Registered user login:

Elections2008

Elections 2008

Newstatesman.com's unrivalled analysis of the key local and London mayoral elections 2008

Elections 2008 Homepage

Labour's worst results in 40 years

  • Posted by Ben Davies
  • 02 May 2008

Labour is badly hit in local elections in England and Wales pushed into third place by Tories and Lib Dems

Labour is in “listening and learning” mode after suffering what are widely predicted to be its worst election results in 40 years - beaten by Tories and Lib Dems into third place.

Across England and Wales the Tories made gains hitting hard into areas traditionally seen as Labour’s heartlands.

Labour deputy leader Harriet Harman got the dubious honour of trekking around the studios on Friday morning as the party licked its wounds.

She told the BBC’s Today programme: “It’s very disappointing indeed.” Pointing to the current economic challenges such as high food and fuel prices plus growing concern about the financial and housing sectors, she added: “People feel the situation is affecting them very personally - sometimes at elections there are political overarching things happening in the world.

“We have to listen and learn.”

David Cameron’s Conservatives meanwhile were celebrating as Labour’s results were being compared to another local election - 1995 - when an unequivocal verdict on John Major’s premiership would translate two years later into wipeout for the Tories.

This time though the Conservatives had something to celebrate. Their gains included taking control of a number of councils induding Southampton, Harlow, Bury and Maidstone.

In Wales, meanwhile, Labour’s Rhodri Morgan acknowledged the tide seemed to have turned strongly against Labour with defeats in Methyr Tydfil, Blaenau Gwent and Torfaen.

In Norwich there was good news for the Greens where they became the second biggest party.

In Liverpool, the Lib Dems defied predictions and seem to have clung on to power after signing up an independent just after the returning officer had announced the council had gone to no overall control. They also took St Albans.

All this and the results for the London mayoral and assembly contest have yet to come in - they are due on Friday evening. The question is will they be the icing on David Cameron’s cake or will Ken Livingstone salvage something from what has been a highly disappointing set of results for Labour?

Whatever happens, Gordon Brown has just two years to neutralise this Tory momentum and turn Labour's fortunes around.


Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

6 comments from readers

Carl Jones
02 May 2008 at 10:32

At best, it looks like a hung parliament after the next election....was it worth getting rid of Kennedy to avoid an out come which now looks likely? Ken`s ballot papers are being counted in three locations by machine....lets hope they aren`t hackable,lol

Admin
02 May 2008 at 11:57

Was that Robert Kennedy or John, Carl?

Ben Davies.

Carl Jones
02 May 2008 at 23:09

LOL....I was tempted to say "Nigel" Kennedy, but you aren`t worthy of such humor, or tune. In context to the subject and a hung parliament.....(still not got it?).....I was refering to Charles Kennedy. Now Ben, its 3.00pm, so its time to go home.:)

I`d rather be nice, but I don`t believe you are upto it....all rather sad, but I don`t have the "Dark Forces" looking over my shoulder....but then again, maybe I do.LOL

knave
03 May 2008 at 08:24

Would a coalition be that bad.

Vincent cable as CofE for tories or labour wouldn't be that bad.

TheElitesWin
03 May 2008 at 13:18

Reports keep stating that it was the abolishment of the 10% tax thats caused Labour's downfall. The fact is, people rebelled for a lot more reasons, i.e. no referendum on the treaty of Lisbon, they way they have raised stealth taxes, the way the Gordon Brown forces other MP's to vote on his ideas and thoughts, the invitation of Ed Balls at the Bilderberg group meeting in Toronto Canada, the vast amount of money Labour MP's have swindled out of the tax payer and must more. It's not just about the 10% tax!

Sandy Franzen
03 May 2008 at 15:17

LOCAL ELECTIONS?

I am disappointed that the local elections have been used by the major parties and the media as a mini general election. There has been little focus on local issues and the performance of councils and councillors. In Irlam and Cadishead (2 wards in Salford) the Community Action Party worked hard for the community and blasted Labour councillors for complacency and inactivity on local issues. As a result they won in Irlam defeating the Labour chair of the Greater Manchester passenger Transport Authority. He was a champion for bringing the congestion charge into the North west and a front man for Wigan Labour leader Lord Smith who lost 4 more seats in Wigan down 30 in just four years. That is about local politics sending a message to Whitehall. Could it be a start to the end of the congestion charge spreading beyond London due to the efforts of the Community Action Party? The local Tories and some Lib Dem councils are still sitting on the congestion charge fence in Greater Manchester, maybe now they can make a decision.

Ex Councillor Sandy Franzen

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before your comment is displayed on the website

We want to encourage people to comment on our content and to exchange views with other readers and hope this will be done on a courteous basis. However, if you encounter posts which are offensive please let us know by emailing comments@newstatesman.co.uk and we will take swift action where necessary.

About the writer

Ben Davies

Ben Davies trained as a journalist after taking most of the 1990s off. Prior to joining the New Statesman he spent five years working as a politics reporter for the BBC News website. He lives in North London.

Recent Posts

Is this what a police state looks like?

  • By Claire Provost
  • 03 May 2008

Life after Ken

  • By Ben Davies
  • 03 May 2008

Allegiances are fluid after a decade of Labour

  • By Nick Clegg
  • 02 May 2008

On course for a Green MP...

  • By Caroline Lucas
  • 02 May 2008

Covering the coverage

  • By Paul Evans
  • 02 May 2008

Alun Michael: a concession was painted as a climbdown

  • By Ben Davies
  • 02 May 2008

Smith: London could fall to Boris

  • By Ben Davies
  • 02 May 2008