Return to a secret country

Kevin Rudd's apology to the Aborigines has changed little. White Australia must offer its first peop

I remember the boys dressed in army surplus, the girls in hessian, silhouettes framed in beach shanties, staring across an abyss. You were not meant to talk about them. They were not counted in the census, unlike the sheep, and anyway were dirty and feckless and dying off.

You were not meant to disturb the surface of our great southern idyll, sun-kissed and God-blessed, in circumstances that might raise questions of race. At high school, I studied a celebrated historian, Russel Ward, who wrote: "We are civilised and they are not." They were the first Australians. At least he mentioned them. Other textbooks simply left them out.

Today, almost everything has changed and has not changed. For many Aboriginal people, who value healing, Prime Minister Kevin Rudd's apology last year was important. They and their white allies had worked tirelessly for the mere word to be uttered. The resistance was formidable; white supremacist politicians, journalists and academics damned the "black armband version of our history". And when Rudd finally said it, the Sydney Morning Herald described the apology as "a piece of political wreckage" that the "government has moved quickly to clear away . . . in a way that responds to some of its supporters' emotional needs".

Australia's apartheid

There is to be no compensation for those thousands of Aborigines wrenched from their families as children, known as the stolen generation. And the previous, openly racist government's "intervention" into Aboriginal lands in the Northern Territory is being consolidated. In 2007, on the pretext that Aboriginal children were being sexually abused in "unthinkable numbers", the government of John Howard suspended the Racial Discrimination Act and sent the army and "business managers" to take over black communities.

Within a year, barely reported statistics proved how bogus it all was. Out of 7,433 children examined by doctors, at most four possible cases of sexual abuse were identified. The Australian Crimes Commission found no evidence of paedophile rings. What it found, it already knew: poverty and sickness on the scale of Africa and India.

Since Rudd's apology, Aboriginal poverty indicators have gone backwards. His "Closing the Gap" programme is a grim joke, having produced not a single new housing project.

An undeclared agenda comes straight from Australia's colonial past: a land-grab combined with an almost prurient need to control, harass and blame a people who have refused to die off, whose genius is their understanding of an ancient land that still perplexes and threatens white authority. Whenever Canberra's politicians want to look "tough", they give the Aborigines a good kicking: it is a ritual as sacred as Don Bradman worship or Anzac Day.

The indigenous affairs minister, Jenny Macklin, has decreed that unless certain communities hand over their precious freehold leases, they will be denied basic services. The Northern Territory contains abundant mineral wealth, such as uranium, and has long been eyed by multinationals as a lucrative radioactive waste dump. The blacks are in the way, yet again: so it is time for the usual feigned innocence. Rudd has said his government "doesn't have a clear idea of what's happening on the ground" in Aboriginal Australia. What? The learned studies pour forth as if the sorcerer's apprentice is loose.

One example: the rate of incarceration of black Australians is five times that of black South Africans during apartheid. Western Australia imprisons Aboriginal men at eight times the apartheid figure, an Aussie world record.

On 16 November, a 12-year-old Aboriginal boy appeared in court charged with receiving a Freddo Frog chocolate bar from a friend who had allegedly taken it from a supermarket. Only the international headlines forced the police to drop the case. Two-thirds of Aboriginal children who have contact with the police are jailed; two-thirds of white children are cautioned. A young Aboriginal man was jailed for a year for stealing £12 worth of biscuits and soft drink.

A mattress in the desert

In my lifetime, Australia has become one of the most culturally diverse places on earth, and it has happened peacefully, by and large. This proud achievement fades when you drive into a country town and pass the funerals of native people, many of them young, who take their own lives. The whispering in Antipodean hearts is race. The navy is sent against leaking boats filled with refugees, Tamils and Afghans, and if they cannot be dumped behind razor wire somewhere in Indonesia, they are isolated on Christmas Island, which, for the purpose, has been "excised" from the Australian map by a legal sleight of hand. How clever.

While I have been in Australia, Irene Khan, Amnesty's secretary general, has been travelling through the vast outback region known as Utopia. The roads are dirt; water often trickles from a single standpipe. She saw children, their eyes streaming and coughs hacking. She met Elsie, who sleeps on a mattress in the desert, yet pays rent to the government. Shocking, she says.

There is currently a liberal clarion call for a bill of rights, and the republican movement is stirring again. These debates are meaningless until white Australia summons the moral and political imagination to offer its first people a genuine treaty, as well as universal land rights and a proper share of resources. And respect. Only then will this fortunate society earn the respect it so often craves by other means.

On 4 November, John Pilger received the Sydney Peace Prize, Australia's international human rights award. "A Secret Country", his history of Australia, published 20 years ago, remains in print (Vintage, £10.99)
www.johnpilger.com

Next week: Mehdi Hasan

4 comments

Gideon Polya's picture

Excellent article by John Pilger. Jezza67's comments are extremely offensive but reveal the mentality of White Australia.

However lots more needs to be said. Thus the Australian Labor Party (aka the Apartheid Labor Party) in Opposition supported the Liberal-National Party Coalition's race-based legislation that removed Northern Territory (NT) Indigenous Australians from the protection of the 1975 Racial Discrimination Act.

(1) NT Indigenous Australians are forbidden to see, read, buy, transport, sell or consume things that all other Australians can; (2) their welfare monies are seized and controlled by the Government (the Apartheid Labor Government now wants to make this nation-wide without specification of Aborigines but this will simply mean, like the White Australian Policy, that non-Whites will be targetted nation-wide without the racist Labor Government actually saying so); (3) NT Indigenous Australians can be expelled from their homes, communities and sacred Lands on the say so of White officials with no legal recourse; (4) new laws will mean that nearly all school instruction to NT Indigenous Australians will be conducted in a foreign language (English) - ethnocide.

Several years ago the National Indigenous Times devoted a whole issue to the appalling circumstances of Indigenous Australians including an article by me about the appalling medical circumstances and entitled "Body Couint. The Awful Truth" (see: http://www.nit.com.au/news/story.aspx?id=11552 ) .

In short, the annual death rate is 2.2% for Indigenous Australians, and 2.4% for Indigenous Australians in the Northern Territory - as compared to 0.4% (what it should be), 0.9% for Indians, 1.0% for non-Arab Africans, 2.5% for SHEEP in Australian paddocks, 4.0% for Poles in the Polish Holocaust under the Nazis in WW2 and 7% (for under-5 year old infants in Australia-occupied Afghanistan).

The world must stop the Aboriginal Genocide by Sanctions against racist Apartheid Australia.

Jonathan B's picture

Interesting article JP but very bleak and one sided. You ignore the tens of thousands of Australians including Jenny Macklin who daily work with or care for the indigenous communities - to make their lives less of a struggle - with varying degrees of success but all with genuine resolve. Which brings me to the first point of contention with reliable Gideon - contortion of the issue of "English in the morning" at school into an instance of racial genocide!!

Please Gideon - take a Bex and a lie down. What would you have the teachers and in most cases the elders do? Leave each tiny community in the trap of their colonial past? Not teach them English (because not teaching them in the morning would surely mean that)? My second point - I laughed when I compared JP's paragraph regarding the Fredo Frog with (for example) Robert Hughes' (The Fatal Shore) compelling lists of crimes for which of the ancestors of a sizeable proportion of today's Australian population were SENT there for - stealing bread, stealing a bolt of cloth etc. Etc. And you think things have changed? It takes generations particularly amongst New South Welshmen (and women) to turn the gaoled into the gaolers. Only six months or so ago I heard of a case in no less a pleasant place than Ringwood in outer Melbourne where a boy of 19 was found guilty for stealing a box of chocolates from Coles. Albeit that he didn't go to gaol I am not sure that his conviction was racially motivated. Or was it JP/Gideon? Take out the word "aboriginal" and this could be a story of the petty crime that is dealt with by weary and bored police and magistrates over the entire country. There are an estimated 700 homeless teenagers sleeping on the streets in and around central Melbourne. AND JP you should know better than to write that a minister can 'decree" anything - that's either sloppy journalism or just plain deliberate. Kind Regards Jonathan B

mount1's picture

damn statistics. call it a nation, and it has the lowest literacy rate in the world

Jezza67's picture

No John, you may crave the respect of others, most Australians do not. The simple fact is that as long as the aborigines choose to live in the middle of nowhere, they cannot expect to live a first-world lifestyle.

If you wish to blame some white person for the plight of the sick and blighted, please feel free to blame the rights activists and anthropologists who insist that maintaining the aborigines in their "pristine" state so that they may preserve their culture.

No probs - take your pick - ancient culture and ancient health care and education, or join the 21st century and let the activists and academics find real jobs.

I also take exception to your selective use of statistics (the 12 year old Freddo-thief) and insinuation that all white Australians are crypto-racists. This is academically lazy and displays a crude ignorance of the nuances of demography and immigration policy.

Latest tweets