Crackdown on crisis loans is simultaneously dystopian and Victorian

Tesco-only crisis loans, and paternalism for the poor. Marvellous.

A food bank in upstate New York. Photograph: Getty Images
A food bank in upstate New York. Photograph: Getty Images

The Guardian reports on the expected deluge in demand for crisis help, which is leading a number of councils to invest unconventional measures for helping those most at need.

Patrick Butler writes:

Cuts next year to the social fund, which provides emergency aid to vulnerable people, mean that from April 2013 many councils will no longer be able to provide cash help to applicants. Instead they will offer "in kind" support such as referring clients to food banks and issuing electronic food vouchers.

Crisis loans – short-term financial aid for people in dire need – cost £230m in 2009-2010, but the coalition has devolved responsibility for the loans in England to councils, while simultaneously cutting the pot back to 2005 levels.

This means that the days of simply being handed the money you need to make it to the next pay day are over.

Instead, poor people should look forward to being treated as though they can't be trusted with money.

Butler writes:

Conservative-run Kensington and Chelsea council in London is proposing to issue credit-card style vouchers – or "gift cards" – in lieu of crisis loans, enabling recipients to buy items at certain shops, likely to be big retailers such as Tesco, Argos and Sainsbury's. Some councils will put blocks on the cards preventing the purchase of alcohol and cigarettes. . .

Households who would previously have been eligible for a community care cash grant will be instead offered vouchers for reconditioned beds, cookers and fridges redeemable at furniture recycling charities.

But it is the plans to refer crisis loan applicants to food banks that will cause most controversy.

Crisis loans distributed in the form of gift cards which can only be redeemed in Tesco is the stuff of dystopian sci-fi, and giving poor people money while preventing them from spending it on alcohol and cigarettes is straight out of the Victorian age.

If you can help it, probably best to try and not be poor for a while.

6 comments

groc's picture

...and in the other corner MPs are still able to claim expenses for a fully furnished second London home, but 'claimants' are to be penalized for having a spare room, with food vouchers claimants are to be restricted in what they can buy (definitely no alcohol and no cigarettes) but MPs have their tax-payer subsidized bars and restaurants - and a well stocked wine cellar - and the Lords get £300 a day just to turn up and have a snooze. There is something very wrong with this picture.

zagbah's picture

'The poor can't be trusted with money', says some patronising git who, from hearing a couple of people talking about spending their crisis loans on a night out, then assumes that every poor person must naturally be financially irresponsible. Well, after bills and rent, transport costs and food, I would spend my crisis loans on paying more bills, extra food, extra transport costs and putting money in the gas and electric meters. So if some moron wants to smugly think that we poor cannot make good financial decisions, let him think it.

Simon Gothard's picture

Ahh insults. It wasn't a couple of people, the post office was queued out of the door with kids cashing free money cheques. Tw@

Dark Heart of Toryland's picture

Another government subsidy for Tesco, then.

KFZdiagnosegeraet's picture

Kfzdiagnosegeraet.de,on-line exporter featuring auto diagnostic tools for Do-It-Yourself and professional automotive mechanics, for online shop owners wholesale dropship at very low price. Kfzdiagnosegeraet ship its tools all over the world. Kfzdiagnosegeraet ever-lasting promise is Top Quality, Good Service, Competitive Price.

Simon Gothard's picture

The poor cannot be trusted with money. I recall having to sign on for JSA on a friday and there were queues out of the door for crisis loans for people who I heard talking to friends organising their night out once they had collected it.

Latest tweets