Is it a good thing that Diane Abbott has joined the Labour leadership race?
And who else should throw their hat in the ring?
By Mehdi Hasan Published 21 May 2010 11:47
My column in this week's New Statesman examines the Labour leadership race and says that it's time for the two Eds, Miliband Sr and Andy Burnham to "come clean" on their views. As Jon Cruddas has pointed out, do we really know what they stand for? What they believe?
I also have a lighter piece in today's Guardian G2 proclaiming my delight at the decision by Diane Abbott to put herself forward as a candidate for the Labour leadership:
Hooray for Diane Abbott! I never thought I'd write those words. I've been ultra-critical of her in recent days, dismissing Abbott as one of the unreconstructed Labour tribalists who had scuppered any prospects of a post-election deal with the Liberal Democrats and a new "rainbow coalition" of the centre left.
But how grateful I am to the MP for Hackney North and Stoke Newington for entering the Labour leadership race. And to John McDonnell, the secondary-school dropout and son of a bus driver. So far the contest has resembled a City boardroom. Two Eds. Two brothers. Plus Andy Burnham. All of them white, male, fortysomething, Oxbridge graduates.
Was this the best Labour could do, 81 years after the appointment of the first woman cabinet minister, 35 years after the Conservative Party elected a female leader and 23 years after the arrival of the first four ethnic-minority MPs in parliament? Could no suitable female or non-white candidates be found among the 258-strong Parliamentary Labour Party? Perhaps the party needed to appoint itself a diversity czar.
Don't get me wrong. David Miliband, Ed Miliband, Ed Balls and Andy Burnham are all talented candidates. But I can't pretend I wasn't disappointed by the glaring lack of diversity on offer in Labour's first leadership contest for 16 years.
For the record, I didn't pick the headline ("Why I'm glad Diane Abbott has entered the race") and I'm not an Abbott supporter. Nor do I think she has any chance of actually winning.
But here is my question to all of you: are you satisfied with the current crop of Labour leadership candidates? If not, who else would you like to see throw their hat in the ring?
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Jobs
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists

















42 comments
Abdul, I think you have a problem , having read your comments. your comments are clearly ricest ideology. Diane Abbot is within her rights to stand as Labour candidate.
No to the Miliblair twins.
No to Balls-that-once-were-Brown.
No to 'Don't look at me, I'm no racist' Burnham.
Yes to socialist leadership for a socialist party.
Does Diane Abbott help matters? Not if she splits the left MPs, thus preventing both herself and John McDonnell from getting onto the ballot.
Indeed, you have to ask yourself whether her candidacy - which no one thinks will leave Abbott as party leader - is actually designed to stymie McDonnell, thereby making sure his name does not appear on the ballot as a left-wing alternative to the No-Labour and Next-No-Labour candidates.
I hope the all get the support they need as this may trun out to be the most fascinating leadership contest Labour has ever had. David Miliband is a Blairite, Ed Balls is a Brownite, Andy Burnham and Ed Miliband are both likeable with a number of female admirers, John McDonnell is old Labour through and through, then last but not Diane Abbott as most people will warm to her easily as she has a vibrant personality.
I'd like to see Hilary Benn MP throw his hat into the ring. An excellent constituency MP for Leeds, Hilary made his ministerial mark in international development. I for one would throw my support behind HB.
I think Abbott's bid for the leadership is a distraction. It would be like Bill Cash running for the tory leadership.
She cannot win for various reasons and Labour already has a scheming feminist in the Deputy Leadership anyway.
For this leadership campaign to be a success the party must assert it's core beliefs (without drifting too much to the left).
As soon as the new Leader is in place HE must quickly hold this shotgun marriage of a coalition to account.
Dear Mervyn Drage -
The very last thing that The Labour movement needs is "Marxist-Lenninist education". As someone who is a recivering Lenninist, and had generations of my family in the old CPGB, could I just ask, when will you learn?
Whilst the Marxist critique of capitalism has a lot going for it, and Marxian Historiography much to admire, every single application of your creed has led to slaughter, oppression and torture. Not least for the workers.
As the origional Clem the Gem said: "Soviet Communism is the illegitimate child of Karl Marx and Catherine The Great".
As for Dianne, I am all for her standing, and for a left vote that is as high as possible. Please dont forget the other positions up for grabs, like treasurer - a key post within the Party when it comes to re-building our strength.
The left will never control the Labour Party entirely, but at this time, our voice should be heard, after all, it wasnt us who started all the backstabbing and infighting, was it?
Abdul, if you don't like her, you did not need to get all personal and nasty. She is not the best candidate by all means but we should welcome the variety she brings as it will make the contest more interesting. If she and John McDonnell were not in it, then the contest would be a damp squib with David Miliband walking it.
Have you ever seen her on the TV with Portillo? Usually just giggling and simpering at his side on the sofa and rarely anything intelligent to say to warrant her about £1k appearance fee. The sooner they get someone to replace her to present a serious socialist commentary the better.
I don't think it matters that only a certain type of candidate had put themselves forward - it's not like women or anybody older than 45-or-so were banned, it's just that until John McDonnell and Diane Abbott nobody outside that range had put themselves forward.
I'm glad they're standing, because it shushes the all the people who are moaning about the lack of diversity, but I don't think that the leadership race should be based on what you look like.
The fact is that although the Milibands, Balls and Burnham are similar in terms of age and ethnicity, they're all slightly more diverse in terms of their policies.
Since the majority of Labour supporters were bleating on about "substance over style" throughout the general election campaign, I'm surprised how quickly they've all ditched it.
Much as I cringed to hear her kid was in private school, I know she does a lot of good stuff and if she was leader, I'd vote Labour for the second time ever (Green except 97, sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry).
Enjoyed the article, Mehdi, and agreed with what you were saying. A shame that you used the epithet "hard left" to describe Abbott though. The real dogmatists are on the right of the Parliamentary party, and her views on many subjects are closer to the centre ground, as defined by public opinion, than those of the Labour frontbench - Iraq being just one obvious example.
Dear Clem the Gem,
That is absolute nonsense my dear boy
Its a shame such a high proportion of the PLP are required to sponsor each. It limits the field at this stage, preventing the possibility of a dark horse candidate coming through in the end.
I'd ike to see someone like Bob crow or Mark Serwotka
or Jeremy Corbyn ,seeing as how he's a labour party member/mp (not sure about the other 2)Any they have to be firebrands and lefty to the max
oh and it's very difficult to sign off with out saying aah you're a effing jerk
I dont suppose anyone read the Evening Standard when Abbott announced she was joining the race? Some of the comments left after the article were shockingly racist. Seems there are still plenty of unreconstructed viewpoints in England about the thought of a black party leader....
The fact that Diane Abbott is more than 10 years older than her Labour leader hopefuls and also Cameron and Clegg, whom she'll be competing against in the next election if she wins the leadership, is a negative point, unfortunately. It'll be too easy to portray her as not being as energetic and vibrant etc as the males.
'...23 years after the first ethnic minority MPs...'
err no, in fact more than century after, have a look at the Operation Black Vote website, or maybe wikipedia, check those 'facts' please, try Peter Fryer's 'Staying Power' for instance, but please learn some REAL history before you make ludicrous statements that deny the long, long history of ethnic minority participation in British democracy
I really think Harriet should make way as Deputy Leader for a younger woman like Dianne. I see Dianne as a Prescott Figure, stirring the troops into battle and keeping the Party together by sheer physical force of personality and bluster. The Labour Party needs a bruiser, and I think we've found one. She'll also be able to throw in some left wing ideas into the debate.
Thanks, Mehdi
If I had my way, the political spectrum would be defined by the range of public opinion, which would be the democratic approach. Polls on a range of issues suggest that would place most of the political class squarely on the right.
I think you will find that the first BME MP was not elected in 1987 but in fact in 1892. His name was Dadabhai Naoroji and was elected as the MP for Finsbury Central. Get your facts straight.
Abdul, eh stop hiding behind that ridiculous name of yours, you're probably very white and from some distinctly tory stronghold, it's only a front so you can get away with your very bigotted and racist views on people like Diane Abbot, leave out the personal stuff and go and do something useful eh?
Now onto the more serious stuff, I think it's a reasonable line up. It's good for diversity that Diane is up for it, she's got some very good views but I think sitting on the sofa too long with Portillo has probably lessened her chances of being taken seriously. It's between the two Milliband's, at first I thought David but now I'm thinking the other one. Like it or not we've got to go with someone with public appeal who comes over as though they mean what they say and has the backing of the party, they'll see him as sensible, well balanced and level headed; unlike the cam n clegg conjoined twins who'll be crying out for a separation under the NHS before too long, let's hope they've not demolished it before the surgeon puts them on the table!
Hi Mehdi
I think Caroline Flint and Lucuana B would be my other choices as they seems to be good women too.
Well I take my hat off to Diane for making that commitment to show diverse Laborites, multicultural families and young people who wants to get in to politics in UK that education hard work and commitment deliver good public servants. It is ok to go to Oxford! It is ok to go Cambridge! It is ok to go to a private school. Those things were called as virus by some just to keep working class at a bay. You can go to some of those prestige institution and still delver good public services you don’t’ have to be selling your soul just because you been to public schools or good universities. Most of the common wealth leaders come from those prestigious universities and they are doing fine !
She also lay the message to young people that carrier choice is not only be limited only be a footballer, musician or doctor, Lawyer or Gangster Raps star and the to be in a video to make it in to the future! To be able to make decent living and have the recognition you can also be a politician and topnotch one!
The politically dissolute men and women who are those we met during the campaign trail, the men and women I met during the Barking and Dagenham campaign, the men and women I met in Stoke, he told me that they do not think that they can break the glass ceiling, Well this is a clear message that Game On! That’s the mantra you keep hearing can be broken. The chain links have been broken. She gives us the message of hope! Trust in politics again that we can be trusted!
That is that if you keep up at your work, work hard and be smart you can make the changes you want to make. It is not about wining it is about taking part playing your role as a inspirational leader. I also think that she is saving the Labour PLP women and our memberships.
Most of the great women one I admired Hillary Armstrong, Estelle Morris gave up during the BlairBrown period. Choose! Then having woman DPM and Brow as PM we didn’t get enough BAME candidates as they promised! Within winnable seats, it is all gone white 40's something Oxbridge men and women who have naked ambition to be an MP. I also noticed that on leadership was a coronation the women decided not to contest. Perhaps they lost in the system with many men who would have been better leaders!
Some of them didn’t act on time! They kept everyone who was on the top table happy with trigger happy consciousness by not rocking the boat. Indecisive! Results are that we back on the opposition bench with 29% vote after been in the power for 13 years! I like d the way Caroline tried so hard to fit in and in the end gave it up with dignity. So she should have been my other preferential candidate but she is not taken up the chance.
Therefore Labor failed to produce good caliber women to take on. However good on Diane and it is about time you become a serious politician do the thing you are born to do!
We've already had a black leader in England, albiet 1800 years ago! Septimius Severus, a North African Libyan, ruled England as Roman Emperor between 193-211 AD.
It's a pity that Ken Livingstone is no longer a MP as he'd be a very good candidatee. I second the comment about Jeremy Corbyn, a great MP, but with Dianne and John Mc in the race we've possibly got enough lefties. Hilary Benn is another good shout but he performed badly in the deputy leadership race probably because he foolishly continued to support the Iraq invasion. The most important thing now is that either Dianne or John Mc get on the ballot paper.
Fabulous, Diane Abbott running to be the Leader of Labour.
I nearly fell out of my chair when I saw 'This Week'. I like Diane Abbott very much and hope she wins the leadership race. Marvellous!!
Lammy should put his name in the hat!
@Abdul Amir Hassan you are moronic and rude.
@ Trotty, I'll second that! My guess is that almost everyone else on here would as well!
The reason for supporting her is because she is right and the others are wrong.
I would still like to hear more from her on economic questions however-what isthe best source for what she has had to say about the economic crisis?
Seriously, to all those who actually engage him - don't. Such a pity the NS doesn't have an account system for posters: that way they could block 'Abdul Amir Hassan'. Instead, it's up to us - just ignore him. Don't feed the troll! That's what he wants!
thanks al ,it's so hard to let him /it get away with it
Come on new statesman improve your system get a mod on to rid us of this appalling burke
i come on here to learn from/engage with other like minded lefties
get rid of AAH please
Diane Abbott sold her soul to that trashy politics show she fronts with Neil and Portillo. Nothing to do with gender, she just is not good enough. Please remember that Westminster remains the preserve of the white, male,middle classes. I hope some female Labour candidates step forward, however.
BUBBLY, GIFTED AND BLACK.
She is certainly not New Labour.
Personally however I have lost interest in elitist, corrupt Parliamentary politics.
The MP's all swear allegiance to the Queen and therefore support the state apparatus and capitalism.
Britain needs a socialist republic run by the workers.
If the Labour Party is ever to emerge as a socialist mass based organisation fit for power and Government, it needs to eject all the highly educated pro capitalist morons and hangers on who currently dominate the party.
It needs to engage in the real lives of ordinary people and workers who are struggling to survive during the monopoly capitalist slump.
I personally think the Labour project is a lost cause after Brown and Blair turned it into a party of the ruling class and bankers; they turned it into a party of mass unemployment and imperialist wars.
They got rid of Clause 4 and turned Labour into bourgeois liberal outfit.
We should campaign hard for the trade unions to finally ditch the Labour traitors and supporters of the system.
I think we need to work from the grass roots and re establish a strong, disciplined Marxist Leninist Communist Party in Britain.
We need to ditch Labour, Trotskyism and revisionism in our struggle for socialism and power of state for the workers.
We need a Soviet Britain not a liberal, weak British Road to Socialism.
We need to make the Morning Star an attractive newspaper for the oppressed and the workers.
At the moment the Morning Star is dominated by the CPB clique made up of comfortable trade union officials and teachers.
Very few oppressed people or workers read the rag at present.
We need Marxist Leninist political education, dialectical and historical materialism, democratic centralism and the dictatorship of the proletariat.
Placed in a contemporary context in the struggle against US and British imperialism, Zionism and monopoly finance capitalism.
In international affairs we should support Cuba, the DPRK and all anti imperialist countries such as Iran, Brazil and Venezualia.
We need to challenge the anti communist, anti worker lies and propaganda of the bourgeois mass media including the BBC which is the organ of the establishment.
In education we need to kick out liberalism and idealist concepts, and introduce dialectical and historical materialism.
Post new comment