Our streets are aflame. Now black Britain will be allowed its say
The politics of race has, at best, retreated to a narrow debate around the issue of Islamophobia.
By Dan Hodges Published 08 August 2011 11:36
Like most of those leaping on the flaming bandwagon of Tottenham, I have no idea what lay behind the weekend's disturbances. It may well be, as some have suggested, that the chaos represented a realisation that the idyllic existence enjoyed by black inner-city youth during our years of plenty is now drawing to a close. Perhaps the Metropolitan Police is now so cash strapped it is no longer able to deploy significant manpower to low priority targets such as the prevention of a full blown riot. Or maybe we've simply been made aware of the full length to which London's drug gangs are prepared to go to defend their lucrative trade.
But now these issues will be debated. Crime, the cuts, drugs, social policy, policing policy. Oh, we'll debate them. There's nothing like a burnt out high street or two to get us debating.
And something will happen during the course of this debate. Something different.
We will invite black people to contribute to it. To be precise, we will invite members of the Afro-Caribbean community to participate in our political discourse.
There will be youth workers. Community leaders. Street kids. A local politician or two. They will all be allowed to articulate their case. Tell us about what it's like to be black, as opposed to white or Asian, in Britain. Because we are happy to let black people speak about politics, just so long as they have flames or body bags as their backdrop.
The riots of the 1980s produced some positives. The police finally dropped the 'one or two rotten apples' mantra, and embarked on a far reaching, and genuine, process of modernisation and reform. Casual social tolerance of racism became the exception, rather than the norm. Politicians of all persuasions began to focus seriously on inner-city, not jut regional, regeneration.
But those advances came at a price. And one of them was the de-politicisation and marginalisation of Afro-Caribbean politics, and with it the effective political disenfranchisement of an entire section of society. At the start of the 1980s, the black community had tribunes. Black politicians like Diane Abbott, Bernie Grant and Paul Boateng were elected to parliament speaking openly, honestly and provocatively about the issues affecting their communities.
Where are those voices and advocates today? Before this weekend when did you last see David Lammy on your television screen? Probably not since the brief period when Tony Blair put his arm round him, told him he was a future leader of the party, then dumped him.
A quarter of a century after our first black politicians were elected, how many currently sit around the cabinet or shadow cabinet tables? How many senior black parliamentarians chair our select committees? How many senior black advisors are part of either David Cameron or Ed Miliband's inner circle?
This is not an issue about the exclusion of minorities. There are influential Asian politicians across the political spectrum. And they form the spearhead of similarly influential lobbying groups. Our Jewish community, our Indian community, our Muslim community; all have effective advocates who sit at the heart of the political process. The Afro-Caribbean community, almost uniquely, has no such representation.
Of course there is Chuka Umunna, the great black hope of British politics. But he is totemic, his profile a symbol of what we have lost, rather than what we have achieved. And even Chuka is careful to represent himself as a politician who happens to be black, rather than a black politician.
No one is expecting Chuka Umunna to stand at the Despatch Box at the next session of Treasury questions and give a black power salute. But there is no point pretending that black politics and politicians have successfully broken into the political mainstream. Nor that the handful who have made it have brought their community and its agenda with them.
The politics of race has, at best, retreated to a narrow debate around the issue of Islamophobia. At worst, it has been pushed into a cul-de-sac of British Jobs for British Workers and cups of tea with Mrs Duffy.
And as our streets burn, what plans are afoot to address this political gagging of black Briton? None. Our selection processes are geared exclusively to tackling the under-representation of women. Our policy agenda to addressing the plight of the squeezed middle, not those at the economic margins. Our entire political narrative built around an appeal to the White Working Class.
And so there is silence. About the appalling levels of educational attainment by black male youth. About the scourge of gang culture that blights black communities. Or if there is not silence, the voices that are raised are not strong enough to force these issues to the top of the political agenda.
But we've had our riot. So now we can have our debate. And once again, for as long as the flames continue to flicker, black Britain will be allowed to have its say.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Jobs
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists


















154 comments
http://youtu.be/2A91ASkWww8
I have been surprised to hear a lot of comments about Jews rioting - as if this was a sport reserved for black and Muslim communities. A lot of hostility from commentators directed towards the Hassidic Jews who joined in. Can anyone explain this?
The Londonistan Spring..
Yes, they will. Its called the sentencing phase.
Very interesting and accurate point that race relations discourse in Britain is all about muslims. Most of these riots seem less about race and more a combination of disadvantaged people just angry during difficult economic times combined with the scary prospect of professional criminals using social media to coordinate mass criminality. I was in Brixton last night before the trouble started and there were lost of people who were wasted (there was some kin dif festival on) itching to smash things. The trigger - the shooting last week - does suggest though that race relations were forgotten.
"And even Chuka is careful to represent himself as a politician who happens to be black, rather than a black politician."
Unlike Bernie Grant or even David Lammy, Chuka Ummunna isn't from these communities. He's from a middle class family, a nice area and is the nephew of a QC not ap oor boy made good. Unsurprisingly both for this reason and because he is ambitious he wants to be a mainstream politican whose interests are the economy, media regulation etc. Not the black community. Umunna may have been happy to get media coverage as the british Barack due to his skin colour but he quote obviously wants to be a mainstream cabinet member not a tribue of a disadavantaged community.
Everything now rests on David lammy's shoulders. He wasn't particularly successful as a mainstream careerist politician. Now lets see if he can raise his game as a community politician when his own community has come under attack.
Why is it that white countries and ONLY white countries are Forced to become multicultural? Why are white people and ONLY white people FORCED to be tolerant? Why am I called a naziwhowantstokillsixmillionjews or a klansmanwhowantstorapeandlynchblacks when I point out the ongoing program of genocide against my race, the white race?
The problem is parenting - plenty of people live in poverty but don't riot.My guess would be that the majority of rioters come from one parent families - very little money or the education to teach their kids right from wrong.Solution - don't have kids unless you are in a stable relationship and can afford them.
The Olympic Games were won for he City of London on the basis that we would be getting more young people into active sport instead of them wasting their time menacing the the streets or playing IT games or or using social media like texting or tweeting/twittering. So lets do all we can to make the Games a success.
The reason why the BBC goes to Newcastle if there is a negative story about the inner cities they cant avoid is that it has the largest predominantly white English inner city left in Britain. But the foreign media does notice that the English inner city riots are in the least European areas of Europe as where the riots in France.
This libertarian viewpoint is rife throughout the media, its very cosy but it has failed to inbed itself in the minds of majority of people. It is very uncomfortable to watch coppers and their perspex shields and cute little sticks trying to fend off rapacious mainly black youths in a frenzy. im bored of the media pussy footing round the black community, they are statistically less educated, more violent tend towards crime in massive numbers.
give our cops a break and let them at least meet criminals like for like.
Oh do shut up. The divide was between those who smashed, looted and burned the livelihoods and property of other people, and those who did not. There were all sorts of people on both sides.
Different cultures have different values. Look to the motherland of each to get a key to what a race or culture values.The violent cultures always run out or kill the more peaceful.There is still room in the world for whites to flee to, however one day they will be backed into a corner and the outcome will be regrettable for the lower classes.
The photos of the yobs show more white than black -- so what is this whole discussion about? As I logged on, I wondered how many of yobs, black or white could do the simple arithmetic problem to sign on. Are blacks not allowed to vote in the UK? Are they prevented from registering as voters? Are they blocked from the polls? So what is the excuse -- other than illiteracy and no knowledge or interest in the political process?
What if the British people were given a referendum on returning third world non working immigrants to countries of origin.
What do you think the overwhelming result would be?
Tony the phony Blair and the labour stooges have created this problem by swamping the country with alien immigrants.
What is so striking to me is that while these scenes of violence unfold in politically correct (and so quick to judge and condemn when it comes to others) Britain - in Israel hundreds of thousands of ordinary citizens have taken to the streets in the last weeks to protest social injustices. Rallies all over the country on Saturday evening were estimated at 500 thousand people (in a country of 7 and a half million)
What are we seeing? Music, singing, children carried on their parents' shoulders, handicapped, people of every colour and background all joining together in HARMONY. Not a smashed vehicle or shop front in sight. (Of course you are NOT seeing this as the BBC wouldn't dream of giving GOOD coverage to Israel)
Makes me proud to be Israeli . And very sad to also be British.
In spite of the skewed reporting on the situation here in Israel, we still have firm family values and respect for our police force.
Let's hope Britain gets them back QUICKLY!
Dan, given what you say about the Jewish, Indian and Muslim communities making the most of their political involvement, why do you think the black community have failed to do the same?
Is the black community crippled by its own political, social and cultural dysfunction?
The government and wider society must simply DEMAND better from them. The time is up for making excuses.
The first thing we need to hear from the black community is that it has a problem and for its leaders to admit their own culpability in the perpetuation of its enormous failures.
Britain be viewed as 'treasure island' by the corporate world... charge as much as you can get away with... unfortunately too many people cannot afford to pay that 'ransom'... so they do unto others as others do unto them... cheat, steal, 'mug'.
A less materialistic (and by default low-brow) society would suffer less temptation.
I have a problem with the narrow (minded) assumptions in this article that this is simply a "black" issue and a problem with the ensuing clichés perpetuated in the text as a result of this presumption.
The pictures that I have seen in more enlightened press have shown a mix more accurately representative of urban youth as a whole (as pointed out by Greg), even if the bias of disenfranchisement still falls disproportionately on racial/ethnic lines.
The “appalling levels of educational attainment”, mentioned can not skipped over without at least some mention of the high instances of school exclusions (often for petty reasons). And what about youth unemployment, who should take responsibility for that?
And the author needs to clarify this so called “idyllic existence enjoyed by black inner-city youth during our years of plenty”. Unless he is referring to the fantasy we were all sold and some of us bought into, that materialism fuelled by credit and debit would give our lives value and purpose.
Disenfranchisement does not excuse the criminality on display, but if we have created a world where consumerism dominates, we can hardly be surprised that people who are excluded by legitimate means will participate by any means necessary (irony intended).
@andrew ... and you call "the black community"less educated? - are you aware of the history that brought this community to your shores, essentially making them "your" problem? Well since we are into being reductionist, then statistically the white European community is covertly racist, comparatively more violent than any other race on earth (having violently colonised most of the planet, enslaving and changing the customs of indigenous peoples almost everywhere) and notoriously thieving, having in their coffers the gold, diamonds, not to mention other natural resources of poor nations that for generations as a result are still "developing". You wouldn't want to be judged like this would you? But if we were going to stereotype, this would then be a description of you.I think an education is in order @andrew, check out the marginalisation, poor inner city education and lack of mobility that draws young people regardless of colour (I agree @greg) into a feeling of deprivation and anger, and eventually into the societal disconection that leads to violence. It always makes the racist more comfortable believing in some racial inferiority garbage to explain social problems, than it is for them to take a look an honest look at the problems, and see that actually race is only a part of it while they continue to be racist - why not just work on creating a colour-blind world where everyone has an equal chance? What are the attitudes and beliefs, including your own, that continue to stop this from happening?
Sounds like a lot of public school bollix to me.
How naieve of the OP - all these idiots have done is allow the kick-start of armed policing, right wing policies and hikes in Council taxation on their own doorstep - thought that one through did you ? Oh no doh! Nothing but nothing can condone the plainly subhuman shit that has passed in the last few days, however "angry" or "disaffected" the youth may feel - get off your arses and get a job, don't rob Poundland. And wtf are all the parents doing (apart from sitting resplendent in their new shell-suit, watching their local charity shop burn on their new 32" Samsung?)
This was a great article, I had a go at trying to work out some of the causes myself on the link below. I included this article as "extra reading" so thanks for being a sensible voice in this debate.
to west hillman
I wish white actually had a grasp on reality most of the east violent gangs are white the krays are a prolific example. The gangs who bring in drugs are white most hard core famouse criminal gangs and drug rings leaders are white,. who do you think bring the gangs to this country. I was raised by a black father alone with 8 brother and sisters 4 of us are self employed and the other holding down jobs like social workers and journalist, who rasied the MP's who stole taxpayers money. being raised by good parents is a not the only ingrediant for good behaviour. What working class children are facing the same problems. I think society has a different treatment model for black boys that challenges their masculinity and their strenghth so they assert them self in the best way they know how, unfortunately it is not the best way. Black boys are the first to be excluded from school. growing up i had friend who was told he needed to go to a special school because he was quiet and did not interact with the other children, had his parents not fought against his life would have been a different story, now he mentors young people has two degrees, sound like a fairy tale but it is true. A strong father can not stop all the ills that society throw at black boys. I work in accounts and due to may education i get job in blue organistions/ well known and time and time again i am shocked when i walk and i am the only black man on a floor of 200 people. I have known educated black men to cry real tears at the hands of the racist employer because they do not do the pub run. Really for black boys it is survival of the fittest. And it is even worse when they have a no male role models. but saying that i know amazing black women who raise their children well without a male role not by choice. let's face it the nuclear family is dead, even the royal family have absent fathers, where is the father figure in fergies life???
Young people need to watch the documentary feature The Story of Lovers Rock. Musis is a good outlet to heal emotions.
Chuka Umunna is mixed race not black. It's an important difference and I wish some would recognise this rather than lazily refer to mixed race individuals as "black".
Sad this is not a black and white issue this is a working class issue and unfortunately there is a signicant about of blacks and asains who fall into this demographic. The perception is that everyone who was rioting was on benefits and in social housing and predominately black, but that is not the case. So what has happened the midlde classes have raised their ugly heads and have started screaming get them out of housing get them of benefits. Really!!!!! we can jump on our folding bikes and a enjoy a lovely day in the city and then jog along suburba pretending life is great. Because we have the choices and but how dear they complain. Everyone is ignoring a major fact in this rioting 50% were under 18. So do we violate the humans rights of their entire family because a 12 year old has committed a crime. E. benz who talks about immoral behaviour, have tried to understand the immoral behaviour of the high earning MPs who steal tax payers money to enjoy even more priveleges. or the police who appear to be on the verge of being given a medal for their work on the riots, who are not law abiding keeper of the peace they in fact they take money from crooked publisher to infringe on humans to privacy. It is not that complicated to for desperate man to steal but explain immoral behaviour when you already have so much.
I can not justify the grounds of theft on any level. MPs committing fraud, come on guys, yes E.Benz you probably are racist, but that is the society that we live in that why the term white collar crime was devised.
Children in certain communities are neglected because may just being two jobs to survive, not because they are bad parents.
Matthew; We are all mixed race.
If these riots have been caused by social deprivation, lack of job prospects and a general low quality of life, then why haven't there been riots in areas like Glasgow, Newcastle and Middlesborough? Towns which are predominantly white areas.
Invite the Third World to London, London becomes Third World. Pretty simple, really, and a lot more real than the idea that White racism is causing them to go ape.
We need a tame UK version of Barak O, to keep the blacks under control, and wraps, here don't we? Keep them silent for another 8 years -
Sadly, no crooked enough 'black' on the UK horizon
Another small matter. People with guns and bombs in the third world are rebels with real causes aren't they, and we support them don't we?? They have minority grievances like the Tamils in Sri Lanka, Muslims in India .....
@Zinc Oxide - where is the First World? And what separates it from the Third? All my life, I thought I lived in one world ... Stupid me, as a black woman born in the UK, I should know my place, please tell me how to get to the third world, and what you think all other third worlders, including myself, should do once we get there? I personally think the first thing, should be to keep all the sugar, bananas, coffee, oil and cheap labour to ourselves ...
trouble is, i'm as much of a bleeding heart liberal as the next new statesman reader, but when i see criminality on this scale i immediately forget the met's inadequacies and want them to crack a few heads.
it just so happens that our cleaner will be coming from lithuania (via west london) to clean our house today at a not-especially-generous-but-not-starvation-rations £9 per hour. i'd happily employ someone from tottenham to do it (it's much nearer than west london, let alone lithuania), but would anyone chucking bricks at the police last night get off their arse to actually do some work? will they fuck.
Another fine mess the liberal elite have got us into...
No doubt the criminal violence and looting of the last couple of days will be met with the usual slap on the wrists and the trite excuses... of the liberal elite.
http://www.blottr.com/uk/breaking-news/thug-life-uk
@Pious Pigeon
If these riots have been caused by social deprivation, lack of job prospects and a general low quality of life, then why haven't there been riots in areas like Glasgow, Newcastle and Middlesborough? Towns which are predominantly white areas.
probably because white kids are not dying in police custody.
Chuka Umunna seems to be one of these politicians who is, like both Milibands, only capable of speaking in politician jargon. I fail to see how anybody can see him as inspirational, or anything like Obama. They are worlds apart in both rhetoric and oratory but also ideas and leadership potential.
David Lammy who was seemingly invisible during Labour's government years now has an opportunity now to raise his respect and profile within his community and from across the political spectrum.
Bernie Grant was a polarising figure, not only for his anti-police sentiment but for his far-left views. Lammy, a centre-left Blairite has less divisive political views and could begin to prove himself as a proper role model for aspiring black politicians.
Of course there are also several Conservatives who are able to do the job, Kwarsi Kwarteng, Adam Afriyie but they seem conveniently forgotten here.
A real point to think about, however, is how we can make our stuffy, 18th century Parliament with wigs, tights, black rod, purposefully confusing etiquette relevant to young people, particularly those who are non-white or of non-British origin.
How many Black teenagers can look at the House of Commons and say "I can see myself working there"?
@aneka, this is spew, i do not need a history lesson thanks all the same. you are confusing the word racist with rationalist. does standing up for black people make you feel less guilty about being a bored WHITE middle class housewife, like you're making a difference. after years of 'positive discrimination'( that doesn't mean anything does it)
for every 5 videos from youtube of chalkys rioting or acting with extreme violence, i'll find you 100 of our black brothers doing the same.
Im not saying there are not legitimate reasons why this occurs, but it does, and the way it is being dealt with by the media and police is clearly not making a difference.
What do you mean Bill Fraser? Something about "liberal elite", what specifically are you adding to the debate?
I'm very happy I emigrated to the antipodes - the labour elites deliberately flooded the UK with third-worlders in order to destroy the UK, they admitted as much. And they have been successful beyond their wildest dreams.
the looters are being punished a lot.
"Or maybe we've simply been made aware of the full length to which London's drug gangs are prepared to go to defend their lucrative trade."
This is such an ill-informed statement, the riots have shown that young (black) youths who usually fight for drug turf or over postcodes are willing to come together for the right cause. Boys from Clapton, Tottenham, Enfield, Hackney, Bow, Holloway, Islington... joined forces over the weekend, ignoring normal rivalries to riot and loot. It had nothing to do with drug gangs, there was no fighting between youths, just between youths and the police.
I'm sorry but this article is just daft. If these people want justice and fairness, they shouldn't burn down people's homes. Lets not all get stockholm syndrome!!!
The level of racism in some of these comments is completely unacceptable.
You really are pathetic.
Let millions of Blacks and Muslims into the UK and you don't expect big problems. I got out of London, UK (for New Zealand)three years ago because most of it is now on a par with the 3rd world. The Labour party flooded the UK with 3rd world immigrants between 1997 and 2010. The UK is finished, London kids are now an ethnic minority in their own nation. How stupid can you get?
So you have no idea what caused the riots, but you have a solution Dan?
Terrific.
I have an idea what caused this riot, it was the sense of entitlement driven into these children in place of a rigorous education that leads them to believe they can take what they want.
You don't need to look far for the root cause, they are all sitting around you.
This may save the UK from total collapse.
1) Revoke all Citizenship and Residency from all 3rd world immigrants since 1997.
2)A total freeze on all immigration permanently expect for those with top level skills.
3) Ban islam, all mosques and all islamic schooling.
4) Get out of the EU and maintain only a free trade agreement with Europe.
5) Ban all muslim money from UK institutions. They are promoting the evil hate and death cult through all UK institutions and have been for decades.
Can`t see why the colour or creed of the rioters is so important in this article, we (all of us) in the UK should be proud of the diverse mixture of peoples, the reasons for the riots will be told by the people that lived and worked there, lets not jump to conclusions and kangaroo court the situation as the tabloids do ... something went seriously wrong, lets hope it`s not too sinister ..
A recent poll reported in the Jamaica Gleaner found a majority of Jamaicans (in Jamaica) thought things were better under the British. Ha!
Gun crime and knife crime are not phenomena indigenous to the UK, they are imported from Ja. As are attitudes to the Police who in Jamaica are a little mafia.
Whitey liberals go to the source.
This is a great article! It really discusses and hits where it hurts. It summaries the current political system. One learns a lot from by looking at the way things are - the structure. And you'll learn a lot from the fact that politicians, officials, intellectuals, media and elite class do not want you to look at it.
Post new comment