The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Cameron's tax return isn't enough

The PM should also reveal his wealth and assets.

New Statesman
Cameron is "relaxed" about the idea of tax returns being published. Photograph: Getty Images.

I noted last week that the decision by the London mayoral candidates to publish their tax returns had set an important precedent that other senior politicians would feel compelled to follow. Since then, George Osborne has said he is "very happy" to consider publishing ministers' tax returns and, now, David Cameron has followed his Chancellor's lead. A source tells the Daily Telegraph:

The Prime Minister is relaxed about the idea of the tax returns of senior Cabinet Ministers being published, but wants the opportunity to explore how this might work

But would Cameron's tax return be enough to satisfy the new demand for transparency? In a significant intervention, David Davis has rightly argued that any proposal should also cover the disclosure of wealth and assets:

This will induce the politics of envy – but if you are going to do it, you have got to cover everything: wealth, trusts, whether you are a beneficiary of trusts, whether you are going to inherit things.

If you want really to know about someone’s tax affairs you have to know about more than just someone’s tax return. You have to know their assets, the potential inheritances, if they are going to be the beneficiaries of upcoming trust funds – all those things.

Among other things, this would draw further attention to Cameron and Osborne's privileged status, an ever more sensitive issue since the abolition of the 50p tax rate. Osborne, for instance, owns a 15 per cent stake in his family's wallpaper company Osborne & Little and stands to inherit around £4m from a trust fund, while Cameron's wealth is estimated at £3.2m (excluding inheritance). Indeed, the latter once memorably admitted to the Times that he couldn't remember how many houses he owns.

Here's the full exchange:

So how many properties do you own? “I own a house in North Kensington which you’ve been to and my house in the constituency in Oxfordshire and that is, as far as I know, all I have.”

A house in Cornwall? “No, that is, Samantha used to have a timeshare in South Devon but she doesn’t any more.” And there isn’t a fourth? “I don’t think so – not that I can think of.” Please don’t say, “Not that I can think of.” “You might be… Samantha owns a field in Scunthorpe but she doesn’t own a house…”

The rest of the interview was punctuated with Cameron’s nagging anxiety about how this exchange was going to make him sound: “I was wondering how that will come across as a soundbite”; “‘Not that I can think of’ makes me sound… I am really worried about that…”; “I am still thinking about this house thing”; and his parting shot was: “Do not make me sound like a prat for not knowing how many houses I’ve got."

Davis, who recently observed that Cameron and his ministers ("very well turned out, well-fed") "look like they’re in a completely different world", will have his own motives for demanding greater transparency. Ever since he fought Cameron for the Conservative leadership in 2005, Davis has rarely missed an opportunity to contrast his humble background (he was raised on a council estate in Tooting) with that of the Eton-educated Cameron.

15 comments

rayban4177's picture

Ray Ban Sunglasses are about the cutting edge of fashion and give a diverse collection associated with distinctive models. Rayban is a fashion icon known around the world for the bold statements that their own apparel makes. When it involves Ray Ban, they do not restrain on their creativity and focus on detail.

MagpiesView's picture

These are all people who are, not only in public life, but make decisions regarding how the rest of us live, the taxes we pay, the quality of services we receive, the risks our sons and daughters are exposed to. A comprehensive report of the finances that these people have access to (including expenses) and their involvement in any organization are all relevant to an informed opinion about them, who are after all supposed to be our representatives.

PS - I sure Gideon is happy to consider publishing such details, just as I'm sure he will happily hide behind any excuse he can scrape up in order to avoid doing so.

mbrecker's picture

This obsession with taxes reminds me of an old Harold McMillan quote (hope I've got the right person). "Tax the rich till they scream". Once he did that, it set off a huge tax exile wave (Peter Sellers, Sean Connery, Michael Caine and others).

Patrick Stewart's right. Cameron and his priveledged mates aren't like the rest of us. Samr problem with Romney and Obama in the States. Both are millionaires. One lives off investments and the other is the most powerful man alive. Now, how do you rebrand yourself as "average"?

Syzygy's picture

I think that Samantha's inheritance of 30+m and salary of 350k should also be included.

Syzygy's picture

I think that Samantha's inheritance of 30+m and salary of 350k should also be included.

p j wall's picture

It was great viewing watching Flashman 'SQUIRM', when Joey Jones from Sky asked him if he`s ever done anything that could be seen as Tax Avoidance?, his face went beetroot as usual, looking like a cabbage patch doll!!.
I find it very funny looking at all the usual, selfish, Tory apoligists on here trying to divert attention away from their beloved Tories!, i think we all know which party the majority of hypocritical Multi Millionaires belong to?, ALL MPs should divulge their incomes, wealth, properties, and how much tax they pay?, otherwise, we have the pathetic situation of Multi Millionaire Gideon claiming he doesn`t earn enough to pay the full tax rate!!!.

Tussyisme's picture

Careful with the party-political point-scoring. How many Labour parliamentarians own more than one property, are BTL/other landlords? Full disclosure, please. Register of Members' Interests inadequate as doesn't disclose property held in spouses' names.

Herbert's picture

Who can't forget Michael Meacher forgetting how many properties he owned? And, while we're at it, Tessa Jowell not knowing how much she owed on the family mortgage and who was helping to pay it?

Indu Pendent's picture

@george
This is great - pls keep going.

Lets get Ed Balls and Yvette Coopers affairs full disclosed.

The slight flaw is that the Coalition front bench have already volunteered to publish their returns. HOWEVER, just like Hattie dragged her feet and attempted to suppress the publication of MPs expenses information (which is why the press by passed her), Miliband is "considering" whether it is OK to publish the Labour front bench return. Same old Labour.

What has actually happended is that there is a problem with the returns of some of the Labour front bench and they are currently trying to work out how to get around it.

Eddy S's picture

i think the best thing is if everyones tax returns are published online, then we would all know how much we all earn, this would create a very open society and there would be no hypocrisy either or the opposite boasting too !

i think publishing politicans assets and there partners too would also be a good idea, most MP's labour, tory or lib dem have a good house and had previously done well from expenses.

Herbert's picture

The problem is that by the time they get to their tax return the hiding has already been done.

London Exile's picture

Perhaps we could start with all journalists and blog editors making this kind of disclosure about their finances.?

Celeriac's picture

I would have thought they would have arranged their capital and income in the most lucrative and discrete way, well before the election. It's not like they are stupid, or anything is it?

SoapboxL's picture

All in this together

Latest tweets