Well Cuil?

Could the mighty Google ever be overcome? A new search engine has been set up. It's called 'Cuil', h

Just a few days after Google claimed to have visited one trillion unique URL’s on the internet, a new startup launched onto the web with the lofty claim of already having indexed more pages than the big G.

Cuil (pronounced ‘cool’, of course) opened for use yesterday claiming to have some 120 billion pages indexed. Blimey.

Formed by ex-Googlers with $33m of venture funding, Cuil has been in development for the last three years and has attracted a huge amount of interest, coverage and upon launch - searches.. So many, infact, that a few hours after opening for business it buckled under the sustained weight of new-user’s excitable queries. Not to worry, it’s back up now…

Cuil claims to have a vastly improved search method than Google - most importantly from a business point of view, making it far easier to scale as it grows. Rather than ranking keywords as Google does, Cuil seeks to index meaning from pages and then give you the opportunity to refine your search as you go.

By understanding the context of your search through such semantic indexing, Cuil claims to distance itself from the the pretenders to the Google throne such as Powerset which uses an artificial intelligence approach to try and understand natural language.

The user interface itself is pleasing. It also displays the results in an easy to browse columnated format with the category options off to the side. It’s really is rather like reading a magazine of search results, with the suggested tabs and further options making the whole exercise feel rather more like a pleasant browse than a laser-focussed search.

Perhaps most notably absent from the site are the paid searches which run down the right-hand side of every Google search. It’s a refreshing change from the Google norm, but one which isn’t destined to last. Eventually Cuil will establish ad-sales as its principle revenue stream proving the Web 2.0 truism that if you can get the eyeballs, you can get the money.

Perhaps the most conspicuous way in which Cuil distances itself from Google, is in its attitude to privacy. Whilst Google has based an entire business model upon knowing the intimate surfing trends of its users, Cuil has taken a provocatively different approach.

Rather than just promising that it won’t do "evil" with the information it collects, Cuil’s approach is to not collect that information at all.

As landmark rulings such as the YouTube vs Viacom case have shown, Google is going to find it increasingly difficult to sustain both its power and stay a comfortable distance from Satan.

Cuil has a gargantuan task ahead of itself to try and catch Google (or even Yahoo), but it’s differentiated enough to be off to a good start.

Search for something on Cuil

14 comments

Pencils's picture

Well... I just used Cuil to search for a cd, of which I know of only one very expensive copy for sale at Amazon.com. Google came up with 10+ pages - onlly the first half dozen being exact matches, admittedly.

CUIL COULDN'T COME UP WITH ANYTHING.

VERDICT: COULD TRY HARDER.

And I think Carl Jones is right: don't use it for downloading any Al-Q training manuals.

Robert Powell's picture

They're watching y aaaaargh, please stop, no, don't ....

Viscount  Firm's picture

Powell, are you alright?

Robert Powell's picture

Yes fine thanks. Why?

Viscount  Firm's picture

Oh no reason.

taghioff.info's picture

I've tried Cuil, and as of yet it does not offer me higher quality results than Google.

The idea of contextual searching is good, but the current drilling in feature does not help one focus in that much, though it does help you if there are major areas of what you are researching that you don't know about: It reveals bits of the taxonomy that you have missed out.

But Google still gives a stronger list of results straight off.

Waldstock's picture

Interesting choice of name.

Cuil is a word in the Irish language with a number of meanings depending on context.

Without an accent it can mean, a fly, or wicked or to have a venomous aspect or great eagerness.

With an accented 'u' it most commonly means back, supporting or reserve. It can also mean a corner nook, or couch or heap.

On balance, maybe they should accent the 'u'.

G's picture

Searching for my latest online creation and...
Google lists it as the first result (after about a month of launching the website and improving it's rating),
Cuil doesn't know about it, and just has a number of references (with URL) to the website.

My conclusion...
Cuil is rubbish.

VC's picture

Cuil`s best marketing ploy would be to state that its not hot-wired into the CIA/NSA/MI6 and storing everyone`s search history (lol), Until Cuil states this as fact, I`ll assume its been hot-wired into the SIS community.

May I recommed that everyone spends 5 minutes eash day searching the net for unusual and extreme (legal) content. Use as many ""HOT"" words as possible, you can find lists of these on google (lol), but I`m sure you can add a good bunch more.lol

Remember, they are spying on YOU, and YOU have every right to use disinformation, just like "they" do in the MSM. :)

Jenny Webb1's picture

If you know it to be true why do they need to fess up, Carl?

Novartza's picture

More to the point, Cuil's most urgent task is, rather than catching up with google or Yahoo, match up its servers and resources to users' demand and expectations. Because the better it becomes, the more people will use it, and the more likely it is to crash or overload. $33m is nice for starts, but in the long run that'll be far from enough.

Viscount  Firm's picture

You mean to say someone has a record of the specialist websites I visit? I've not been this outraged since I don't know when.

IrritatedofTonbridge's picture

I've just had my first look at Cuil and I have to say I think it's quite good - a way to go before they thrash Google though, not least for the reasons highlighted by Novartza.

VC's picture

Jenny, I said "assume". I`m assuming Cuil is hot-wired into the SIS, because they aren`t using this as a selling point. Google has serious privacy issues....in fact, the CIA funded google`s setup and thats another point, it would be fair to assume the CIA are into Cuil as well.:)

Latest tweets