Welcome to the New Statesman website. Please sign in or register to participate in the conversation.

Mehdi Hasan

Mehdi Hasan’s polemical take on politics, economics and foreign affairs

Syndicate contentRSS

A big boost for Labour in London

Ken v Boris just got very interesting. The former mayor has much more than a fighting chance come May.

Back in November 2010, I wrote in my NS column:

One of the most frustrating aspects to writing a regular column on British politics is having to challenge the conventional wisdom in which so many of our leading broadcasters, reporters, columnists and now bloggers seem to bathe. Groupthink abounds inside the Westminster village. Lazy assumptions proliferate like weeds.

Take the run-up to the general election. For much of 2009, political correspondents and pollsters, columnists and commentators queued up to predict the size of the impending Tory landslide. Would it be double-digit? Or triple-digit? The idea that the Tories might fail to win the election outright was, to put it mildly, considered "unconventional".

I also noted how I had been

mocked by some of my peers for daring to suggest on these pages, in June 2009, in the wake of Labour's humiliating defeat at the European elections, that the Tories' poll ratings were "soft" and Labour still had "a fighting chance of a hung parliament at next year's general election".

So I couldn't help but smile when a press release from YouGov, with the results of their latest poll on London's forthcoming mayoral election, dropped into my inbox this morning.

It revealed that Ken Livingstone had overtaken Tory incombent Boris Johnson in the race for City Hall, with the Labour candidate taking a narrow 51-49 lead.

Ken takes lead over Boris in race for Mayor

announced the headline in the Evening Standard.

Refreshingly, YouGov president Peter Kellner openly confessed:

The facts have changed, so I have changed my mind.

Throughout last year, I regarded Boris Johnson as the likeliest winner of London's coming mayoral election. YouGov and other pollsters showed consistently that around one-in-five Labour supporters would desert Ken Livingstone and vote for Boris. From Labour's viewpoint, London began to look alarmingly like Scotland, where Alex Salmond won his stunning victory last year because one in five normally Labour voters switched to the SNP.

Our latest poll tells a different story. We find a five-point swing from Boris to Ken. Last June, Boris enjoyed an eight-point lead (54-46%); now Ken is two points ahead, by 51-49%. Allowing for sampling error, the race is too close to call.

Will others in the Westminster village and the commentariat now join Kellner in "changing" their minds? Will they now admit that Ken Livingstone has not just a chance but a fighting chance, a good chance, of winning May's mayoral contest? Up until this point, the "lazy assumption" - even among some centre-left journalists - has been that Boris Johnson will walk it, that he has the election sewn up. (Remember all those journalists and columnists who were so keen to crown Cameron as PM in 2009 and January-April 2010, and assume a landslide majority for the Tories was in the bag?)

YouGov's latest poll suggests that those of us who were sceptical about such claims had good reason to be. Admittedly, it's a single poll and there's all the usual stuff to note about outliers, rogues, sampling errors and the rest, but I suspect more and more polls will start reflecting Ken's start-of-the-year "surge" in the coming weeks.

As the Standard notes:

Moreover, the three issues that Londoners regard as most important are those that Mr Livingstone has campaigned hardest on: tackling crime (picked by 42 per cent), improving transport (41 per cent) and easing the cost of living (33 per cent). Only four per cent think promoting London abroad, a regular Boris theme, is a priority.

The energetic and focused Livingstone is hitting the right issues - and hitting them hard. There is a lesson for his party leader here: Ed Miliband shouldn't be trying to cover and campaign on every issue, in detail, all the time, but picking those few issues that voters care about and that Labour has leads over the Tories on - for example, jobs and the NHS - and hitting them hard, in speeches, interviews, photo-ops, etc, again and again and again.

There's also the intriguing issue of Livingstone's personality, his authenticity: in the modern political era, few candidates for high office are harmed by being themselves. In fact, the reverse is true.

Speaking of Ed Miliband, this latest poll will provide a much-needed boost for him and his aides too, after a horrid start to the year. If Livingstone wins against the odds in May, and London goes Labour, expect Miliband and his supporters to spin it as a victory for his leadership and his political agenda - and vote of no-confidence in David Cameron. If Ken loses to Boris, however, expect whispers about the future of Miliband's leadership to get louder. Much louder.

Tags: London Mayoral Election  Ed Miliband  Ken Livingstone  Boris Johnson  Labour

22 comments

stevem1's picture

Oh Dear Quattroman If you want to play here with the grown ups then do some research before you start typing. Todays poll shows Labour in the lead again by one point . Who would have thought it given the appalling week they have had and despite the BBC doing its level best to massage the bad ecomomic news. Quattroman will be given a smack on the wrist by his masters .Keep up!!!

Politico's picture

Medhi,
Language is very important part of driving your message forward. You state "Lakoff outlines "a basic principle . . . when you are arguing against the other side: do not use their language. Their language picks out a frame - and it won't be the frame you want."
The attempt to use socio- linguistic theory in your statement only provides an example of the political class reaching out to each other. The problem with Ed Miliband the basic rules he is applying which enables him to engage in speech, that is the ability to communicate, is not understood by the British people. Quite simply his message is not getting through.

Politico's picture

Medhi we can quite easily be distracted and engage in a debate discussing the transformation of information through our knowledge and philosophy in a social and cultural dimensiion, but it no good if the people you are reaching out to do not understand.

Politico's picture

I give up with your spam blocker

Politico's picture

You are perhaps guilty of attempting to reach out to a small group of elite through this News Statesman. Personally I am not impressed
I am working class and I fully understand everything you publish.
You very arrogantly write an article thinking that the readers would not understand or be unable to respond to . How wrong you are.
Try rhetorical devices.

Politico's picture

Without quoting Bernstein (RC and EC), language correlations, deficit theories, whorfian interpretation and especially what is going her "Elitism" Labours language is rteaching out to who? You very much understand the point I impart.

quattro man's picture

Hey Ricky

Check this one out for 19th Jan...it certainly is getting better..just not for Labour.

Tonight’s YouGov poll for the Sun has topline figures of CON 41%, LAB 38%, LDEM 8%. It’s the biggest Conservative lead YouGov have shown since December 2010

Politico's picture

If Ken Livingstone gets elected...which he won't he will be a sad day for Labour. Would have been a great job for alistair Darling.

Londoners do not trust Red Ken. They still him and the regime for the problems we are now facing.

Dave C's picture

Peter Kellner is always a level-headed commentator, basing his opinions on the facts.

It's the politicians manqué like John Rentoul who just keep repeating what they want to believe.

Clem the Gem's picture

The real scandal here is the quality of both candidates. Neither Boris nor Ken are ideal - one is so out of touch that he considers a £250,000 a year stipend from The Telegraph "chickenfeed", and the other has practised special interest politics to an extreme.
On balance, getting rid of Boris would be the best choice we have...

John P Reid's picture

A 1% lead is nothing to write home about.
Le'ts not forget Ken got 1,600,000 second prefernece votes in 2008 when he lost and only 800,000 second preference votes in 2000 when he won, teh 2008 election wasn't BORIS WON IT WAS Ken lost as the Anti Ken vote came ou in srength to oust him, Niw we've seen Boris record he thought he ould cut police, especially from outer london and crime wouldn't rise,well that's where his vote came from, Boris has been a disaster for london, But the tories secret weapon in this campaign is the baggage ken has,

Abraham2's picture

The attempt to use socio- linguistic theory in your statement only provides an example of the political class reaching out to each other. The problem with Ed Miliband the basic rules he is applying which enables him to engage in speech, that is the ability to communicate, is not understood by the British people. http://www.101realestate.net/

Robert Taggart's picture

Lundun going 'red' again ?
More fool Lundun !

richy's picture

cant wait for the Trolls to swamp this blog...wonder what their reasoning shall be?

Ken "buying off" the electorate with his Fare Deal policy? Some islamo-facist conspiracy?

Medhi is bang-on about group think. There are so many examples in westminster: David Miliband HAD to win the labour leadership, Gordon Brown "spent all the money", any move away from Gideons recession inducing spending cuts means "borrowing more that we cant afford"...

Rai's picture

Kalamity Ken has publicly threatened to bring back the abominable bendy bus.

And he still hasn't apolgoised for that condescending horrow show of a meeting with Yusuf Al-Qardawi.

Boris isn't perfect, but Ken Livingstone shames the left. I'd vote for the Monster Raving Loonies before I'd vote for him.

richy's picture

"kalamity Ken"

you dont really have much of an argument there? Scrapping the bendy bus was hardly a pressing priority at a time of spending cuts and rising fares.

Rather than pathetic character assassination, how about a list of Boris's achievements in his four years.....?

Sarmad's picture

With the London riots, the ridicules increase in public transport prices above inflation it is hardly surprising that Londoners have started looking inwards to solving their own problems first. Boris needs a strategy beyond “look how great London is, with our Olympics etc” and needs to look the problem in the face. Without this he will continue this slide.

Rai's picture

Funny you should mention spending cuts because wasn't Ken then one who went on pointless trips abroad to "promote" London, one of the world's most famous cities. Whatever next? A marketing tour for oxygen?

And if the buses aren't a priority, then why does your man plan to spend even MORE money to bring back the bendy buses?

And I'm still not over his embrace of Al-Qardawi. Nick Griffin represents the views of a disenfranchised group too, but I don't see Ken falling all over himself to give him a platform. I do wonder why Griffin's loathesome views are abhorrent and Al-Qardawi's aren't.

Better?

richy's picture

So london was brought to its knees by Ken making trips abroad? Are you telling me that Boris hasn't done this either?

Where do you get your bendy bus information from? Ken has never stated any intention of bringing them back (although he should, it was pure populism getting rid of them).

Still not better, what have Boris's achievements been in 4 years to merit reelection?

quattro man's picture

I guess this just about sums up where Labour are, rock bottom in every other opnion poll. However a tiny lead in one poll is misinterpreted to mean something. Dream on. Boris will win. Ken is history.

richy's picture

quattroman

This just gets better. So labour are rock bottom in every poll? They polled ahead of the Tories in the 17th of Jan Yougov poll...

Yeah Boris will definately win, thats a thorough analysis you have conducted..

David Lindsay's picture

In the race for the position of Mayor of London, the lead has been taken by the candidate who tops the poll for the National Executive Committee of the Labour Party and who openly campaigns for anti-Labour candidates of the Far Left.

He is now ahead of the candidate for whom the London Labour Party's paid staff and their courtier media are campaigning, namely the pro-drugs Conservative, an Ottoman aristocrat of very recent extraction who has publicly recited the Shahada in Arabic, who believes that Christianity overthrew a superior civilisation (slavery, pederasty, the games), and who sees the means to putting things right as being a European Union of which the most populous member-state would be Turkey.

Mayor of London? President of the Third World Banana Republic of London, more like it.

Post new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Latest tweets