Return to: Home | Blogs | Bright's Blog

Shiv Malik -- latest

Mixed (but on the whole good) news from the hearing into whether a journalist should hand over his notes to Greater Manchester Police

Congratulations to Shiv Malik for challenging the production order from Greater Manchester Police demanding material relating to the book he has been writing with ex-jihadi sympathiser Hassan Butt.

Although the hearing at the high court decided that the order was right in principle, it said its terms were drawn too broadly. Shiv now faces a new hearing.

Whatever happens, he has confirmed that journalists can challenge such orders, even in terrorist cases and established the principle that the police should not be allowed to trawl through journalistic material looking for evidence.

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

4 comments from readers

redharry
20 June 2008 at 13:16

'ex-jihadi sympathiser Hassan Butt'

but Martin, Butthead has confessed to making it all up.

http://www.daily.pk/world/europe/81-europe/4207--hassan-butt...

others had smelled a rat earlier

http://www.aim.org/guest-column/was-cbs-duped-by-radical-isl...

Butt's book would have been as genuine as the receipts forged by your neo-con/RCP mates at the Policy Exchange.

http://www.cpgb.org.uk/worker/722/borisspiked.html

ps I keep asking you about Dean Godson's libel writ against Newsnight, but you never reply. Was it lost in the post?

http://www.policyexchange.org.uk/Press.aspx?id=476

They made the libel threat on 13/12/2007 - that's six months ago.

pps

What are you doing giving interviews to a racist website?

http://podcast.shirenetworknews.net/:entry:tuatara-2008-06-11-0000/

owenblacker
20 June 2008 at 14:28

Now I know I shouldn't feed the troll, but how can someone simultaneously be of the Revolutionary Communist Party and a neoconservative (or neoliberal)?

I'm pretty sure about the only thing Milton Friedman and Stalin would have agreed on was the wanton use of torture, murder, kidnapping and disappearance to silence those who get in the way of one's plans.

redharry
20 June 2008 at 18:29

If owenblacker had bothered to click on the links provided, he would have found that the RCPers of Spiked (eg Munira Mirza ) had joined Martin's neo-comrades at the Policy Exchange in forming Boris Johnson's administration.

Although I disagreed utterly with Milton Friedman's economic theories, he never supported torture, murder etc. What's your evidence?

There are worse things to be other than a troll - an idiot for one.

owenblacker
26 August 2008 at 11:08

Sorry, I tend to have better things to do than click every link on every comment by every person who looks like a troll.

Perhaps redharry could do with familiarising himself with the history of South and Central America throughout the 1980s. Naomi Klein's latest book would probably be a good grounding — a little histrionic and oversimplified, as Ms Klein's work can tend to be, imho, but a good start on why Milton Friedman caused immense suffering and death across the globe with his ridiculous economic theories.

Post your comment

(Your email address will not be published)

Recent Posts

The horror comes home

22 January 2009 09:58

Ken Clarke's return

19 January 2009 16:10

A New Deal of the mind

15 January 2009 09:31

It's a New New Deal

08 January 2009 09:51

A year of ups and downs

18 December 2008 09:44

Mystic Mart

15 December 2008 13:06

The two-man show

11 December 2008 09:44

Past Entries

Follow this blog

Vote!

Should we build new nuclear power plants?

Suggest a question

View comments

© New Statesman 1913 – 2009

Tracker