Alex Hern

Dispatches from the front line of the internet

Syndicate contentRSS

Louise Mensch invents Twitter; shame Twitter already did it

Will you Menshn? Probably not.

The scoring system explained. Screenshot via Techcrunch.com
The scoring system explained. Screenshot via Techcrunch.com

The end result of Louise Mensch and Luke Bozier's side-project, MenschBozier, was revealed today by TechCrunch. It's called Menshn, and it's Twitter. Twitter may have already invented Twitter, but that won't stop MenschBozier.

The new site is focused around sending Tweet-like messages (of up to 180 characters, rather than 140, which is a crucial differentiator for some reason) about specific topics. The site will launch in the US only, and be focused around the American elections.

Mensch told TechCrunch:

I had a brainwave over Christmas about Twitter hashtags and the frustration of following one topic, especially in politics.

Then I got my husband on Twitter [Peter Mensch is the manager of heavy metal band Metallica, among others] and although he liked following people in the music industry and what they had to say, he hated the mundane tweets about people having breakfast. He wanted something on topic.

Menshn also aims to encourage quality with a rating system, similar to that on sites like Reddit, and by stripping out many of the features that make Twitter such a vibrant medium, like retweets and mentions (yes, the site's name is a pun on a functionality it doesn't actually have). The site still has its analogue of following someone, likely called something like "Mensching" them, but if your tweet is the top five per cent of tweets, then everyone will see it, whether they follow you or not.

Menshn seems to be the creation of someone who likes twitter but is annoyed that they don't have enough control over it. For Louise Mensch, it will most likely be a better experience; Twitter must be a horrible place for her to be, because the service simply doesn't deal well with people who set out to abuse celebrities and nothing else. But for most other people, all the functions which Mensch and Bozier seem to dislike so much – the "off topic" discussions, personal conversations, viral jokes and ephemerality – are precisely the important functions of the site. Persuading people to give those up for the chance to have their tweet seen by everyone (in a function that absolutely will not scale - can you imagine seeing the "top five per cent" of the 340 million tweets sent per day?) is unlikely to happen any time soon.

Nice website design, though.

Update

Well, we got on Menshn, and first impressions are that it has a bit of a troll problem:

 

Also, the rules are amazing:

menshn is for talking on topic. We're passionate about politics and we love debate. But if you harass, spam, clog feeds and so forth, we can delete your account without notice. So be like Fonzy and be cool.

menshn will grow and change. We can change what menshn does and the service it provides without notification to you or other users. See rule 4. We reckon you'll figure it out if we do.

menshn is not forever...

You can say that again.

16 comments

poodleby's picture

I can see why she has called it 'Menshn'. Being such a hit with the public, her name has so much kudos and credibility. Not narcissistic in any way at all! I must buy into it. A failing Tory politician is just the person I wish to be associated with!

Louis MacLift's picture

Is launching it in the states part of a tax avoidance scheme?

Louis MacLift's picture

Is launching it in the states part of a tax avoidance scheme?

Louis MacLift's picture

Is launching it in the states part of a tax avoidance scheme?

Louis MacLift's picture

Is launching it in the states part of a tax avoidance scheme?

Louis MacLift's picture

Is launching it in the states part of a tax avoidance scheme?

clay's picture

An incredible 180 characters – 40 more than on that epitome of blandness Twitter, so the vacuous can be even more bland than usual.

Louise Mensch reminds me of a 15 year old schoolgirl obsessively texting her pals as if her very life depended on it. “I must get those characters out there - my public demand it.”

Zee's picture

(As much of a cliche as it may be) Menshn really is a good example of 'a solution in need of a problem'.

Bhuvnesh's picture

It happens to be visually impaired and using a text-to-speech browser, you'll be clueless as to what this site is about (hmmm... that may be no different to those without any visual impairment).
Flats in Dwarka

Bhuvnesh's picture

It happens to be visually impaired and using a text-to-speech browser, you'll be clueless as to what this site is about (hmmm... that may be no different to those without any visual impairment).
Flats in Dwarka

Go GG's picture

'Menshn also aims to encourage quality with a rating system'

I suppose the comment, Mensh is a useless tory prat who owns a home in Murdochs top pocket, is not going to earn much rating in her system then.. what a shame!

Agent's picture

Right that's it, this weeks YAWN award is as good as won.

Barrie J's picture

When you don't have the safest parliamentary seat, not particularly popular and sit for one of the most corrupt political parties since 1800, it makes sense to ensure you have several revenue streams.

hobson's picture

They should sort out that e-mail address collection box so that the text "enter email address" is cleared away when you first start typing in there as it would improve the experience a great deal

Ciaran Goggins's picture

Didn't she call for Twitter to be closed down last August? Also for tweeters who disagreed with her to be arrested?

Chris McCray's picture

"Nice website design, though" - only accssible if you're in the USA. Interesting move by two British politicos, avoiding any criticism from the UK?

Two technical points about the design - the text that greets non-US users, erm, isn't actually text, it's embedded in the image:

http://menshn.com/nonus/non-us-visitor.jpg

If you happen to be visually impaired and using a text-to-speech browser, you'll be clueless as to what this site is about (hmmm... that may be no different to those without any visual impairment).

And the way the e-mail address collection box works - the text "Enter email address" isn't cleared away when you first start typing in there. It's a common enough design trick in javascript to get this to happen, and just improves the user experience that little bit. It's called a "textbox watermark" - you can see what I mean in the demo here:

http://digitalbush.com/projects/watermark-input-plugin/

So I won't be providing no, Louise & Luke with my e-mail address for them to spam me with crap about their US-centric website.

Latest tweets