Eric, Ernie and the under-rated genius of Peter Bowker
The BBC's Morecambe and Wise biopic was a wonderfully understated piece of TV.
By Helen Lewis Published 03 January 2011 16:53
It's one thing to make drama out of big, splashy, life-changing events -- births and deaths and alien invasions -- but there's something special about a writer who can make life's tiny triumphs and disasters sparkle.
Peter Bowker is one of those writers. His latest outing, BBC's Eric and Ernie (broadcast on New Year's Day; available until 8 January on iPlayer here), was one of the best pieces of new writing on television over the holidays.
The 90-minute drama told the story of how two boys called Eric Bartholomew and Ernie Wiseman became the Christmas telly staples Morecambe and Wise. You can already see the potential pitfalls, can't you? The biopic genre is heinously hard to get right; either the untidy events of real life have to be crowbarred into a standard three-act structure -- and it feels a bit paint-by-numbers -- or the writer attempts too broad a span and the whole thing collapses into unfocused bagginess.
Eric and Ernie deftly sidesteps both these pitfalls by being what comic book fans would call an "origin story". It follows the child star Ernie tap-dancing his way to the West End, while the gangly Eric performs with a giant lollipop in a church hall; it documents their first meeting (they didn't hit it off immediately, shall we say), the weeks they spent sharing a room in London during the Blitz and their disastrous first foray into television on a live show now lost to posterity.
Along the way, Bowker throws in some wonderful moments. There's Eric's first waggle of his glasses and a wonderful shot of the two boys sitting up in bed together, side by side. A less experienced writer might have felt the temptation to give the audience a nudge in the ribs at these points -- "Look! It's just like they did in the show!" -- but letting them pass without comment is so much classier.
Bowker was helped by some stellar acting performances. The youngsters who played the boy and adolescent versions of Eric and Ernie were incredible; no toothy stage-school mugging here. Victoria Wood, playing Eric's forthright mother, was predictably brilliant (sample line: "Eric, listen to me. You make people laugh, you're a lovely dancer and you can hold a tune but more than that -- and I mean this as the mother who carried you and nursed you and raised you . . . you aren't any good at anything else"). And Vic Reeves (acting under his real name, Jim Moir) was a revelation: he turned in such a wonderfully understated performance as Eric's good-egg dad that I'm almost prepared to forgive him his appearance on I'm A Celebrity.
Comedy-wise, much of the heavy lifting was done by Daniel Rigby, who captured Eric Morecambe's strangled stage delivery with uncanny precision, while avoiding sounding like a cheap impersonator. His background as a stand-up undoubtedly helped with the many sequences showing M&W in performance (let's face it, if the actors had been crap, the plausibility of the programme would have disappeared faster than you can say "What's a Grecian urn?").
Bryan Dick as Ernie was also spot-on; particularly in the heart-rending scene in which the two tell Eric's mother that they've got a "proper manager" and don't need her to ferry them round any more. Here, Dick gives Ernie the emotional maturity to realise that this isn't necessarily the unambiguously wonderful piece of news that Eric thinks it is and Victoria Wood caps it all off by giving just the faintest hint of a snuffle as her train carriage pulls away from Eric and Ernie, who are (inevitably) clowning around for her on the platform.
As I said, sparkling little moments. Eric and Ernie is well worth a watch, even if you're not the most devoted Morecambe and Wise fan in the world (my husband promptly spent an hour watching clips of them on YouTube as soon as we'd finished, which tells you something).
What's more, this being the dear old Beeb, they've put together an interesting behind-the-scenes documentary, featuring interviews with the comedian's families, historians of variety theatre and classic clips (I defy you not to laugh at "He won't sell many ice creams going at that speed"). It can be found here.
But my real plea is that if you enjoy Eric and Ernie, then please watch some of Peter Bowker's other work. In Britain, very few television writers have any name recognition at all (Steven Moffatt, Paul Abbott and Jimmy McGovern perhaps being the only exceptions), which seems ludicrously unfair given the size and scale of their achievements. While America excels at getting huge groups of writers together to crank out 22 episodes of top-quality telly, year in, year out, we've always been better at nurturing individual talents.
Bowker's past work includes 2009's Desperate Romantics, a thoroughly silly yet undeniably enjoyable romp through the lives of the Pre-Raphaelite painters (watch out for Tom Hollander as a pornography-obssessed Ruskin) and 2005's Dennis Potter tribute Blackpool. The latter is one of my personal favourite pieces of television (and not just because of the presence of the dishy David Tennant); fresh, keenly drawn characters, evocative setting and the weird but wonderful choice of songs for the actors to lip synch to.
I've never seen Bowker's other major success, 2009's Bafta-winning military drama Occupation, but -- spurred on by Eric and Ernie -- I certainly will. And if you have any recommendations for other great British TV writers I should investigate further, I'd be pleased to hear them.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Jobs
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists

















9 comments
eric and ernie was riveting and thoroughly entertaining,cast was execellent,however daniel rigbys portrayal of eric was absolutely brilliant,you would have sworn you were watching the real eric he had his mannerisms off to a fine art,enlighting of how visionary erics mother in her support and guidannce during their early careers quite instrumental i would say...regards blackpool totally agree...viva las vegas,viva las vegas,viva viva las veegaas!da da da da da..(got ya right from the start)
I watched this as I felt under a bit of an obligation having seen no fewer than 379 'trailers' for it [only a slight exaggeration] and very nearly ended up watching a Welsh language drama called 'Ar Y Tracs' about a train journey to a big rugby match [well, it did have Ruth Jones in it, of whom more later]
But Eric and Ernie was the right choice - let us hope the young actors will see write-ups such as this and be inspired into even more good dramas in the future. as in the article, I ended up watching clips on YouTube [mind you, I watched clips of a few of the Band Aid stars, and 'When Bob met Harvey was a bit of a let-down.]
So what we want to know is when is Ruth Jones doing her Hattie Jacques thing ??
this is /was a drama of real quality. Totally believable and a joy to watch. It would be interesting to watch a production viewed from Ernies perspective.
Restored my faith in old auntie
I didn't watch this as I'm normally averse to biopics of personal icons (Frankie Howerd, JFK) and the prurient raking in the muck that is prevalent in the genre. You've sold me though. I shall watch it tonight and report back.
Couldn't agree with this article more.
Eric and Ernie was truly brilliant all round. I would have paid to watch that in the cinema - it was better than anything in the multiplex at the moment!
But more importantly, I've always stood by Peter Bowker - he's one of my favourite writers by a good distance, especially after Eric and Ernie. Blackpool blew me away and since then everything I've watched by the writer has always been so spot-on, he's one of the best in Britain.
I'm genuinely jealous of those who get to discover Bowker all over again - like yourself being able to watch Occupation for the first time. It's wonderful.
Never did take to Morecambe and Wise, the poor man's Abbott and Costello.
Best Xmas TV was 'Road to Corination Street' and the family films 'Enchanted'and 'Shrek'.
Pretty turned off and bored by the likes of Downton Abbey and Upstairs Downstairs. Cannot see what all the fuss is about. Much better series is Larkrise to Candleford
A better depiction of the 30's is Poirot and Miss Marple, and you get a cracking puzzle as well to solve.
Suchet makes the best Poirot and Juia MacKenzie the best Miss Marple.
Post new comment