The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Autism should never be used as a political insult

We condemned George Osborne; we should condemn France's Europe minister, too

When George Osborne suggested that Gordon Brown could be "faintly autistic" there was justified outrage. The shadow chancellor was rebuked by Labour and Lib Dem politicians and other public figures, including Nick Hornby, who memorably remarked: "George Osborne doesn't seem to have noticed that most people over the age of eight no longer use serious and distressing disabilities as a way of taunting people."

Osborne wasn't the first. The Tory MP Peter Viggers, now best known for his duck house, was forced to apologise when he described Brown as "financially autistic".

Now the French minister for Europe, Pierre Lellouche, speaking to the Guardian, has accused William Hague of a "bizarre autism" in their discussions. The increasing use of autism as a political pejorative is disturbing. If we allow conditions such as this to be used as synonyms for social and political ills, we create a new layer of prejudice against sufferers.

The same applies to other mental or physical conditions. I won't use "sclerotic" to refer to a stagnant economy. I won't use "schizophrenic" to describe variable weather.

It is essential for the liberal left to condemn Lellouche (however reasonable his other remarks) as strongly as it condemned Osborne. Anything else, and past complaints will just look like political opportunism.

7 comments

Tom's picture

Oh, hang on a minute - if as many people suspect, Gordon Brown could have a diagnosis of Aspergers Syndrome, would he not be seen as a role model ? Boris Johnston with his bumbling professor, eccentric, soup down the tie image is uncannily like many people with Aspergers.

British comedy is full of people who might be diagnosed with Autistic Spectrum Disorder - literal, poor social skills, funny voice - Mr Bean, Frank Spencer.

"I won't use "schizophrenic" to describe variable weather." - who on earth would use such a strange phrase?

But as someone who's son suffers from both ASD and epilepsy, I'd like to say he's not being helped by people who refuse to use the word "brainstorming". Really it's not a problem, and diverts attention away from the real issues.

John Hopkins's picture

George Eaton claims “If we allow conditions such as this to be used as synonyms for social and political ills, we create a new layer of prejudice against sufferers.”

Do tell us George, does this apply to all adjectives used to describe human attributes? I mean, am I forbidden to describe a building as “ugly” on the grounds that this increases prejudice against ugly people?

Please, please, please let us have your full set of rules for the use of the English language. On receipt of same, I’ll waste no time in using it as toilet paper.

Sally C's picture

Not quite the James MacIntyre school of [non] journalism but still off base.

George Osborne did not decsribe GB as 'autistic'. Someone suggested Geoerge Osborne was autistic and he joked that they must be confusing him with GB
.
Not the best comment but an off the cuff retort to someone insulting him is rather different to someone using the term unprovoked against someone else.

So your attempt at even handedness - though welcome - still fails.

But for The New Statesman, its a big leap forward.

vanrisszcu's picture

Does the "C" stand for Conservative, Sally?

Yakoub's picture

As a parent of a teenage son with autism, I find any pejorative use of the autism offensive. Perhaps it's worth remembering that children with autism are the largest group appealing to special education tribunals and over 90% of UK adults with autistic spectrum disorders are unemployed, with the rate for the group with Asperger Syndrome (normal IQ and language development) not much lower. People with autism remain marginalised in Britain. Politicians and all responsible public figures should be challenging that marginalisation, not affirming it.

Yakoub's picture

As a parent of a teenage son with autism, I find any pejorative use of the term autism offensive. Perhaps it's worth remembering that children with autism are the largest group represented in appeals to special education tribunals and over 90% of UK adults with autistic spectrum disorders are unemployed, with the rate for the group with Asperger Syndrome (normal IQ and language development) not much lower. People with autism remain marginalised in Britain. Politicians and all responsible public figures should be challenging that marginalisation, not affirming it.

Latest tweets