Michael Brooks

Here comes the science bit

Syndicate contentRSS

Curiosity lands on Mars: the US wins the space heptathlon

Red planet: the film showed a manned mission to Mars. Photo: Getty
Red planet: the film showed a manned mission to Mars. Photo: Getty

"There's a one-ton piece of American ingenuity and it's sitting on the surface of Mars right now.” That was the reaction of John Holdren, director of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy, to Curiosity’s landing on the Red Planet. “In your face, China!” he might have added under his breath, glancing at the Olympic medal table.

Let’s not understate the significance of Curiosity’s extraordinary and daring seven-point landing routine. The US has won the space heptathlon (separation from cruise module, heat shield deployment, parachute opening, altitude sensing, rocket-powered sky crane, rover touchdown and skycrane flyaway, since you ask). Even better, China got a DNF. Last year, thanks to the failure of the Russian Phobos-Grunt mission, the most recent Chinese effort to reach Mars managed little more than a dismal few turns in low-earth orbit and a humiliating crash into the Pacific Ocean.

Olympic medals are about bolstering national pride. Big space missions have always had the same goal. The Apollo missions to the moon were a reaction to Soviet successes in space. Getting Curiosity to Mars will be far more important than Apollo, scientifically speaking, but American scientists would not be celebrating a Chinese landing on Mars with half as much enthusiasm.

That’s because being first to the data is also a matter of national pride. The Chinese had to rewrite their Martian plans after the failure of the Phobos-Grunt mission. It was meant to carry China’s Yinghuo-1 probe to Mars to perform analysis of the Martian atmosphere. But next year, NASA will launch a probe that will do what Yinghuo-1 would have done: in January, the director-general of China’s National Space Science Centre told the China Daily that this means China has to change their scientific goals. No one wants the embarrassment of taking silver in the hunt for new discoveries.

Curiosity’s success is also likely to prevent the Chinese accepting America’s offer to collaborate on future Mars missions. Last week, NASA administrator Charles Bolden said the US would seek international partnership for these undertakings. China has been invited to get involved, but national pride is at stake here too. Michael Phelps might as well offer to help the Chinese swim team catch up with the US.

In space exploration, the offer is particularly patrician: by the time manned missions are feasible China will be the world’s biggest economy, and probably the only serious player in space. The 2013 federal budget request, published in February, took 20 percent off NASA’s planetary science funding.  The Mars program budget could plummet from $587 million today to $189 million by 2015. A future manned mission to Mars will be far beyond NASA’s means.

If researchers in Beijing have any sense of how the land lies, a life-detection mission seems like a good next step.  Curiosity won’t look for life for political reasons. The 1976 Viking missions had to report a negative result in their search for life on Mars. Though interesting to scientists, it sounded like failure to politicians. NASA really can’t afford to invoke the F-word these days, so it has decided not to ask the question. Instead, the rover will hunt for carbon-based molecules that are deemed essential for the existence of life – past or present – on Mars and use its laser, cameras and other imaging equipment to examine rocks to gain a better understanding of Martian geology.

But if the Chinese do steal a march with the detection of alien life, it won’t happen for years yet. Curiosity, having done the hard work, just has to turn in some great pictures and data, and the US will hold onto the gold medal for Mars exploration for the foreseeable future.

USA FTW!

12 comments

Posh Tosh's picture

The vehicle has just found an old sign which reads "We have stripped this planet of all its natural resources, and are sending a spacecraft to a planet that we shall call Earth, as has plenty of water and looks a good place for our continuation as a species"

Curious Joe's picture

Why do Americans get so paranoid about dominating other countries... I don't get it

Heterarch's picture

One possible reason is that Americans come from all over the world - nations that have have, at one time or another, been conquered or dominated by others at one point or another. Nearly the entire history of oppression, throughout the world, is engrained in the national mentality of America in one way or another. Add to that the bullseye on our back since the fall of the soviet union, and you've got a recipe for "dominance-paranoia". Just a though though.

mbrecker's picture

The US cannot pay off it's national debt. China is it's biggest creditor.
There are 310 million Americans. There are over 1 billion Chinese.
The Chinese have more money to invest globally than the States.
If Obama is re-elected and cuts NASA's budget, this means less tax revenue. What good does a tax cut do when you have no job?
NASA engineers and assorted staff are human beings just like the rest of us.
If NASA's budget is cut, who's going to monitor Curiousity? Will NASA management bring in scab staff?
Govt. employees have unions.
They also have lobbyists.
They are everywhere.
They do not forget.

screwge's picture

What good does a tax cut for Mitt and company do when folks have no jobs to buy stuff imported from Bain outsourced "rescues"?

screwge's picture

What good does a tax cut for Mitt and company do when folks have no jobs to buy stuff imported from Bain outsourced "rescues"?

John Cheese's picture

What good does a US economy run into the ground & 42 months of 8%+ Unemployment do? I bet the Staples employees that kept their jobs feel different than you. And all the other Bain-saved companies. And corp-fund 401K investors. Get the poser out & put in a successful leader & press GO! Or we can argue about how Mitt's wife is too pretty...

hugh markey's picture

We think we heard it on RT but did Russian space engineers have anything to do with this Martian probe. Forget the Chinese. They'll get there under their own steam.
Suspect a lot of NASA's team are imports. Always have been in the past. What was it - Verner Von Braun and his bosses.
RT is also claiming some premier US rockets are utilizing old Soviet rocket engines. Must be over twenty years since the demise of that old political jigsaw.

Flash Gordon

hugh markey's picture

We think we heard it on RT but did Russian space engineers have anything to do with this Martian probe. Forget the Chinese. They'll get there under their own steam.
Suspect a lot of NASA's team are imports. Always have been in the past. What was it - Verner Von Braun and his bosses.
RT is also claiming some premier US rockets are utilizing old Soviet rocket engines. Must be over twenty years since the demise of that old political jigsaw.

Flash Gordon

dwight D phobos's picture

Testing for conditions required for life.
Ground for lifeforms to stand on . check

sangos's picture

Sometimes I wonder why the USA is so bothered about China....this article is one

Mortimer Sanderson's picture

A better question for the people of Tibet, or of Shinjiang, or for the millions of dissenting voices in China (including untold thousands of imprisoned Falun Gong adherents) Why, you should ask, are they so bothered by the PRC regime?

Latest tweets