Registered user login:

Bright'sBlog

Bright's Blog

Politics uncovered by Martin Bright, New Statesman political editor

Bright's Blog Homepage

Sunday Roundup - 10 August 2008

  • Posted by Martin Bright
  • 10 August 2008

A weekly look at the politics stories in the Sunday newspapers

A good start from Toby Helm, the new Whitehall Editor of The Observer with a story about the trade union dream ticket of Jon Cruddas and Alan Johnson. The idea is that the unions feel this is the only way to stop David Miliband and a perceived return to Blairite free market fundamentalism. So there is now a pincer movement from the left and right to replace Gordon Brown. Is the game really definitively up?

The unions are misreading Miliband, who is not a Blairite in the classic sense at at all. Indeed, many on Blairite wing of the party are worried that he is far too much of a centralising social democrat. The truth is that David Miliband is just much less of a "bloke" than Cruddas or Johnson. However, there is now little doubt that the battle for the soul of the party will take place between the centre-right Compass group, which sees Cruddas as its leader and the centre-right forces gathering around Miliband.

Matthew d'Ancona has written a very well-informed column about the state of the rebellion. He accuses the rebels of being a "bunch of wusses", which is about right. But this is, after all, the Adrian Mole generation, so what do you expect.

John Rentoul on the Independent on Sunday and Andrew Rawnsley on the Observer appear to be away. Alan Watkins gives some important historical perspective, as usual. Unlike most commentators, Watkins thought Brown would have lost the elction if he had gone to the country last October. But clearly not as badly as if he went now. One scenario outlined by Watkins is that of Brown bowing out before Labour Party conference with the NEC and the Cabinet left to appoint and acting Prime Minister. Now who would that be, I wonder? Jack Straw, Margaret Beckett, Harriet Harman? It's all too grisly for words.

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

1 comment from readers

BegbiesEvilTwin
12 August 2008 at 02:12

Perhaps it's not a misunderstanding of the unions but more of a case that they have very little evidence to make a balanced case. My impression is that Miliband hasn't bothered to establish a meaningful relationship with them. Factoring in his close inks with Campbell, Gould and Blair it seems like not an unreasonable assumption to make.

To me Miliband's recent article attributed to be his stake in a leadership challenge had the typical rhetoric of a typical Blair speech. As one of Blair's former speechwriters that's hardly a surprising but as part of a campaign to make him stand out from the others he really should have taken the opportunity to distinguish himself from the Ancien Régime then he doesn't deserve the support of the unions.

Initially the Cruddas-Johnson ticket sounded quite interesting. It seems quite novel to have a leader who has a good grounding in politics both in practice and academically. Both have a particular weaknesses though. Cruddas has previously expressed (paraphrase) that he was never keen on being in the public eye. Over the last 10-15 years the times I have observed Johnson at various things he always gave me the impression of holding his cards a bit too close to his chest and something not entirely comfortable with himself. Even in the last 10 days he has been described in one publication as 'opaque'.

Still, it looks like they are the best of a sad, bad and spineless bunch.

Hmm...if they win the leadership I wonder if Neal Lawson will be offered a position?

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before your comment is displayed on the website

You may enter up to 2000 characters (about 300-350 words)

Characters left:

We want to encourage people to comment on our content and to exchange views with other readers and hope this will be done on a courteous basis. However, if you encounter posts which are offensive please let us know by emailing comments@newstatesman.co.uk and we will take swift action where necessary.

About the writer

Martin Bright

Martin Bright began his journalistic career writing in very simple English for a magazine aimed at French school children. This experience has informed his style ever since. He worked for the BBC World Service, and The Guardian before joining the Observer as Education Correspondent. He went on to become Home Affairs Editor before becoming the New Statesman's political editor in 2005.

Recent Posts

The travelling man

  • By Martin Bright
  • 20 November 2008

Sunday comment round-up -- 16 November 2008

  • By Martin Bright
  • 16 November 2008

Recession blues

  • By Martin Bright
  • 13 November 2008

Two elections a world apart

  • By Martin Bright
  • 08 November 2008

Leaders-in-waiting

  • By Martin Bright
  • 06 November 2008

Why I'm on the outside

  • By Martin Bright
  • 30 October 2008

George and Mandy Go Wild on Corfu

  • By Martin Bright
  • 23 October 2008