Generation X factor
Though often dismissed as slackers, the cohort that produced Elliott Smith, Pavement and Sonic Youth was a creative force in music.
By Yo Zushi Published 21 October 2010 18:41
A decade ago, the Atlantic magazine called them "the most politically disengaged" young adults in US history. Their accelerated culture -- to borrow the novelist Douglas Coupland's phrase -- had taken shape among the over-educated "slackers" who crowded the skate parks and arcade centres of middle America; the alienated offspring of Nixon-era suburbanites who had traded flower power for Wall Street.
Where the postwar baby boomers had Holden Caulfield, their children had Beavis and Butthead. Writing in 1991, Coupland called them "Generation X", in reference to the ambiguity that defined their world view. The label stuck.
Coming of age in a time of recession, rising crime, the Chernobyl disaster and war, and denied even the license for sexual adventurousness that the boomers had enjoyed (largely due to the emergence of Aids), the X-ers had much to complain about. Falling wages and commensurate increases in urban poverty contributed to an atmosphere of economic insecurity, while political scandals (from the US treasurer Catalina Vásquez Villalpando's incarceration for tax evasion in 1992 to the Clinton/Lewinsky affair) only widened the chasm between the generations.
Declarations of mistrust were hurled from both sides of the generational divide. "We are the sons of no one," sang the Replacements in their 1986 college-radio hit "Bastards of Young". A Washington Post headline, meanwhile, exhorted the young "crybabies" to "grow up".
Social liberalism was on the up and huge improvements in the educational system -- hard won by the civil rights movements of the 1960s and 1970s -- had led to a more functional democratisation of knowledge than the US had experienced ever before. By the 1990s, the average student at many undergraduate institutions was a working woman over the age of 22. It was this, perhaps, that engendered the informed cynicism of Generation X, depicted in pop culture as equal parts langour and intellectual rigour.
If young people weren't interested in the adult world of business and politics, they directed their energies toward more private ends. Self-consciously non-commercial music, much of it recorded at home (Palace Brothers, the Beat Happening), as well as photocopied fanzines and comics about intense, personal experiences (Adrian Tomine's Optic Nerve) flourished in the era.
Today, fans will be marking the seventh anniversary of the death of Elliott Smith, one of the generation's icons. Born in August 1969, Smith began his musical career at the height of the grunge boom as a co-founder of the Portland indie rockers Heatmiser. Smith, a philosophy graduate who named his album Either/Or after a Kierkegaard treatise on aesthetics, was a bedroom musician par excellence; over a span of half a dozen albums, he chronicled his failed relationships and spiralling drug abuse with rare clarity.
After the demise of Heatmiser, Smith became a fixture in the New York singer-songwriter circuit, where his whispered vocals and Big Star/Beatles melodies caught the attention of the film-maker Gus Van Sant. Van Sant commissioned Smith to write a song for his 1998 film, Good Will Hunting, which unexpectedly resulted in an Oscar nomination (Smith would lose out to Celine Dion). A short period of minor success followed and his music grew ever more ambitious. At the core of his writing, however, remained the hesitant romanticism that had distinguished him in the first place.
Smith's suicide in 2003 has seen him crudely cast as a rock'n'roll martyr. Yet what he will be remembered for is his music. On 1 November, Domino Recordings will release An Introduction to Elliott Smith, a compilation of his hits that never were.
It's a strange feeling to see the bands and musicians of our youth repackaged as "classic" artists and reforming for nostalgia tours. But the X-ers are all in (or approaching) their middle age. Between 1-3 October, the indie label Matador celebrated its 21st anniversary in Las Vegas, with a mighty roster of alternative music's prime movers, including Pavement and Sonic Youth. That the 1980s no-wave veterans Sonic Youth have been around five years longer than the Arctic Monkeys' Alex Turner has even been alive is a stark reminder of the new irony of that band's name: sonic they still are but youth they most certainly are not.
The buzz surrounding the festival and the compilation, however, attests to the enduring legacy of the X-ers. Many of today's rock luminaries (including the Bright Eyes singer Conor Oberst) cite Smith and the Matador set as major influences. Generation X may have seemed like a lost generation but perhaps this was deliberate -- after all, who likes a try-hard?
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Jobs
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists

















20 comments
In a way Gen-X were the last counterculture. Todays most prominent youth culture ("hipsters" though I find that to derogatory for my purposes) have the left-wing views ,the commitment to creative activities, and the DIY attitude. But they lack a vital ingredient: societal alienation. Whether this turns out to be a good or bad thing in the long run is not yet clear.
council estate nihilism
in hulme with the untested
test department,tools you can trust
greg dulli was the most debauched i've ever seen
naked with the afghan whigs on stage at the gallery strumming-just
paranoid gibberish trying to be allen ginsberg
yo zushi forgive my ignorance what are you meaning by the 'mats
oh i just remembered wil billy childish he must fit in somewhere
As a child of the punk generation still find it strange to see 'Sex Pistols' shoes marketed although the fact that they were reduced in price may be a comment on where we stand. Then again, maybe people were put of by the fact that the trainers in question had "No Future" on them...
Oh I Love the replacements ermeber seeing em in manchester
supported by a madchester lot they were appalling
J Mascis -god still
right I'm sick of waiting
can we have more now wave generation stuff
and less of the
high brow poo
anyone heard the new dead c album?
loud brash angry discordant hateful
This article sums up Generation X quite nicely and astutely - I'm currently writing an MA thesis on the subject and I've been examining the different ways members of the age cohort attempted to give themselves a voice - in contention to the thundering yell of the baby-boomers. Music played a very important role in this, but sometimes people took things farther than playing songs. In the early 1980s in Canada, a member of an early punk band joined up with a group called Direct Action - and they decided to use bombs to garner attention to issues they thought important - and carried out a series of attacks before their capture by the authorities.
I write about Direct Action on my blog, if you'd like you can check it out here:
http://thepastisunwritten.wordpress.com/2010/05/14/punk-and-protest-laws...
cheers for that
modern day canadian post rock is heavily influenced by anarchy and communalism
vis godspeed you black emperor ,do make say think
Post new comment