The 10 greatest political films
Do you agree with our list?
By Staff blogger Published 29 April 2010 14:17This week's Critics is a cinema special, so in honour of the occasion we have compiled a list of the 10 greatest political films. Tell us: do you agree with the list below? Which films would make your top ten?
All the President's Men, dir: Alan J Pakula (1976)
This real-life dramatisation of how the Watergate scandal was exposed makes the NS list not just because it details the work of the hotshot journalists Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein (played by Robert Redford and Dustin Hoffman), but because it is a fantastic thriller that lays bare the corruption of the Nixon presidency.
Battleship Potemkin, dir: Sergei Eisenstein (1925)
Made in the flood of ideas that followed the Russian Revolution, Potemkin tells the story of a mutiny, and helped shape film as we know it. Although it may be dismissed as Soviet propaganda in some quarters, that only raises the question: how much of what we watch today is propaganda of one sort or another?
Godzilla, dir: Ishiro Honda (1954)
Fans of Stanley Kubrick may protest that his satire on the atomic bomb, Dr Strangelove (1966), did not make our top ten; this is because Godzilla pipped it to the post. Honda's science-fiction tale, made less than a decade after the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, is a thinly veiled polemic against nuclear war. And it has a giant monster in it.
In the Loop, dir: Armando Iannucci (2009)
Not only was the Oscar-nominated satire (based on the television series The Thick
of It) proof that British comedy can transfer successfully to the big screen, but its sharp dialogue demonstrated how grotesquely language is manipulated by politicians in the pursuit of power.Kadosh, dir: Amos Gitai (1999)
Set in an ultra-Orthodox Jewish area of Jerusalem, Kadosh details the plight of two sisters trapped by their community's strict customs. Gitai's stark realism and willingness to confront the harsh truths of Israeli society have made him a controversial figure in his home country.
La Chinoise, dir: Jean-Luc Godard (1967)
An alumnus of Cahiers du cinéma (see Emilie Bickerton's piece, facing), Godard became a more overtly political film-maker towards the end of the Sixties. Loosely based on Dostoevsky's 1872 novel The Possessed, La Chinoise is a portrait of a group of French students with revolution on the mind that vividly renders the excitement - and frustrations - of youthful idealism.
Land and Freedom, dir: Ken Loach (1995)
Following the journey of a young man from Liverpool who volunteers to fight in the Spanish civil war, Loach's film covers similar territory to George Orwell's Homage to Catalonia. What makes Land and Freedom a great work in its own right is its ability to forge compelling drama from the battle of ideas that raged within the anti-fascist movement.
Nashville, dir: Robert Altman (1975)
Centred on the country'n'western music business and a shady political campaign, this two-and-a-half-hour epic was a state-of-the-nation address to the United States as the country approached its 200th birthday.
Strawberry and Chocolate, dir: Tomás Gutiérrez Alea (1994)
The world-renowned Cuban director trod a fine line between supporting his country's revolution and taking a clear-eyed look at Cuban society. Fresa y chocolate is about a university student who is befriended by a gay artist resisting the Castro regime's persecution of homosexuals.
The Battle of Algiers, dir: Gillo Pontecorvo (1966)
The Italian director's gritty, black-and-white study of Algeria's anti-colonial war against France is an uncompromising look at the politics of independence struggles. It also serves as a warning to armies that seek to crush guerrilla movements - the Pentagon screened the film for staff shortly after the 2003 invasion of Iraq.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists



















30 comments
what about 'Thirteen Days' on the Cuban missile Crisis ?
What about Z?
Here are a few I'd add:
The Constant Gardener – brilliantly directed, beautifully filmed and acted John le Carre story about love, Africa and alive conscience
Cup Final – the Israeli- Palestinian conflict through the eyes of a small group of soldiers from both sides thrown together
Long Walk Home - wonderfully realized film on a seminal civil rights struggle, the Birmingham bus boycott
Matewan and Norma Rae – unusually powerful labor rights sagas
Missing – Jack Lemon excels as a father searching for the truth about his son’s disappearance following the overthrow of the Allende regime in Chile
Romero – Raul Julia stars as a conservative cleric who becomes a hero in the fight against repression in El Salvador
A Force More Powerful -- Stories from every continent of everyday people using nonviolence to fight dictators and injustice
The one exclusion I find unforgivable is "if....", and it's sequel O Lucky Man! is brilliant too (although I can perhaps understand why - I would relegate A Clockwork Orange to "mere" social commentary rather than a political film). Other suggestions - The Birth of a Nation? Controversial, but stunning. Network (1976) is also a fantastic politically charged film. Warren Beaty's The Parallax View is similarly themed, and his Reds (1981) is also good, and more overtly political. Of those on offer, La Chinoise is probably my favourite (which reflects my own disposition - I would also back up calls for The Working Class Goes to Heaven's inclusion, and the lesser known Comrades (1986) for a historical piece), along with the Battleship Potempkin, and Nashville (I'm also a huge Altman fan).
I think 'The Wind That Shakes the Barley', a film about the British occupation of Ireland in the late 1920's, could be in there. I don't think it's very well known though.
Why Costa Gavraz' movies are missing from the list? I would have definitely added "Z" to the list. I also liked "Missing".
Z is long before my time, but I just looked it up and it looks great, I will watch it soon, thanks for everyone pointing it out.
Another good Spanish Civil War movie is "Libertarias" , ostensibly about "The Free Womeen of Spain", and how they teach non-radicalised women about economy, politics, and invite them to join their militia. Depressing ending as with all Spanish Civil war films. Some brilliant action scenes and constant humour as well though. Come to that: Pan's Labryinth could be on here.
I'll give you, without question, The Battle of Algiers (it should be higher, if not #1), Potemkin, and, although I would never have thought it myself, Godzilla. And I could be persuaded by Nashville.
But there are some glaring omissions here: Do the Right Thing, the best, and one of the two most important films ever made on race in America; Weekend, which, among Godard's films, is far more radical, with the formal elements articulating the ideas.
But the real omission, a film omitted, I assume, because its politics are so abhorrent. But its political stance cannot disguise its significance: Triumph of the Will.
I must shamefully admit that the only one of them I've seen is In The Loop, but thats the best political film I've seen.
Also a big fan of The Deal, The Ghost and Frost/Nixon, all very recent.
what about Wag The Dog?
Surely 'Citizen Kane' should be the numero uno in the above list.
The nexus of big business and media ( including its new creature the internet and its offspring ) was made abundantly clear. Xanudu represents the present consumer society writ large, with celebrity culture not too high profile in train. Exposes as aids to political assassination and the publication of intimate secrets are there in black and white. Thirteen Days, Fail Safe and Dr Strangelove and other such movies must always re-assure the American public that the US Defense Forces are top dog. It takes three sams to down the U2: a USAF bomber obliterates New York on U S President's orders; a lumbering B52 piloted by good old-boy Slim Pickens penetrates missile and interceptor defenses designed for Hustler/Valkyrie supersonic aircraft fleets.
Gullible
Z
Lawrence of Arabia
The Candidate
Casablanca
Citizen Kane is too contrived. Its a pastiche.
The Third Man is a lot lot better.
But I agree that Dr Strangelove must be mentioned. And Reds.
I would only include The Battle of Algiers. All the President's Men is oh-so-precious and self regarding that it is intolerable.
Other good ones included Seven Days in May, The Manchurian Candidate (1962 version) and I'm Alright Jack. John Ford's The Grapes of Wrath is a work of genius.
Best political film: "Burn" (alternative title: "Quemada"). Stars Brando/directed by Pontecorvo/terrific music by Morricone)
A Very British Coup
The Battle of Algiers is brilliant, and would be my number 1.
You should have included at least one film by Francesco Rosi, eg Hands Over The City, about political corruption in post-war Naples, with a spectacular building collapse, or Salvatore Giuliano, about Sicily, or The Mattei Affair. I remember Alex Cox once describing the latter to me as "the Italian Citizen Kane". He wanted to show it on Moviedrome but the BBC wouldn't let him. I should add that I don't know Alex Cox; I just bumped him into one day and we got talking about Rosi and what he said stuck in my mind. Italian directors used to make fantastic political films.
Salt of the Earth was formative for me in theorizing race, gender, and class; also in understanding solidarity in the labor movement and the history of McCarthyism.
In spite of its didacticism, it is moving, witty, and beautiful.
I would like to submit a few of my favourites:
Fog of War: 11 Lessons from the Life of Robert McNamara
Thirteen Days
Bob Roberts
What about: Goodbye Lenin, Nineteen Eighty Four, and the Working Class Goes to Heaven?
To follow up the previous comments, I'd add Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion, Todo Modo or The Working Class goes to Paradise by Elio Petri. Political satire at its best, savage analyses of Italy's venal governing classes and the blackest comedy on the theme of Italy's "strategy of tension". Indeed this period produced much of Italy's greatest political cinema, which inspired the promising Paolo Sorrentino (see The Consequences of Love). A necessary mention also for Roberto Rossellini for Rome: Open City, and Germany: Year Zero - absolutely heart-wrenching humanism. Mmm what else...
Best political film of all time: Our Daily Bread
Good list. But, like Balaraman (30 April at 14:31), I feel that Costa Gavras' Z deserved a place. His State of Siege,too, is worthy of consideration.
Good list. I would have included The Night Porter, The Marriage of Maria Braun and Dr Mabuse, der Spieler.
Citizen Kane was mentioned; I'd rather vote for Touch of Evil (-58): Political on all levels. How about Tarkovski's Stalker (-79)? It was the look ahead which Stalker offered to us...
I should probably asterisk Reds (1981): see Zizek's analysis in particular, who sees the film as reductionist of the political content in parts to the relationship between Bryant and Reed. Although the film also interrogates the bourgeois distinction between the personal and political through Bryant, so it is not unconscious of this.
I have to commend every single comment above because of two glaring omissions that qualify two of the most propagandistic films ever made (1) to justify the Iraq invasion ("The Hurt Locker" which demonises the Iraqis for daring to defend their ancient homeland) and (2)the outrageous Israeli "Walz With Bashir" which reverts to the same old boring victims in the holocaust justification for slaughtering the people you are occupying.
"Walz With Bashir" was one of ten Hollywood propagandistic movies released to coincide exactly at the time of the Gazan massacre to extract as much sympathy for Israel as possible at the very moment they were murdering Palestinian babies with white phosphorus.Anyone who argues against the fact that Jews own Hollywood has to have his head examined. I avoid seeing Hollywood trash as a result ever since.
No Waltz With Bashir? Tut tut.
Robin and Marian is a fine piece of Vietnam related work.
for political cinema, what about 'Matewan', 'the Lives of Others', 'Taxi to the Dark Side', and 'Sacrificed Youth'.
these are not very theoretical, but they do record what goes on at the sharp end of politics - the need for sacrifice and its cost.