A spoiled state

Gabe Mosca

Published 23 October 2008

New Hampshire teacher Gabe Mosca tells us why voters in the Granite State get privileged access to their politicians

Barack Obama addresses New Hampshire voters

New Hampshire is the most spoiled of all the states.

Every four years presidential candidates converge upon New Hampshire and plead with voters. Give me a moment of your time. Give me your hand to shake. Give me your baby to kiss. Give me your vote.

But New Hampshire has just over one million residents? But New Hampshire is worth only a measly four electoral votes in November?

None of that matters.

New Hampshire has the first presidential primary, and because of this they sit in the top seat. In no other state do Americans have the ability not only see, but to converse with, so many candidates running for president of the United States. On any given weekend during the late fall of 2007, I could travel a short distance and listen to a candidate in an intimate setting. Close enough to hand Hillary a Kleenex. Close enough for Rudy Giuliani to hear my audible sighs.

When it comes to politics, particularly presidential politics, New Hampshire matters. Even with its lack of ethnic diversity or even an urban center, New Hampshire is given the task of leading the nation. One would think or at least hope that with this responsibility New Hampshire voters would be the most knowledgeable in the country. Unfortunately, they are not. Citizens of New Hampshire, like their countrymen, are too caught up in being on the side that wins.

As a secondary school history teacher I have the honor and duty to inform my students about the world around them. However, I also have the opportunity to hear their thoughts on the most recent election. The fascinating thing about the twelve year-olds I teach is that their political musings are often the unfiltered diatribes they hear at home, from their parents, New Hampshire voters.

Just yesterday I heard one student say, "Did you hear that Obama might not be able to run because he was born in Kenya?" This spring one lovely young girl was convinced that Senator Obama was a Muslim. I told her that was untrue, but followed up by asking what would the consequences be if it were true. Perhaps the most jaw-dropping of all statements came just last week when one young man said, "Obama said his priest was a racist."

Talking to eligible voters and listening to their children has convinced me that New Hampshire is no more informed than any other state. Which is a shame, because no citizens have greater opportunity to be well-informed as the people of New Hampshire.

Gabe Mosca teaches geography and politics in New Hampshire.

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

12 comments from readers

Randy Dujour
23 October 2008 at 18:59

Let me preface my statement by saying that I think the entire election process in the United States is a farce. It has been proven beyond a reasonable doubt that the 2004 presidential election was stolen. There are people serving time in Federal prison. My children's teachers are not aware of this. When my 9 year old daughter was asked which of the two candidates she would vote for, she replied, "Can I vote for one of the other candidates". Her public school teacher responded, "I didn't know there were more than two". There are at least five on the ballot in my home state.

Regarding:

"Just yesterday I heard one student say, "Did you hear that Obama might not be able to run because he was born in Kenya?"

The Washington (state) Secretary of State has asked that Obama provide the original birth certificate before allowing him to be place on the ballot there. So far, the Obama campaign has been unable to produce this document.

And then there's the fact that Obama has a brother in Kenya that he really didn't want anyone to know about.

So, its a legitimate question. You have to be a natural born citizen to be President of the United States.

Obama needs to provide the document and then this matter will be put to bed.

I like the man Obama but our government is not run by people but by large organizations.

Did you know that Obama's campaign finance manager is "Penny Pritzer" who ran the very first bank that was bailed out for sub-prime mortagages back in 2002? Obama has received 3 times as much money from Wallstreet as McCain and the current "crisis" is benefiting him.

As soon as we stop allowing questions to be asked and make our decisions based upon conjecture and anecdotes, we find ourselves at the mercy of the story tellers and their mega broadcast system.

prebek
24 October 2008 at 09:27

No, we're at the mercy of bitter voters like you who

aimlessly rant. Here is Obama's birth certificate:

http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/.shared/image.html?

/photos/uncategorized/2008/06/13/bobirthcertificate.jp

g

Of course you probably think it's a fake, because it's

easier to be mad that way. And by the way, you're exaggerating Penny Pritzker's role in Superior Bank of

Chicago's collapse. The company was founded by her

father Alvin Dworman. Penny only had a board seat in

the last 7 years of operation.

prebek
24 October 2008 at 09:32

correction: "her father AND Alvin Dworman." And here is

the obama link:

http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/.shared/image.html/photo

s/uncategorized/2008/06/13/bobirthcertificate.jpg

khewitt
24 October 2008 at 14:29

Regardless of my opinion on your political statements, I have a larger problem with your belief that, "As a secondary school history teacher I have the honor and duty to inform my students about the world around them."

Do you have the duty to inform them about politics? Do you even have the right to talk politics with them? You cannot prove any of the statements you made to students (Obama born in US; Obama not a Muslim), so therefore, you are doing the exact same thing that you criticize your students' parents for an projecting your views onto impressionable minds. As a teacher, you have even less of a right to do this than a parent does.

justflynby
24 October 2008 at 16:38

The "certificate" that Mr. Obama has posted on his official WEB site is a "Certification of Live Birth," and not a "Birth Certificate" from Hawaii. There is no indication on even this certificate as to specifically where the birth took place.

Mechinfantry
24 October 2008 at 20:14

Also, to all of you out there that keep refering to Senators McCain and Obama by just their last names..... You are the ones who have degraded the positions which they hold, not to mention the presidency. Call your mothers and tell them that they raised raised you wrong.

Randy Dujour
24 October 2008 at 20:15

Penny Pritzker was involved as a member of the Pritzker family. I'm not suggesting that she did anything wrong. But there is almost no reporting of this.

McCain/Palin is just too bizarre for me to contemplate. I live in Illinois which will deliver its electoral college votes to Obama which is fine with me.

My beef is with our media which somehow missed the rigged election of 2004 and the mysterious collapse of WTC7.

This isn't about personality and I'm not bitter.

Randy Dujour
24 October 2008 at 20:17

Senator is not a title of respect. I believe their approval rating is around 15%.

Respect the respectable.

Mechinfantry
24 October 2008 at 20:21

"Senator" is their title though!

moreteacrystal
24 October 2008 at 23:58

The world is full of opinions. Some good. Some not as good. The beauty of democracy in practice is that everyone is entitled to one. Gabe would be doing a disservice to his students if he didn't try to convince them of the merits of his own. Helps everyone with perspective. And judging by his craft of this article, I'd be willing to bet he is more apt to parent than some of the mongrels living in the boonies with him.

More to the point, the media spins everything for a story. The "facts" are so distilled by the time they get to us, it is virtually impossible to make a fair and informed decision about anything. As a result, we run things through our own filters and form opinions (some good, most shitty) which we then bestow not-so-unwittingly to our children . (Un)fortunately for them, they don't have these filters (read: sarcasm, distrust, gullibility, idealism, paranoia, bias, etc...) and many times end up taking what we say at face value. Usually, not a recipe for success. If I had a peso for every time a friend provided an erroneous interpretation of the global economic meltdown, I'd spend my weekends playing poker with Carlos Slim Helu. The "informative" culprits are always the same - CNN, NYT, Yahoo, etc... Mass media outlets manufacture, aggregate and syndicate garbage to drive traffic. Accuracy isn't so important. Eyeballs are. People love tragedy. People love villians. People love to blame. People love to consume.

But the reason our democratic system works is because my "informed" vote counts as much as their "uninformed" vote. I don't get extra points for being a wise ass, and they don't get penalized for being grossly incompetent.

In close, sweet pitch Gabe. Although you overstate your relative importance, it's good to hear someone with an educated opinion gives a shit.

khewitt should be tied to a piano and thrown in the Hudson.

moreteacrystal
25 October 2008 at 00:36

"Start teaching them how to read and write and shut your mouth about politics"

also, mechinfantry - i just ran into john scopes and clarence darrow at starbucks. they commended your insight and recommended you for sam brownback's next presidential campaign.

Mechinfantry
25 October 2008 at 20:58

Moreteacrystal....

I don't know whether to take that as a compliment or not. Clarence Darrow is one of my heroes. I am a soldier and I believe in three things; Accuracy, Brevity and Clarity.

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before you can comment on the website

Read More

Newsletter

Enter your email address here to receive updates from the team

Vote!

Will the Iraq inquiry be a 'whitewash'?

Suggest a question

View comments

© New Statesman 1913 - 2009

Tracker