Australia’s Katrina moment
Corruption and the cult of the market have made a natural disaster into an outrage.
By John Pilger Published 29 January 2011
When you fly over the earth's oldest land mass, Australia, the view can be shocking. There are scars as long as European countries, the result of erosion. Salt pans shimmer where once native vegetation grew. This is almost impossible to reverse. The first to die are the most vulnerable species. According to the International Union for Conservation of Nature, Australia's devastation of its natural environment has caused more mammal extinction than in any other country. The iconic koala is used to attract tourists; the Queen and Oprah Winfrey are photographed cuddling one, unaware that this unique creature has enriched the state of Queensland for decades with its industrial slaughter and the sale of its skin to Britain and America. Today, the belatedly "protected" koala is threatened not by flood or drought, but rapacious land-clearing, of which Queensland is the national champion. Each year, according to the World Wide Fund for Nature, the state in effect destroys 100 million birds, mammals and reptiles.
The land is "cleared" by fire or machinery, often with a heavy chain tied between two bulldozers: a technique developed by Queensland's most notorious land-clearer, the late Sir Johannes Bjelke-Petersen, the conservative state premier for 19 years, whose self-awarded knighthood was given for "services to parliamentary democracy", such as winning gerrymandered elections with 20 per cent of the vote. In 1992, a defamation jury found that Bjelke-Petersen had been bribed "on a large scale and on many occasions". Two of his ministers and his police commissioner were jailed. Lucrative land became a prize for cronies known as the "white shoe brigade". Brown envelopes of cash were handed over at a five-star hotel recently lapped by floodwaters in the centre of Brisbane.
Wrong type of flood
Last May, the Queensland Labor government announced that it had sold swaths of the state's forests and plantations to Hancock Queensland Plantations, a subsidiary of a US-based timber multinational. Queensland has many low-lying flood plains on which developers have been allowed to make fortunes selling plots. The victims of the great flood have been mostly poor people. Most could not afford insurance, or discovered that their policy did not include "types of flood".
The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, says an ACCC report, deliberately stopped insurance companies from agreeing a common definition of flood so that "insurers will continue to compete vigorously by product differentiation" through offerings that use many definitions of "flood" to specify which risks are covered and which are excluded. The callousness of this imposed confusion is emblematic of how the Australian elite have treated those ruined by an inland ocean the size of Germany and France combined. Flooding also struck Brazil in April and Sri Lanka in December, but the disaster in Australia is far more revealing; for Australia is a "first-world" country with advanced technology and communications, and yet tens of thousands of people received no emergency warning. Here, the cult of the "market" has diminished public services and infrastructure budgets, and divided by wealth a society that once boasted the most equitable spread of personal income in the world.
Little of this is discussed in a media where Rupert Murdoch owns 70 per cent of state capital-city press. When the leader of the Greens, Bob Brown, dared suggest that the Queensland flood was due in part to "the burning of fossil fuels [causing] the hottest oceans we've ever seen off Australia", he was told to apologise to the mining industry. In the decade to 2005, says the Wilderness Society, "the amount of land-clearing in Australia was so extensive that the greenhouse gases produced rivalled the amount produced by cars and trucks".
Divide and rule
A feature of the floods has been the PR campaigns of leading right-wing Labor Party politicians, notably the prime minister, Julia Gillard, and the Queensland premier, Anna Bligh, who have talked up the "Aussie battler" spirit in the face of "Mother Nature's wrath". The media echo of this evokes Sir Johannes's description of spinning a line to journalists as "feeding the chooks". In truth, successive governments have rejected, ignored or suppressed the recommendations of their own experts which, if acted upon, could have saved Brisbane.
In 1999, a report commissioned by Brisbane City Council warned of "significantly higher" flooding than in the last great flood in 1974. When this was leaked, an alleged cover-up was referred to the state's crime and misconduct commission, but nothing happened.
Andrew Short, director of the coastal studies unit at the University of Sydney, compares the Queensland flood with the scandal of New Orleans following Hurricane Katrina. "This is something we have been waiting for . . ." he said. "Why were there no levees to protect the low-lying towns? . . . Why are major highways and railways still below flood level?"
Prime Minister Gillard has so far offered crumbs from a treasury in surplus, that subsidises the fossil-fuel industry with A$10bn (£6.2bn) and that is pledged to spend A$1.1bn on Australia's mercenary "commitment" to American wars. Having sent just 13 helicopters to rescue the stranded, Gillard appointed Major General Mick Slater to lead the recovery operation: an admission that the civilian emergency services had been so depleted, they could not cope. Slater's most interesting statement has been a threat. "There is no reason why we won't have [success]," he said, "unless . . . the media start to become divisive within the community and then, if there are areas of failure, I think I could find the reason and track it back to different areas within the media." He was not challenged. The chooks were fed.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists


128 comments
this is my last salvo andyg.
If you are too lazy to work out what a rebate is then you deserve none of my knowledge.
got that you lazy git.
dickhead. get an economics education.
Mr Divine, you are now talking environment but don't define what you mean by the word. I'm glad that you have the thing's that you say you have and given your correspondance I get the gut feeling that you have earned them with honest intent of which I take my hat off to you.
But part and parcel of the environment debate whether in Australia or elsewhere is why are the waters rising, and why is mother nature fighting back? This is the crossroads of where those profiteers are now sending the PR people to give the lies and disinformation, again whether it be in Australia or elswhere. If it wasn't for people like John Pilger bringing this into the open then worse atrocities will most certainly occur in your country and Mine. Power Mr Divine, true power begins with the land and ends with the gun. All the things you mention including your computer, home, car, etc etc began by been extracted from the land.
I agree Jonny B. QLD under you won and lost. Some parts of the land were destroyed by your eagerness to develop whatever the consequences. But modern day has moved on. there are a lot of smart people in Australia who are well aware of the need to protect the land from overdevelopment. The Land care program is huge in Ausralia as is the national park staff.. and rightly so. There is no doubt that government is here to protect ourselves from vicious property development especially in areas of natural beauty (which is in fact all the earth!). The Australian government has done an excellent job in many respects. Credit where credit is due. Criticism where criticism is due. That's the problem John you're always just seeing it from a telescope fixed to a 'standard' viewpoint of the world. And you twist facts to suit your 'bad' view of the situation.
Maybe you know this, but the real action in writing at the moment is on this part of the telescope, looking at you, looking at the world.
For tis the nature of the beast to proclaim his cleverness and flaunt his new found wealth; For there is no forward thinking within his intellectual makeup, merely a childlike need to fullfill the gratifications for immediate pleasures. He struts his stuff creating resentment, hatred, boastfullness and a lack of all known rules in witnessing hidden sadistic pleasures.
That baying beast, is always revealed by the sound of his roar.
(William Shakespear).
Natural disasters happen, the same as shit, even to good fearing socialists! The problem is clever white men starting with the Victorians have minimised their impact even in tropical lands! Overpopulation will mean more newsworthy events that can be blamed on climate change.
@ Mr Divine
I accept your apology........... again.
Hope your head and liver recover. Ican just imagine you hitting your head on the rebate of some door, poor thing.
Your last salvo never addresses the whole. I wasn't aware that you required a degree to work out human right abuses or to understand what profit means. Isn't profit wages that haven't been paid to the worker(s)?
Mr. Woogy; why are being racist to white men? it's all men.
Another racist bites the dust.
Good article by John Pilger. One wonders when look-the-other-way Australians will finally join the dots and realize the extent to which cowardly, corrupt Lib-Lab politicians have betrayed them by inaction over man-made climate change.
Climate scientists inform us that because the weather is variable one cannot attribute the severity of specific events such as the La Nina-connected Australian flood and Cyclone Yasi disasters to man-made climate change - but that this cannot be excluded either. They also tell us that increase in such events is predicted by climate models; that there has already been a 4-10 fold warming-associated increase in severe floods since the 1950s; that ocean temperatures are increasing; that severe cyclones have doubled in recent decades; that the area burned each year in the Western US has increased 5-fold in 4 decades; and that global warming means increased humidity, increased precipitation (for numerous expert, science-based views on man-made climate change and floods and cyclones see https://sites.google.com/site/300orgsite/climate-change-floods and https://sites.google.com/site/300orgsite/scientists-cyclones ).
Greens leader and senator Dr Bob Brown has sensibly demanded that the major GHG polluters such as the gas and coal industries should be taxed to pay for the damage they cause via climate change. Indeed, extreme weather aside, it can be estimated that carbonaceous fuel burning pollutants kill about 10,000 Australians every year (see: https://sites.google.com/site/yarravalleyclimateactiongroup/2011-carbon-... ) .
Instead, the do nothing, pro-coal, pro-gas, pro-Zionist, pro-war, anti-renewable energy Lib-Labs support a $9 billion pa subsidy for fossil fuel burning (that should be used for post-disaster reconstruction) and $1 billion pa for a criminal and unwinnable Afghan War that so far has killed 4.5 million Afghans, this including 2.3 million avoidable Afghan infant deaths (money and resources that should be used for flood relief rather than for passively killing Asian children).
Climate criminal, Lobbyocracy and Murdochracy Apartheid Australia is a world leader in annual per capita greenhouse gas (GHG) pollution but its Zionist US-perverted look-the-other-way culture means that its Lib-Lab politicians still won't accept that it is fouling its own nest, with the last month alone seeing record floods from Queensland to Tasmania, the worst cyclone for a century and disastrous bushfires in Perth.
Sorry andyg, Friday night piss up: Look a rebate is a refund on the tax you have already paid. The diesel rebate in Oz is for ALL primary producers. its a tax refund not just for BHP. it isn't a subsidy.
but you really need a economics education ... i can't keep giving you lessons. u will never be taken seriously i you don't.
andyg; Yes you're absolutely right in what you have said. Agriculture has destroyed flora and fauna in Australia. and it has been to such an extent that there is problems with salinity in many areas. Nearly all Australians know this... there are buildings in my town with huge cracks caused by the rising salt levels.
Like I said before, all construction involves destruction. But people need to be fed, people have to be accomadated, roads need to connect, mines tapped . It is a balancing act.
Britain used to be covered with forests including the tops of the moors. Australia is pristine in comparison to the rest of the world .. it really is. and while the Australian governments have made mistakes in the past there are policies now in place that protect the natural environment to some extent... have you heard about the no-fishing zones in NSW coastal waters or the water license buy back scheme? I have watched 'Landline' a farmers TV program for the past 15 years and in it there are stories of farmers who have been successful in planting trees and reversing their past mistakes. .
My objection is the inaccuracies that Pilger presents in this article. I have not difficulty realising that people have in some respects destroyed the land.