Cultural Capital

Reflections on books and the arts from the New Statesman culture desk

Syndicate contentRSS

The greatest political songs of all time

Do you agree with the Political Studies Association's list?

90 comments

Johnny Boy's picture

Where is CCR? "Fortunate Son!" So powerful and radical...a bunch of Berkeley kids with a southern rock sound protesting the Vietnam War!

willi reichhold's picture

I am a patriot - Little Steven (or the version of Jackson Browne),
maybe not strong enough for the top twenty list but better then many other proposals

Mike Fraser's picture

Dylan - The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll.
Deeply moving anti-racist song based on a true story, although nowhere does it say she's black (she was).

euonym's picture

No Redskins? Didn't get more political than that when I was a wain.

Lemez's picture

The Election Song Contest is where political songwriting is at during these elections....

http://www.soundcloud.com/electionsongcontest

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JjQ1fsERGzk

writeoff's picture

Latina America is very under represented:

Intillimani: El Pueblo Unido / El Derecho de Vivir En Paz / Simon Bolivar / Si Somos Americanos

Ali Primera: La Patria Es El Hombre / Cancion Bolivariano etc.

It’s not just Costello:
Elvis Presley: In The Ghetto

And never forget Italy’s very best:
99 Posse: Comuntwist / El Pueblo Unido / Rigurgito Antifascista / Pagherete caro

TheD's picture

Fabrizio De André's "La Guerra di Piero" (Peter's war) would make my list. Poetic, powerful, beautiful. Had it been sung in English or French (instead of Italian), it would probably be *the* antiwar song of the previous century. Translations can be found here: http://www.antiwarsongs.org/canzone.php?lang=en&id=5

Also, so many songs written by Mikis Theodorakis would qualify (more than I can list here).

Two that stick out for me are "To Yelasto Pedi" (the laughing boy, also sung in English with the original Berndan Behan lyrics) and "Ena to Helidoni".

IMHO he deserves a mention for his incredible body of work (Z, Canto General, Axion Esti, etc.) which has become synonymous with the struggle against oppresion.

Angus Willson's picture

I suggest addition of two recent political songs by Show of Hands:
Country Life
Arrogance, Ignorance and Greed.

Both remain highly topical.

Bonnie's picture

Where are Pulp? "Misshapes" ( or more obviously "Common People") are both fantastic songs, but also political through and through.
Where are the women as well? Big Yellow taxi is a pretty poor Joni offering, how about ani difranco? "Talk to me now" or "Little plastic castle" (sample lyric: "I was blessed with the birth and the death and I just want some say in between"). Or Kimya Dawson's "Viva la persitence"("globalisation's killing me")
Or brenda kahn ( who i believe has a politics degree.)From "Goldfish don't talk back":
"There's a great big hole
where the sky used to be
and there's an asshole
on my TV who says
"Act now you get nine issues free
Plus an issue of women with an eating disease""

Theo Blackwell's picture

Lots from the Specials, Ghost Town and Maggie's Farm
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=igMMDzBKHyc

phill doran's picture

Sorry all, but if you are talking politics rather than posing – or worse still – shifting ‘product’, then you need to acknowledge the Gods of Protest, the Triumvirate of Transition, viz:

Middle of the Road: Chirpy Chirpy Cheep Cheep. For it was 1971 and the world was in turmoil – and although we all asked “where’s your mother gone?” perhaps we did not want to know the answer... for as recently as last night, we heard our mother singing this song...

Mouldy Old Dough: Lieutenant Pigeon 1972. As the opening bars set the tone for the east-west, ying-yang, neo-classic, neo-fascist, neopolitan ice-cream conflict of youth which the bass line underscores, or ‘muffles’ as the court papers indicated, so the fires of protest were well and truly lit – the rest, as they say, is a hysterectomy

Chicory Tip : Son Of My Father 1972, As Sven Goren Postlethwaite expounded in his seminal work, ‘The Indecipherable Lightness of Lyrics’, communism’s core shook before the power of rock once the people had a rallying cry – then it was ciao Brezhnev... angst for the memory.
(this list appears in my pamphlet “June 1971 – April 1972: 10 months That Shook the World.” Me, et al (although, if I’m honest, all Al did was make coffee)
From Phill Doran at the Institute of Walnut-lined Studies, and Padded Cells, Johannesburg-a-go-go

Tommy's picture

The great leap forward- Billy Bragg...Supreme

Jordi Garcia Fernandez's picture

and what about FUGAZI!, Minor Threat, Minutemen, Black Flag!
"Waiting Room" by Fugazi should definitely make that list.

podilato's picture

Has anyone mentioned the great French songwriter Jean Ferrat who died recently? His most famous 'nuit et brouillard'(influenced by an even more famous classic film of the same title) is about the millions of people forced into concentration camps and extirminated by the nazis during WW2. His most memorable line was 'je twisterais les mots s'il fallait les twister pour qu'un jour vos enfants sachent qui vous étiez' - about singing the words as a popular song - in those days on a 'twist' beat - so that young people get to know about this page of infamous history, transmit the message and never forget. Nowadays we would say 'rap the words' I suppose. This is indeed one of the greatest political songs because it is about the memory, education and the transmission of aural history as it always was throughout human kind.

Jean Ferrat wrote tirelessly about justice and highest political values. Another of his is 'la femme est l'avenir de l'homme' - woman is man's future - need I say more?

John's picture

Any political song list must have Chumbawamba- Never give up, Jacobs Ladder,Enough is Enough, Homophobia

petra sullivan's picture

what about dead prez? they're consistently ncredibly political

secularist's picture

-italian: Bandiera rossa
-Hymn of Bertolucci´s movie 1900
-"per me giunto" /Rodrigo + "liberta" Rodrigo´s and Don Carlos aria in Verdis Don Carlo
-National song of the Soviet Union
-Gracias a la vita V. Jara
-el pueblo unido Quilapaya

Tom Rowlands's picture

You're missing an absolute encapsulating moment of political music:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fvJzCdgB3Tc

Less Mcann and Eddie Harris - Compared to what

Of the US countercultural movement, perhaps the most hearfelt critique of American society.

Timz's picture

What about this current song and music video about the current UK elections:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IPyDwcaiPfc

swatantra's picture

Two more:
Blowing in the Wind
Where have all the flowers gone?

gault's picture

Drive-By Truckers!

mekko's picture

Yes, indeed, where are the Redskins?

scotleag's picture

Nothing from Tom Lehrer? Surely one from 'Werner Von Braun,' 'Vatican Rag' or 'I Wanna Go Back to Dixie' should be in there?

A few other contenders:
Country Joe & The Fish - 'Fixin' To Die Rag'

Joan Baez - plenty to choose from but 'Joe Hill' and 'I Pity The Poor Immigrant' will do for a start.

Eric Bogle - 'And The Band Played Waltzing Matilda' and 'No Man's Land'

Either Woody Guthrie or Dominic Behan's version but 'Jarama Valley' must be worth a shout.

Kris Kristofferson - 'The Law Is For The Protection Of The People'

John Prine - 'Sam Stone' or 'Unwed Fathers'

Asylum Street Spankers - 'Lee Harvey'

Tommy Makem & The Clancys - 'D-Day Dodgers'

Hamish Imlach - 'If It Wasn't For The Unions'

Buffy Sainte-Marie - 'Bury My Heart At Wounded Knee'

Steve Earle - 'John Walker's Blues'

Alex Glasgow - 'The Socialist ABC'

Adam's picture

Faithless - mass destruction?
Buffalo Springfield - for what it's worth?

Freeman2's picture

And what about the song from the only geuine working class revolution of the 20th century - Spain in 1936: A las barricadas:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=32mMk9kQOmM

swatantra's picture

'Always look on the bright side of life...' by Monty Python.

Pilko's picture

'He ain't heavy, he's my brother' - not politically specific, but a hymn to solidarity.

stuart's picture

underdog by kasabian,a true song for the underclass in society.

Mr Yellow's picture

"Mersey Paradise" and "Elizabeth My Dear" by the Stone Roses

John MacKay's picture

Ohio - Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young

You can all stop posting alternate suggestions now.

BillCo's picture

The Workers' Song (Ed Pickford)Sung By Dick Gaughan

http://www.youtube.com/watch?hl=en-GB&v=nrdl4ijru8o&gl=GB

The Freedom Come All Ye (Hamish Henderson) Sung by Luke Kelly

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rl7MYTTHUFg

A Man's a Man For a' That (Robert Burns)Sung by Ian Benzie

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QMRbOupoUfM&feature=related

redsonj.'s picture

No Billy Bragg ? A serious omission.

Paul Burgess's picture

Gerrard Winstanley's The Diggers Song has been stirring left-wing hearts for 350 years. A major omission!

collettex9's picture

Almost all of The Clash, e.g. London Calling, Guns of Brixton. And, surely, Sex Pistols' God Save The Queen & Anarchy in the UK should be there. Also, as others mention, The Redskins. Nor should you overlook The Dead Kennedys, e.g. Holidays in Cambodia.

Jefferson Fox's picture

Here's a new one!

http://jeffersonfox.bandcamp.com/track/bait-and-switch

Simon James's picture

Show of Hands 'AIG - Arrogance, Ignorance and Greed'
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T-n8ITk6UWM

The protest song is alive and well.

Portia's picture

Bob Marley's Redemption Song and No Woman No Cry, Burning Spear's Columbus, Slavery Days, Cry Blood Africa and First Continent. Awuleth'Umshini Wam sung frequently by names too numerous to mention (but the ANC Comrades version is most harmonious and ... very civilized).
Stevie Wonder's Living In The City, Chocolate City by Parliament and Christ Moore's version of Viva La Quinta Brigada.....

David Faubion's picture

Inspiring list and additions to it for our awareness. Commercial radio in the USA allowed us to hear some of the songs in the list; add these: For What its Worth--Buffalo Springfield; Wooden Ships--CSNY; Military Madness--Graham Nash; Peace Train--Cat Stevens; The Battlefield--ELP; The End--Doors; Seagull--Donovan; I'm Just A Singer, and, Lost in a Lost World--Moody Blue. The top forty gave us popular songs heavily produced with a lot of common passion in the lyrics and music.

Alan Parker's picture

great list but the redskins have to be there!

Samuel Dolton's picture

Despite not being around in the 1980s, I think the Thatcher years were the golden age of political songs in Britain. It gives some of us younger ones an idea of the political climate and dissent towards certain individuals. My favorite are:

The Jam - Eton Rifles, Going Underground

The Clash - Clampdown, (White Man) In Hammersmith Palais, Career Opportunities

The Beat - Stand Down Margaret

The Specials - Nelson Mandela, Ghost Town

Simply Red - Money's Too Tight To Mention

These songs include some of the best lyrics ever written, but I think The Smiths were bang on when they said "the music that they constantly play says nothing to me about my life." Would like to see political music revitalised, an unpopular government is needed.

Latest tweets