Cultural Capital

Reflections on books and the arts from the New Statesman culture desk

Syndicate contentRSS

Chinese whispers

Xiaolu Guo on the voices of a changing country

This year's Doc/Fest in Sheffield, which I caught the tail end of at the weekend, had a great selection of films on show. Of note were Men of the City, Marc Isaac's surprisingly tender portrait of workers in the City of London, and Erik Grandini's Videocracy, which unpicks the poisonous links between celebrity culture and political power in Berlusconi's Italy. There were also arts docs covering, variously, Brian Eno and the making of Tarkovsky's Stalker.

For me, though, the real star was Once Upon a Time Proletarian, by the Chinese novelist and director Xiaolu Guo. It consists of interviews with 12 people drawn from across Chinese society: from an ageing peasant who longs for the days of Mao, to frustrated small-town teenagers, to rich Beijing businessmen. Filmed in spare moments during the shooting of Guo's forthcoming fiction film, She, a Chinese (which I wrote about here), it has a wonderful spontaneity that captures a fleeting moment in China's history.

Below, taken from the Q+A session that followed the screening -- and abridged by me -- Guo explains what her film has to say about modern China.

I wanted to make a group portrait presenting the different social classes in China that have arisen over the last 20 years. China used to be a very simple society: before communism it was made up of peasants or slaves and the emperor system. From the 1950s onwards the whole country changed, but it was still a simple social structure: soldiers, workers and peasants.

Now China is in this period of radical change, where people are losing their identities, losing faith in both traditional and socialist values. There's a new middle class, millionaires, even billionaires. People who used to have a peasant identity, who spent their lives planting rice, now have to work in factories making computer parts.

[The film] shows a kind of collective melancholy. This whole country has lost its old values, and we were never a religious country, so now everyone has to force themselves to be civilised.

I don't trust objective narrative. For me, the truth is subjective and emotional. I don't want to know people's life stories, all I want to know is that moment when they look at the camera. It's very powerful but it's over so quickly.

2 comments

ed3's picture

China going through a radical change in faith and values is a myth. The general view of an 'exotic' east illustrates gross ignorance on the part of many on the nurtured nature of chinese civilisation. For instance, how many know that the combination of Confucianism and Legalism produces a non-genocidal version of Nazism - and which is pervasive in chinese dominated nations in s.e.Asia such as Singapore where a party identical to the BNP has ruled for half a century with much popular support, and which is at the forefront of the 'asian democratic' movement that shuns human rights activists and democrats as devotees of western culture.

To understand 'communist' china, and those socialised as 'chinese', one has to understand Confucianism and Legalism - fetishisation of tradition, uniformity and conformity, subservience in the face of all authority, not questioning laws, politics as the business of professional politicians, etc. When one does that, one will be in a better position to understand the entirety of chinese history.

The chinese never had 'socialist' values. They've been gross opportunists since 221 b.c. with opportunism being hierarchically ordered - hence, 'state capitalism'. One of the significant reasons for this is their being forcibly accustomed to top-down oppression for more than 2000 years; formulating a common culture of coping with the consequences of popular political failure; being trained to be averse to difference, hence gross bigotry; and having the distinction of being just about the longest standing nation-state on earth, hence cultural pride and exclusivity.

This sort of served the same function as the protestant work ethic in the west - except that the chinese have had 2000 years to perfect it. Hence, they have always been ready for capitalism and this doesn't require a change in mindset or values, just a cross-application in a socio-economic arena given a new form - capitalism. In terms of being alienated for the purpose of exploitation and opportunism, they are well ready for it.

a2ed.com

ed3's picture

China going through a radical change in faith and values is a myth. The general view of an 'exotic' east illustrates gross ignorance on the part of many on the nurtured nature of chinese civilisation. For instance, how many know that the combination of Confucianism and Legalism produces a non-genocidal version of Nazism - and which is pervasive in chinese dominated nations in s.e.Asia such as Singapore where a party identical to the BNP has ruled for half a century with much popular support, and which is at the forefront of the 'asian democratic' movement that shuns human rights activists and democrats as devotees of western culture.

To understand 'communist' china, and those socialised as 'chinese', one has to understand Confucianism and Legalism - fetishisation of tradition, uniformity and conformity, subservience in the face of all authority, not questioning laws, politics as the business of professional politicians, etc. When one does that, one will be in a better position to understand the entirety of chinese history.

The chinese never had 'socialist' values. They've been gross opportunists since 221 b.c. with opportunism being hierarchically ordered - hence, 'state capitalism'. One of the significant reasons for this is their being forcibly accustomed to top-down oppression for more than 2000 years; formulating a common culture of coping with the consequences of popular political failure; being trained to be averse to difference, hence gross bigotry; and having the distinction of being just about the longest standing nation-state on earth, hence cultural pride and exclusivity.

This sort of served the same function as the protestant work ethic in the west - except that the chinese have had 2000 years to perfect it. Hence, they have always been ready for capitalism and this doesn't require a change in mindset or values, just a cross-application in a socio-economic arena given a new form - capitalism. In terms of being alienated for the purpose of exploitation and opportunism, they are well ready for it.

ed
a2ed.com

Latest tweets