'Hoon is the real vandal'

UK Green Party leader Caroline Lucas gives her take on this week's runway protest by direct action g

Environment Secretary Ed Miliband should be careful what he wishes for. No sooner had he told the Guardian that more popular mobilisation on climate change was needed, than the activist group Plane Stupid kindly obliged.

Using tried and tested tactics from the book of non-violent civil disobedience to make their protests heard far and wide, campaigners took to the runway at Stansted first thing on Monday morning to protest about Ministers’ continuing inaction on the climate agenda.

With 52 cancelled flights, 57 arrests on the last count, and pole position on TV, nobody could say they were unaware of the group’s concerns, least of all the government.

However, the prime minister’s disingenuous response saying ‘everybody has a right to protest, but people also have a right to be able to travel without unnecessary hindrance” clearly shows which corporate lobbyist he remains most loyal to.

The decision to push ahead with the expansion of Stansted airport is environmental and economic madness, and Ed Miliband will need to prepare for many more such actions unless the government starts acting on the climate agenda with the urgency and ambition it requires.

Forget the much criticised “vandalism” of Plane Stupid. The real climate vandalism belongs to Transport Secretary Geoff Hoon, who has been more than willing to brush aside the huge public opposition to the expansion of Stansted, not to mention the wishes of the local authorities.

It seems increasingly clear that peaceful direct action is fast emerging as the only way to focus the government’s attention on the climate challenge.

At Kingsnorth Climate Camp earlier this year, we gathered peacefully to register our disgust at the government’s ongoing commitment to coal. On the Campaign Against Climate Change’s Global Day of Action last weekend, we gathered to demand rapid changes to safeguard our environmental future. This week, Plane Stupid showed that those who care about our planet and its people will not be silenced.

With climate emissions from air travel at an all time high, the government is living in a fantasy land if it thinks it can allow aviation to grow at such an alarming rate, while also committing to significant cuts in greenhouse gas emissions.

As one of the MEPs involved in the negotiations on the EU’s energy and climate package, I’ve seen at first hand – and watched in horror – as government leaders of EU member states, including our own, water down key elements of the package, which were never ambitious enough in the first place.

So it’s a bit rich of government ministers to suggest that politicians can’t make progressive climate policies in the absence of the popular mobilisations.

What we need from our politicians right now is genuine political leadership - and if Labour MPs can’t provide it, they should move out of the way and leave the job to the politicians, like the Greens, who can.

Dr Caroline Lucas MEP, Green Party

16 comments

gnuneo's picture

first of all, building new runways when oil depletion will ensure they will be unused even before they are completed is lunacy, plain and simple.

the world will soon have to move to vastly different form of air-travel, such as air-ships, before very much longer anyway, and they do not require the multinational construction companies to build enormous stretches of concrete and barbed wire. One must wonder if NuLabour's financial backers do not include some of these corporate giants.

oh they do? What a surprise.

the Govts 'climate change' policy is yet another perfect example of "The Third Way" - the Left gets words, the Right gets action.

these campaigners are to be congratulated - not only for *what* they are campaigning about, but also the simple fact that they *are* doing something.

it is NuLabour that should be in the dock defending their actions, not the Greens and environmental campaigners.

It is clear who are the real 'terrorists' here.

MaterialMonkee's picture

You're not gonna cut the CO2 from air travel for a long time. Itll probably be the last to go.
Power generation, automobiles yeah it going to and has to happen and there are piratical solutions that exist to these problems but the technological solutions for the aerospace industry are years behind.
I'm so dubious about the Greens because they basically only ever offer solutions that amount to reducing your materialistic quality of life as opposed generating intelligent discussion about how to improve it while making it act in equilibrium with the planet. This always make me believe that they're more on a puritanical trip against materialism which is their right to pursue but I wish they'd just be honest and say we think people should have less stuff and that will make them better people.

I'm even more dubious looking at Ms Lucas's academic back ground which consists of English literature and journalism. She entered into politics as a CND campaigner which doesn't require a high level of technical expertise to understand. Bombs are bad therefore campaign. But to campaign on most green issues should require a rigorous knowledge of the sciences as green issues are essentially just related to the applied sciences.

The whole campaign against the airline industry is itself indicative of a lack of scientific knowledge and critical reasoning. It constitutes an absolute failure to prioritize in the areas of the economy where CO2 reductions can realistically be made possibly for the sake of making grandiose and theatrical protests.

We spend over 25% of the EU budget on the common agricultural policy, subsidizing farmers to essentially set aside land to do nothing and to raise food prices. A real Green party would mobilize the airport protesters to march on Brussels and demand that the common agricultural policy is reformed so that land that is subsidised to grow nothing will grow bio-fuels for our cars. Bio-fuels aren't increasing food prices,
agricultural corporatism is

MaterialMonkee's picture

On another note I live in the south of Europe on a near minimum wage. I rely on low cost airlines to get home once a year at Christmas to see my family. Southern European salaries are about a third of northern european wages so these budget airlines arn't that low for those us making these wages.

Millions of migrant workers from the ex-soviet blocks use these flights to move about the EU.

Ms Lucas is a MEP, the tax on our meagre salaries pay her wages

How does she get to Brussels and back?

VC's picture

Caroline, MI5 must have agents embedded in "Plane Stupid", not to mention bugging, wiretaps via Langley, ect.

It is clear that the government and MI5 are using a double edged blade, the question is, which edge will impart the deepest cut?

Every passenger on those cancelled Ryanair flights, should sue every protester for compensation and costs. LOL

You greeens just haven`t thought it through.LOL

pete999's picture

I too was heartend to see the left support a gaggle of middle class nitwits in their attempts to keep the poor and underserving out of the sky.

When will they learn that planes are for nice people, not oiks?

BadConscience's picture

pete999:

You are definitely right. The issue can't be about impending global environmental collapse and wide-spread catastrophe. Rather, it must be about middle-class snobbery.

What ice bergs?

pete999's picture

Good question.

A better one might be 'what did Plane Stupid excpect to achieve?'

All thats happened is the media has been full of stories of people who through no fault of their own have missed family events and holidays.

Plane Stupid shot themselves and the environmentaly movment in the foot with this moronic display.

VC's picture

As I`ve pointed out above, if MI5 knew and Standsted security moved a snails pace, the one can only conclude that one of the governments objectives, was an attack on Ryanair itself, in an attempt to protect BA`s long term position/margin.LOL

Michael O`Leary was highly critical of over zealous security following the NWO sham liquid bomb plot which was designed to keep Bliar in power.

Petite Anglaise's picture

"Forget the much criticised “vandalism” of Plane Stupid. The real climate vandalism belongs to Transport Secretary Geoff Hoon ..."

Hoon's a real dumb loon!

VC's picture

Cybertiger

Hoon has always been a "dumb loon", but so is Lynas and Lucas!

I wouldn`t mind if the campaigned for a reduction in air travel across the board, or rationing each passenger with air miles. But they aren`t. They are wasting their time trying to stop runways being built.

Planes at LHR are waiting half an hour, just to land, they are waiting to take off, do we really want this to happen at Stansted? If you can`t get an absolute restriction on flights, then "Plane Stupid" are plain stupid wasting their time on runway building.

As usual, they government/MI5 have used a pressure group to attack one particular airline..."RYANAIR". It stinks.

explodingbadger1's picture

I support the protests whole heartedly. I feel sorry for the people held up but its a very small issue compared to the catastrophe that is taking place around us now. Its very sad to read the idiotic and short and sighted comments about this article. I really wonder about my fellow human beings propensity for self destruction.

sweety's picture

They have the publicity and the irate Colonels fuming as well as the Chavs this time! The manipulation here is interesting. There seems to be direct action against the proles taking these cheap flights to costa blanca. The people who are doing it are the young middle class eco-fuzzy, fodder who take the gap year flights in their droves to the ecologically friendly full moon, narcotic parties at Pha Na Fook. The Ridley's Turtle get high on the left overs!
Why not switch the power station off turn the airport off and when the populace come looking , hand over these eco-fascists to the mob for a bit of true roots, local democracy. Of course in modern EU land policeman even b'stard policeman deserve to have children throw molotov cocktails at them, they should accept the immolation as part of the community bonding process and the road to a better society.

taghioff.info's picture

Yep

taghioff.info's picture

But imagine the protest if all the small farmers in the developing world got wind of what is going to happen to them.

markh's picture

Is it a bit simplistic to think that only the poor take cheap flights? I'd say most of those flying at this time of year are middle class - they have enough money for multiple foreign trips through-out the year.

The cost of disrupting travellers is worth it considering the scale of the problem we are facing - I think the extinction of mankind is a little bit more important than if a few thousand people have their holidays disrupted. Until a carbon ration is brought in reducing capacity is one way to curb the growth of aviation, another way is develop more affordable international high speed trains so people have an alternative.

VC's picture

taghioff.info; so whats going to happen to farmes on the developing world, yawn?

markh, its amazing how complicit the greeens are with the NWO controlled MSM, by targetting Ryanair and the their customers, while BA and the growing cruise line business never gets a mention.

Oh yeh, you can fly LONG HAUL, then sit in a tin can while its pushed around the Caribbean for two weeks, only to fly home LONG HAUL.LOL

The government would like an International agreement on airline fuel duty, but only when the likes of Ryanair are out of business....hence the reason MI5 and the police did nothing to stop "Plane Stupid" at Stansted.

Maybe I should start a protest group and park a couple of cars at the entrance to Terminal 5...that would result in thousands of BA customers missing their flghts!LOL

Next thing we`ll hear, is that Micheal O`Leary has been found "dead in the woods".LOL

BTW, I use Ryanair, several times a year, to fly to Tours or Poitiers. There aren`t many, what you term poor people. There are business people, couples on a short break, MIDDLE CLASS families renting fairly expensive holiday homes and Brits who in France. Of course, these people used to drive, which can be expensive, depending on how many travel. One Ryanair flight has got to better for the environment, than 70 odd cars driving 1100 milies each with ferry, or tunnel crossing.

Like I said, the greeens have thought it through and for all I know, "Plane Stupid`s" high comand is made up of MI5 agents.LOL

Latest tweets