Glossy façades can’t hide an Indian spring

From Jammu Kashmir to Maharashtra, in a land of empty advertising slogans and fantastic wealth that

When the early morning fog rises and drifting skeins from wood fires carry the sweet smell of India, the joggers arrive in Lodi Gardens. Past the tomb of Muhammad Shah, the 15th-century Mughal ruler, across a landscape manicured in the 1930s by Lady Willingdon, wife of the governor general, recently acquired trainers stride out from ample figures in smart saris and white cotton dhotis. In Delhi, the middle classes do as they do everywhere, though here there is no middle. By mid-morning, children descend like starlings. They wear pressed blazers, like those of an English prep school. There are games and art and botany classes. Shepherded out through Lady Willingdon's elegant stone gateway, they pass a reed-thin boy, prostrate beside the traffic and his pile of peanuts, coins clenched in his hand.

When I was first sent to report on India, I seldom raised my eyes to the Gothic edifices and façades of the British Raj. All life was at dust and pavement level and, once the shock had eased, I learned to admire the sheer imagination and wit of people who survived the cities, let alone the countryside - from the dabbawallah (literally "person with a box") to the cleaners, runners, street barbers, poets, assorted Fagins and children with their piles of peanuts.

In Calcutta, as it was still known during the 1971 war with Pakistan, civil defence units in soup-plate helmets and lungis toured the streets announcing an air-raid warning practice during which, they said, "everybody must stay indoors and remain in the face-down position until the siren has ceased to operate". Waves of mocking laughter greeted them, together with the cry: "But we have no doors to stay inside!"

Predators

After the imperial capital was moved to Delhi early in the 20th century, New Delhi was built as a modernist showpiece, with avenues and roundabouts and a mall sweeping up to the viceroy's house, now the president's residence in the world's most populous democracy. If the experience of colonialism was humiliating, this proud new metropolis would surely be enabling. On 15 August 1947, it was the setting for Pandit Nehru's declaration of independence "at the midnight hour". It was also a façade behind which the majority hoped and waited, and still wait.

This notion of façade is almost haunting. You sense it in genteel Lodi Gardens and among the anglicised elite with their enduring ambiguity. In the 1990s, it became a wall erected by the beneficiaries of Shining India, which began as a slogan invented by an American advertising firm to promote the rise of the Hindu nationalist BJP-led government. Shorn of Nehru's idealism and paternalism, it marked the end of the Congress Party's pretence of class and caste reconciliation: in other words, social justice. Monsanto and Pizza Hut, Microsoft and Murdoch were invited to enter what had been forbidden territory to corporate predators. India would serve a new deity called "economic growth" and be hailed as a "global leader", apparently heading "in what the smart money believes is the right direction" (Newsweek).

India's ascent to "new world power" is both true and what Edward Bernays, the founder of public relations, called "false reality". Despite a growth rate of 6.9 per cent and prosperity for some, more people than ever live in poverty in India, and more of them than anywhere else on earth, including a third of all malnourished children. Save the Children says that every year two million Indian infants under the age of five die.

The façades are literal and surreal. Ram Suhavan and his family live 60 feet above a railway track. Their home is the inside of a hoarding that advertises, on one side, "exotic, exclusive" homes for the new "elite" and, on the other, a gleaming car. This is in Pune, Maharashtra, which has "booming" Bombay and the nation's highest suicide rate among indebted farmers.

Start the fightback

Most Indians live in rural villages, dependent on the land and its rhythms of subsistence. The rise of multinationals' monopoly control of seed, forcing farmers to plant cash crops such as GM cotton, has led to a quarter of a million suicides, a conservative estimate. The environmentalist Vandana Shiva describes it as "recolonisation".

Using the Land Acquisition Act of 1894, central and state governments have forcibly dispossessed farmers and tribal peoples in order to hand their land to speculators and mining companies. To make way for a Formula One racetrack and gated "elite" estates, land was appropriated for $6 a square metre and sold to developers for $13,450 a square metre. Across India, communities have fought back. In Orissa State, the wholesale destruction of betel farms has spawned a resistance now in its fifth year.

What is always exciting about India is this refusal to comply with political mythology and gross injustice. As Sunil Khilnani wrote in The Idea of India: "The future of western political theory will be decided outside the west." For the majorities of India and the west, liberal democracy is now diminished to "the assertion of an equal right to consume [media] images".

In Kashmir, a forgotten India barely reported abroad, a peaceful resistance as in­spiring as Tahrir Square has arisen in the most militarised region on earth. As the victims of Partition, Muslim Kashmiris have known none of Nehru's noble legacies. Thousands of dissidents have "disappeared" and torture is not uncommon. "The voice that the government of India has tried so hard to silence," wrote Arundhati Roy in 2008, "has massed into a deafening roar. Hundreds of thousands of unarmed people have come out to reclaim their cities, their streets and mohallas. They have simply overwhelmed the heavily armed security forces by their sheer numbers, and with a remarkable display of raw courage." An Indian spring may be next.

30 comments

Mr Woogy's picture

Pilger like Tarzan goes to India as one of the rich idle elite he pretends to despise so much.

Mr Danger's picture

"Is the $6 to $13,450 a sqm a misprint? , just trying to get my head around it...can't find a source."

The source is Vandana Shiva, an ecofeminist activist. Similarly Pilger's 'conservative' estimate that a quarter million suicides are the fault of western agribusiness is from Shiva.

I can't speak for her first claim but the second is is classic tententious Pilger. We are required to believe that all farmers in India who commit suicide are the fault of the west - it is the only variable in the equation. We are told that Indian farmers are "forced" to plant GM cash crops.

This is obviously ridiculous, farmers in India can grow subsistence crops if they want, and have no obligation to choose GM seeds. The International Food Policy Research Institute couldn't find a meaningful statistical link between suicide and GM seeds. Cotton production has boomed in India and uptake of GM seeds is increasing.

Ellmore Disco's picture

Fascinating article on a woefully under-reported subject.

Oh, and well done for using Bombay and not Mumbai.

Mr. Divine's picture

John:
Merry Christmas
Here's a few photos of my place in the Riverina.

I'm a bloke in the background of one picture wearing a blue checked shirt.

Been watching the cricket?

Mr. Divine's picture

http://photocapsions.blogspot.com/search?updated-max=2011-12-17T19:36:00...

Mr Danger's picture

Pilger also says that "Despite a growth rate of 6.9 per cent and prosperity for some, more people than ever live in poverty in India".

This is a common trick - when the rate of poverty (%) is decreasing, the left often turns to absolute numbers, which is boosted by population growth. So even though a country is successfully decreasing the rate of poverty, propagandists like Pilger can try to fool readers into thinking poverty is increasing.

"for the majorities of India and the west, liberal democracy is now diminished to "the assertion of an equal right to consume [media] images"

Again, the classic Pilger insult to our intelligence. Pilger can go to Cuba and marvel at how few impediments to freedom there are, and upon his return to his comfortable home in Europe he pronounces liberal democracy dead here. Oh the tyranny he must experience in Clapham.

Gideon Polya's picture

A fundamental measure of the success or otherwise of social policy is the annual death rate of under-5 year old infants. Using UN Population Division data (2010 revision) one estimates that in India in 2010 there were 1.9 million under-5 infant deaths out of a population of 128 million under-5 infants, this yielding an annual death rate of 1.5% pa for Indian under-5 infants as compared to (2003 data) 3.9% (non-Arab Africa), 2.0% (South Asia), 1.6% (Pacific Islands including PNG), 1.0% (South East Asia), 1.3% (Arab countries), 2.0% (Central Asia, Turkey and Iran), 0.8% (East Asia), 0.8% (China), 0.7% (Latin America), 0.4% (Eastern Europe), 0.2% (Overseas Europe (North America, Israel, Australasia) and 0.1% (Western Europe). India fares much worse than China (see "Body Count. Global avoidable mortality since 1950": http://globalavoidablemortality.blogspot.com/ ).

However another measure is avoidable mortality (avoidable death, excess death, excess mortality, deaths that need not have happened = actual deaths minus deaths expected for a decently run country with the same demographics) that in 2010 totalled 5.0 million for India or, as a percentage of the whole population, 0.41% pa as compared to (2003 values) 0.97% (non-Arab Africa), 0.0.39% (Pacific Islands including PNG), 0.38% (South Asia), 0.26% (South East Asia), 0.25% (Arab countries), 0.26% (Central Asia, Turkey and Iran), 0.01% (East Asia), 0.0% (China), 0.03% (Latin America), 0.31% (Eastern Europe), 0.05% (Western Europe) and 0.0% (Overseas Europe).

Unlike China, India under a corrupt democracy has been unable to eliminate gross endemic poverty that effectively kills about 5 million Indians every year.

The corrupt Indian Establishment ruling India has nevertheless done rather better than the racist British under whom the annual avoidable death rate for Indians was a genocidal 3.3% in 1947 as compared to "only" 0.4% today. Indeed while 0.2 billion Indians died avoidably in the post-Independence period 1950-2005, about 1.8 billion Indians died avoidably from imposed deprivation under the merciless British in the period 1757-1947 (see "Jane Austen and the Black Hole of British History": http://janeaustenand.blogspot.com/ ).

Indians need a New Independence from merciless capitalist greed.

john woods's picture

It must be nice being Pilger. Wish I chad the time leisure and money to jet off to all these exotic places, - Cuba one week, Mexico the next, India the next, - do a bit of poverty tourism, emote over the locals, then fly back (presumably biz class) to Blighty courtesy of those evil capitalist airline companies and return to my nice house in yuppie Clapham. What this activity actually ACHIEVES i just dunno: just fills column inches, provides Pilger with something to do in his retirement, and makes the people who read it Feel Good About Themselves.

Daulat Ram's picture

What is the NS up to these days?

Running down India and Hindu nationalism while singing the praised of Imran Khan, a notably fierce advocate of Islamic nationalism in Pakistan and indeed the protege of General Hamid Gul, the godfather of al-qaeda and the Taliban?

Is it connected with the role of Jemima Khan as an associate editor on the NS? What are her qualifications for that role other than having a big pile from daddy?

What IS the NS up to these days? Where has the old paper of Kingsley Martin wandered?

john woods's picture

Polya: has it ever occurred to you that the high infant mortality rates in Raj era India might have had something to do with female circumcision and the killing of female babies? Just a thought.

Latest tweets