in Calais ‘Jungle’ Ghetto
A British woman has been raped by a gang of asylum seekers in Calais, it has been alleged.
The journalism student wanted to highlight the plight of migrants who sleep rough in a squalid camp at the French port before trying to sneak into Britain.
She was subjected to a horrific attack by six Afghan men she intended to write about, it was claimed.
French riot police rounded up 200 migrants for questioning.
Ten remained in custody tonight and police said it was possible all had been involved in the rape, which detectives described as ‘extremely brutal’.
Police said the 31-year-old victim, who cannot be named for legal reasons, was a London student who had travelled to France ‘to highlight problems surrounding clandestine immigration’….
And this is not the first time for such a crime. }} more…
I am in despair at the thought of these savages coming to England.
I am in despair at the thought of these savages coming to England.
I am in despair at the thought of these savages coming to England.
What we can't reply to the Iraqi Kurdish refugee is that we can't take any more people who are still coming, endlessly it seems. That the bank's broke, there's no jobs, that he'd be living vicariously under a bridge, even if he managed to get across the stretch of water he keeps gazing at. England, land of milk and honey - not any more, because those who came before him have used it all up. Our grace and favour goodwill, that is. Now our own people are suffering, because we took too many people like him in, and we're top heavy with refugees, asylum seekers, economic migrants, their cousins, uncles, grandparents, all spawning their offspring into our stretched education establishments.
But hey, let them come, let's have a collapsed system, a collapse of everything. It's the first thing to get these do-gooders off their feet and run for the ships. Let all the indigenous people leave and start our civilised society in one of these wilderness places, and leave the refugees this land to salvage what they can. Our society's in it's dying throes anyway, isn't it. Let's all emigrate and throw away our passports, so we can't be shipped back, and start our own new world. Don't forget your seeds.
There are no human rights in Europe, observes the refugee. I am getting tired of hearing this. There is no freedom in the west, observed a friend from the former east-bloc region in the nineties upon seeing a police car cruising by. These people have no clue about what it takes to run a society in more or less fair ways. It is often an awful system, even for non-refugees, but still better than the bizarrely decrepit states these people come from.
I am already thoroughly tired of the scapegoating of refugees. The problem is that most European governments do not have a clue about how to run a society in a more-or-less fair way. Treating refugees so disgustingly badly is not the mark of a fair or civilised society.
Parts of large, empty countries like Libya, Sudan & Somalia etc should be annexed and turned into refugee states. Then we could expel all foreigners and ethnic minorities living in our European countries and harassing the local indigenous population, and also demanding their "rights".
This is a very daft thing to say.
Jane Concernade said that my earlier comment was "a very daft thing to say." The word "daft" is a curious one. I wonder what it means. She didn't explain why she used it, so I assume it was just an insult.
There's plenty of food in the world to go round, and resources, according to Foster Gamble, of the Proctor & Gamble multi-national conglomerate. To watch his documentary film, visit www.whitefeather.gov.uk - scroll down the left-hand list until you come to THRIVE , click on it and watch the film for free. It's VERY revealing.
The new Socialist French government should take care of them. Under International law it's their responsibility, not ours. France has a better climate, food and double the space and besides who in their right mind would wish to live in tory Britain? A Land of austerity with no jobs and let's not forget we have 1 million young people not in work.
I am sure that the people who live next door to em are in despair as well.
With a good humane socialist like Hollande in charge now, they'll probably get all they need from the French state benefit system.
Do the French have a state benefit system? I thought they were too proud to be caught out of work or be ill.