Star Spangled Staggers

US politics from outside the beltway

Syndicate contentRSS

Obama heckled during speech: Journalist or douchebag?

A self-styled reporter heckled President Obama as he announced a major shake-up in immigration policy.

Neil Munro heckles Obama. Photograph: Getty Images
Neil Munro heckles Obama. Photograph: Getty Images

A reporter for a conservative news site interrupted President Barack Obama on Friday as he was announcing a decision to suspend the deportation of children brought to the U.S. illegally. The policy shift was a game-changer politically, because the president essentially dared Republican challenger Mitt Romney to denounce the move, knowing that he can't. Romney is in the unenviable position of having to serve two masters, as it were. To win in November, he must seize the Hispanic vote, which is wary of the hardline immigration policies he endorsed during the GOP primaries. And he must maintain the support of party's conservative base, which in many ways is anti-immigrant.

But that was nearly overshadowed by an unprecedented breach of decorum in the White House press corps by a correspondent named Neil Munro. Munro writes for The Daily Caller, a website that aims to be the conservative version of The Huffington Post. It was founded by Tucker Carlson, who is best known for one of two things: He once said he instinctively wants to cross his legs whenever Hillary Clinton walks into a room; and The Daily Show's Jon Stewart called him a dick on his own show, CNN's "Crossfire," which led to the demise of Carlson's career as a TV pundit.

Munro interrupted the president four minutes into his statement. Over the course of Obama's remarks, Munro shouted no fewer than six times while the he was speaking. The president was clearly livid, the White House Press Secretary had (surely pissy) words with Carlson afterward, and the media almost universally condemned his behavior and wondered: Is this a reporter or a heckler?

There were many reactions. Most said Munro's actions were disrespectful, outrageous, and/or deserving of sanction by the White House. Even Fox News' Bill O'Reilly, Chris Wallace and Shepard Smith thought so. Some thought it was racist or at least in keeping with attempts by wing-nut operatives to discredit Obama. Yet of all observations, one lacks sufficient attention. Munro blatantly and egregiously lied afterward, and his boss has now launched a propaganda campaign to rewrite this history.

Here's Munro's take:

I always go to the White House prepared with questions for our president. I timed the question believing the president was closing his remarks, because naturally I have no intention of interrupting the President of the United States. I know he rarely takes questions before walking away from the podium. When I asked the question as he finished his speech, he turned his back on the many reporters, and walked away while I and at least one other reporter asked questions.

Salient points here: No intention to interrupt. "Mistimed" his question. And, importantly, Obama is stingy about questions.

No one can say with certainty what Munro intended, but we can say the president was not concluding his remarks. The event was carried live on CNN and others. The video clearly shows Obama was surprised by the interruption. Todd Zwillich, the radio correspondent for The Takeaway, tweeted this:

I was standing right behind Munro in the Rose Garden. Idea he 'mistimed' his questions isn't credible. He purposely interrupted. 

And even if he had "mistimed" his question, he didn't stop with one. In fact, he bullied the president into taking questions. The Village Voice's Steven Thrasher was standing next to Munro and captured the "only clean audio of what he heckled at President Obama."

Obama: Excuse me, sir.

Munro: You have to take questions.

Obama: It's not time for questions, sir.

Munro: No, you have to take questions.

Obama: Not while I'm speaking.

So whatever he intended, this was not a matter of mistiming. It appeared deliberate, because not only did he interrupt the president, but he badgered him. This is why some headlines put quotes around "reporter." To serious journalists, Munro was not practicing journalism.

But remember that third salient point in Munro's statement – that Obama is stingy with questions. This has become grounds for Tucker Carlson's push to reframe what happened, not in terms of Munro's belligerence, disrespect and douchebaggery but in terms of heroic journalism. Obama is so hard to get a straight answer out of that a man's got to get tough. Munro wasn't heckling Obama, as Diane Sawyer said during ABC's live coverage of the event; he was searching for the truth. Tucker wrote:

A reporter’s job is to ask questions and get answers. Our job is to find out what the federal government is up to. Politicians often don’t want to tell us. A good reporter gets the story.

Since Friday, Carlson has been on Fox News and other sympathetic news outlets to blame the "liberal media" for not understanding the important work of Munro and The Daily Caller, and to recast Obama as the villain and Munro as the hero. He told Fox News' Sean Hannity, who suggested Munro's timing was a tad off:

The point is that Neil Munro wants his questions answered. We can argue about how he asked it, what venue he asked it, but the bottom-line is that he's doing what a lot of people who cover the White House aren't doing, which is pressing for answers.

Let's forget that The Daily Caller and Tucker Carlson in particular are considered a joke among many journalists, left and right. Let's instead take him at his word -- that Munro is serious.

Fine. Then where was his notebook?

A serious White House correspondent dogging the president and asking the tough questions no one else who is covering the White House is asking would surely have a notebook, right? I'm not the first to notice its conspicuous absence, and its absence suggests only one conclusion. Munro isn't serious. Nor is Carlson. In fact, they are committing a host of journalistic sins, chief among them is a propaganda campaign to save what little credibility The Daily Caller had in Washington.

If he had mistimed his question, Munro could have apologized and moved on. He didn't, because that's not what he was doing. A journalist would never ask the President of the United States questions with his hands in his pockets. But a heckler would.

28 comments

John Cheese's picture

Ha ha...the Egyptian muzlem bros just gave Hillary the "shoe"- better call a press conference...

bike games's picture

Haha there is no doubt. I admire the valuable information you offer in your articles. From bestbikegames.net

John Cheese's picture

NAACP event: compare Romney's straight talk to American Blacks to Øbama's no-show & fill in idiot...

Callahan Adrian's picture

my neighbor's step-aunt makes $83/hr on the laptop. She has been fired from work for ten months but last month her income was $12661 just working on the laptop for a few hours. Go to this web site and read more Http://lazycash24.com

Gringo_H's picture

Yeah, didn't get past the nissan advert. If you can't just put the footage on NS then keep it, ya cheapskates.

I can watch the video in 15 seconds? Pffft.

difference games's picture

I think that reporter just messed it up and now tries to rectify it by blameing his interlocutor, cool stuff.
difference games

jonny brand's picture

Notebook, sound recorder, whatever a reporter wants to use, doesn't matter.
These things should be formal yes but my point still stands, allow some interaction, if you don't then it may be forced upon you. How anyone could detect racism from my previous comment is idiotic. I have no political bias.

Oscar's picture

Ignore Jackass, Jonny.

He cant help himself. He's so full of hate that most of what he says simply doesn't make sense.

jankaas's picture

you always in the habit of telling other posters what to do Osfart? surely Jonny can take care of himself, probably far better than you can...

Oscar's picture

Shift button broken Jackass? Try the caps lock instead.

Maybe not using capitals means you're either too angry to bother about them or you're a bit thick. Are you a bit thick Jackass?

jankaas's picture

yes of course i am thick. you are the really smart one Drosscar.
you know, posting to someone as thick as me, now that's smart.

Oscar's picture

Well I'm glad you acknowledge your none too bright, there's a good little bile merchant. Now, off you go...

jankaas's picture

how frustrating! yet again you put me in my place Oddscab. you are just so smart.

Rick Blaine's picture

Since when does a "reporter" show up at a presidential announcement without a notepad, camera, or tape recorder? He's just standing there with his hands in his pockets. How, exactly, was he going to report the story unless he was attempting to BE the story?

Lalita's picture

Very good question.

simoned's picture

I think that reporter just messed it up and now tries to rectify it by blameing his interlocutor, cool stuff.
And about the President affirmation I have no comment, it's just a campaign. jocu

John Cheese's picture

I think I remember everyone saying exactly the same things with the Bush shoe-thrower incident! Pretty thin skin...

Stephen Floyd's picture

Being from the United States AND being a veteran of the United States Army, I personally believe that this reporter is a "tool" just looking for his 15 minutes of fame. The disrespect and utter lack of courtesy that is shown to world leaders today is appalling.

Anyway,

That's just my 2 cents worth...

For more of my amazing insights please visit me at:
http://www.bottle-rocket.com

Gringo_H's picture

"Being from the United States AND being a veteran of the United States Army,"

Means you're probably a sheep who does his masters dirty work without a thought of your own. Civilian killer.

Everett Rafael's picture

like Stanley explained I'm dazzled that some people able to profit $8384 in one month on the computer. have you read this link HTTP://LAZYCASH24.COM

hugh markey's picture

Surely Obama can find a place for this guy on the front line in Afghanistan. Shame to see all the vinegar and piss going to waste. It'll be like shooting fish in a barrel - a regular turkey shoot if they follow the seed trail, a la Jimmy Baker. Sure, he was a Texan and a Republican. Imagine Big John Wayne at a tea party.

Fightin' Talk
.

Hikaru22's picture

Your "President of The United States" is just an elected politician - much like any other. If he cannot stand being heckled - or, more to the point, if he has not learnt to deal with it - then he ought not to be there in the first place.

truereligionjeansoutlet's picture

What`s the central idea of this passage? can you give us a brief introduction in your own words?we

are true religion outlet online.http://sosoemall.com

jonny brand's picture

Why does he need a notebook? The whole thing is being filmed. If Obama doesn't take questions then his dictating style should be challenged, if the only way to easily do this is 'heckling' then this can only be blamed on the president for not being more open to questions in the first place

jankaas's picture

i see you have no idea about the way these things are supposed to go Jonny. maybe you've never seen this type of situation before. it's really quite simple; whilst POTUS is talking you shut the fcuk up until he is finished, then, you wait till POTUS allows you to put your question to him.

but i see you prefer a system of people shouting and screaming, and whoever does so loudest gets to be heard? bizarre.

jankaas's picture

2 things jump out from your post Jonny;
you clearly don't understand why reporters have notebooks.
and
you clearly think that Obama does not deserve standard decorum in matters of Presidential duties.

so is this because you are a Republican, a racist, or perhaps both?

Oscar's picture

Racist?? You really are a stain on the earth Jackass.

Just piss off and take your scummy little thoughts with you.

jankaas's picture

racist was just one of the options on offer Osfart. and that post wasn't for you either, so you can piss off you eejit.

Latest tweets