Welcome to the New Statesman website. Please sign in or register to participate in the conversation.

Mehdi Hasan

Mehdi Hasan’s polemical take on politics, economics and foreign affairs

Syndicate contentRSS

Does the left have an adequate answer to violent crime?

The death of a pensioner I knew has shaken me

The Daily Mail reports:

A devout Muslim pensioner attacked by a race-hate gang of schoolboys has died.

Ekram Haque, 67, lost his fight for life a week after he was battered to the ground in front of his three-year-old granddaughter, Marian.

As revealed in today's Daily Mail, he suffered horrific head injuries in the assault outside a mosque in Tooting, south-west London, where he had just prayed.

As he and Marian waited for a lift, the gang ran up behind him and clubbed him around the head.

Two other worshippers chased the thugs away but Mr Haque -- described by friends as a 'gentle giant' -- had suffered horrific head injuries.

His granddaughter has been left "very shaken and disturbed", said her father, Mr Haque's son Arfan. Graphic images of the attack were caught on CCTV.

Scotland Yard formally launched a murder inquiry after Mr Haque passed away at St George's Hospital, Tooting, where he had been on a life-support machine since the attack.

Police are linking the assault on the retired care worker to a series of other attacks on elderly Asian people near the mosque.

I'm an occasional worshipper at that mosque in Tooting and I had heard on the grapevine, before it hit the newspapers, that an elderly man had been attacked outside it by a gang of youths on bank holiday Monday, after a Ramadan event. Yet until I saw his picture in the papers over the weekend, I didn't even think that I might know who Mr Haque was -- but I do. I knew him. Not personally. We weren't friends. But I'd seen him around the place and we'd exchanged pleasantries in the past. Now he's dead, killed in a mindless act of violence; killed while minding his own business on a south London street corner, with his three-year-old granddaughter watching. Unbelievable.

And even more unbelievable is this, from the BBC:

Four boys, aged 12, 15 and two 14-year-olds, have been charged with conspiracy to commit grievous bodily harm (GBH).

All four are also accused of attacking two other men before the attack on Mr Haque. The four boys will appear at Sutton Youth Court on Tuesday.

Police are now treating the death of Mr Haque as murder.

All four boys face two counts of actual bodily harm (ABH) in connection with the attack on the two men, one in his forties and the other in his seventies, on 31 August.

How on earth can a 12-year-old allegedly carry out such a brutal attack? How are kids across Britain becoming killers? I hate to sound like Melanie Phillips or Chris Grayling, but isn't there something wrong with a society that produces such disturbed children?

Crime makes right-wingers of us of all. Whenever you hear stories like this, you feel a mixture of emotions: sadness, pity, depression, despair but, above all else, anger -- especially when the victim is someone you know. I can't tell you how angry I am right now. So are friends of mine who are regulars at that mosque in Tooting. They, like me, are filled with rage. One of them emailed me to say he wished a pack of Rottweilers could be unleashed upon the four youths who have been arrested so far (and who, incidentally, have not yet been found guilty of any crime).

It is an understandable reaction. But while we all, in our calmer and rational moments, acknowledge that state-sponsored violence against child criminals is immoral and pointless -- it doesn't bring the dead back to life, nor does it teach young offenders the difference between right and wrong -- there is a huge problem here for the left to address. It is the "Broken Britain" theme, on which the Tories have so successfully capitalised. It is worth revisiting a New Statesman leader from a fortnight ago:

There is . . . a profound and genuine sense, across economic classes and geographic regions in Britain, of a public dissatisfaction, even anger, at the coarsening of our public culture and the slow degradation of our urban spaces. Britain is not a "broken" society as the Tories would have it in their resonant slogan, but there is civic disengagement and a widespread perception that something is not quite right in society at large.

. . . Labour ministers, so adept at robotically rehearsing national statistics on crime, unemployment, income and the rest even as they help to create the most unequal society since the Second World War, ignore at their peril . . .public anxiety about social disorder.

The left, I believe, needs a strong, wide-ranging but balanced narrative on violent crime, and youth offending, that goes beyond the obvious socio-economic factors to explore the growing moral and cultural void at the heart of modern British society. Indeed, the left needs to reclaim the language of morality.

 

9 comments

atropos1's picture

Dear Medhi. "Crime makes right-wingers of us of all"
It is not a right wing emotion to feel sickened by heinous occurances such as the senseless murder of a harmless old man, but a natural reaction shared by any and every balanced human being of whatever political persuasion. There are times when ideology is not enough, and we should be able to stand together and mourn in a common humanity rather than look for political advantage. Though a Tory, I share your grief over a man meeting an untimely death. I hope you can accept that.

Praguetory's picture

Incidents sch as this are unfortunately legion in our so-called civilised society, it's a shame that it has to be an event close to you before you managed to empathise.

You say the 'Left' needs to reclaim the language of morality. I agree in theory. In practice it is the left that has been gnawing away at morality and those who profess morality for decades. Move over - you've had your chance. Britain is broken and a proper law n order Conservative and right government unafraid to set boundaries, support people in authority and punish wrongdoing can fix things (not sure Cameron's government hasd the necessary steel). Sincere condolences to the family. How could the attackers commit such a monstrosity?

Bernard's picture

Yeah right prague. The UK was virtually crime free until 1997. The underlying issue is inequality, massive, miserable inequality. It has continued to get worse because this faux-left government has followed Tory economics for 12 years. Jackboots won't fix it. It will only get worse. Move your shares into electric fences old boy.

Praguetory's picture

Bernard, I missed the part of my post which involved jackboots. I have worked in and visited many places with far greater inequality than Tooting. that do not experience such problems. This crime has nothing to do with inequality, but it probably has got something to do with a lack of trust-community spirit, public failure to intervene re small incidents and broken families.

The idea that this crime would have been prevented by giving the parents of these kids more money is ludicrous. Got any other solutions?

a.m.r.'s picture

From my perspective, as an immigrant to the UK, the transformation of Britain from a still racist to a comfortably multi-racial country took place in the 1980's and 90's, under Margaret Thatcher and the Conservatives - the focus on working and succeeding, rather than obsessions about class and race, seemed to help a lot, as well as the greater prosperity effected by the economic change.

I find this ironic, because it was the Left (although not exclusively) that had been fighting against racial discrimination.

margaretwilson's picture

What the article doesn't mention is that the thugs who did this particular race attack were apparently black. Why does the media highlight the rare cases when whites commit racist attacks but not react the same way in cases such as this?

ScottBronstein1's picture

Praguetory.

The idea that the Left has had its chance is laughable. When? I don’t remember seeing a Left-wing government anywhere in the last thirty years. In fact – when has there ever been a truly Left-wing government? The closest being Attlee’s 1945 government.

It is the draconian policies of the Right that have driven politics ever since Thatcher came to power. With the cult of the individual and promotion of selfishness that the neo-liberal consensus has espoused for thirty years, and ever growing inequality, the sense of community has been lost. With teenagers finding themselves ever marginalised as criminals by the press and media it isn’t so hard to see where things are going wrong, and with the growing racism towards Muslims – that comes from both the government and the media – it will continue to do so.

If you want to tackle the horrors of rising violent crime – and race-related violence – a further lurch to the Right is not the answer. In fact, as the more severe and naked Capitalism becomes, so does society seem to be breaking down. Only by socialising the system will we be able to make improvements and bring back the so badly missed sense of community.

Praguetory's picture

Scott B - Living in East Europe I have seen the consequences of a government trying to 'socialise the system' and the expanded freedoms that followed regime change. Try again.

Post new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Latest tweets