Return to: Home | World Affairs | Asia

Tigers under the bed

Brad Adams

Published 18 June 2009

Observations on the Tamil Tigers

After 25 years of conflict, the defeat of the brutal Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) brought hopes that Sri Lanka’s government would embark on serious efforts to work with moderate Tamil leaders to address the long-standing grievances of the Tamil community, which the LTTE claimed but failed to represent.

Steps to end discrimination against Tamils would be a good start, as would a mood of magnanimity from the Sinhalese majority government of President Mahinda Rajapaksa. Wary Tamils, who have borne the brunt of the Tigers’ violence, need a sign that they will be equal citizens in the “new” Sri Lanka.

They are not getting it. The government is treating all Tamils in the north-east of the country, the former headquarters of the LTTE, as presumptive criminals. Around 300,000 Tamils are now being held in detention camps, barred from leaving even if they have family members or friends who would take them in. Many are children, elderly, or others who cannot reasonably be considered dangerous.

Huge numbers of people are being held indefinitely behind barbed wire. Far from enjoying their liberation from the LTTE, they are prisoners, again. The government could hardly have devised a policy more likely to engender fear and suspicion.

This is no accident. It is part of a larger policy to control all aspects of the postwar situation and root out enemies, real and imagined. In a country that is desperate for IMF assistance to avoid literally going broke, the army has announced a 50 per cent increase in its size, from 200,000 to 300,000.

The government is also systematically harassing and threatening aid workers, the media and Sri Lankans who question the detention policy. It has refused visas to some humanitarian workers and kicked out others. Many Sri Lankan journalists and activists have fled the country recently, fearing the notorious “white vans” that have for so long picked up dissidents in the night and made them disappear.

Rajapaksa and his advisers, staunch Sinhalese nationalists, appear to believe the western world, including the UN, have been plotting against them. Virtually anyone who had any contact with the LTTE, whether Sri Lankan or foreign, is now a suspected LTTE sympathiser. Sri Lanka appears headed for a McCarthyite period where the government believes – or cynically acts as though it believes – there is a Tamil Tiger under every bed.

The end of a long-running war should be a time for celebration, but the Sri Lankan government risks a new cycle of grievance and militancy. It must be pressed to plan for the future instead of fighting the last war. Allowing Tamils out of the camps and investigating the conduct of the war would be extremely significant actions. But they won’t happen if the UN, US, British and other governments move on to other crises and forget strategically unimportant Sri Lanka.

Brad Adams is Asia director at Human Rights Watch

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

7 comments from readers

Shanthy
18 June 2009 at 15:43

There is no magnanimity on the part of Sri Lanka with the staunch ultra nationalists in coalition.

What Colombo needs is to fill up the depleted war chest with humanitarian aid.

vishnurama
19 June 2009 at 11:54

It is not the matter of Tigers; it is the matter of Tamils. Japan supported the massacre of Tamils though it itself is under the Korean nuclear bombs. Japanese just want to put roads and sell their cars. They seem to be learned nothing out of the Second World War. Georgia sent troops to Iraq to help Americans to win the War; in the meantime their fate was decided by the Russians. Different countries nursed different speculative ambitions when the Eeelam war was going on, they pretend to be not aware of that some people are at the other side to decide their fate. In this case nobody is exceptional even ‘the super powers’. That is the logic of conflicts. Western super powers and America have been fighting wars with tribal people; still they are not able to win. ‘The world community’ and ‘the civilized world’ are responsible for making conspiratorial alliance with the racist Sri Lankan regime and encouraged them to do the massacres of the poor and innocent Tamils. Today or tomorrow if same thing happened to those who encouraged the killers, then what the Tamil should feel? Most of the human rights organizations, and media like Aljazeera, BBC etc did not play the required role in preventing the massacre of Tamils. The style of reporting of these media is not up to the level of viewing things in its historical perspectives. American-Western conspiracy has racist and business content. Chinese and Japanese want to sell their products like hazardous toys and cars.

Vishnu Ramakrishnan

vishnurama
19 June 2009 at 12:08

It is not the matter of Tigers; it is the matter of Tamils. Japan supported the massacre of Tamils though it itself is under the Korean nuclear bombs. Japanese just want to put roads and sell their cars. They seem to be learned nothing out of the Second World War. Georgia sent troops to Iraq to help Americans to win the War; in the meantime their fate was decided by the Russians. Different countries nursed different speculative ambitions when the Eeelam war was going on, they pretend to be not aware of that some people are at the other side to decide their future. In this case nobody is exceptional even ‘the super powers’. That is the logic of conflicts. Western super powers and America have been fighting wars with tribal people; still they are not able to win. ‘The world community’ and ‘the civilized world’ are responsible for making conspiratorial alliance with the racist Sri Lankan regime and encouraged them to do the massacres of the poor and innocent Tamils. Most of the human rights organizations, and media like Aljazeera, BBC etc did not play the required role in reporting the truth. The style of reporting of these media is not up to the level of viewing things in its historical perspectives. American-Western conspiracy has racist and business content. Chinese and Japanese want to sell their products like hazardous toys and cars.

Candidly
20 June 2009 at 11:35

So after 25 years of insurrection and terrorism by the Tamil Tigers Brad Adams wants Sri Lanka to wave a magic wand and let everyone go home. It was a common complaint in the decades after WW2 that the vicorious allies were negligent in allowing thousands of former Nazis to escape and carry on as if they had done nothing wrong. Is HRW arguing the same mistake should be made with the Tamil Tiger?

Over the period of their rebellion tens of thousands of Sri Lankan Tamils, Singhalese and Moors (Moslems) were ethnically cleansed by the Tigers and forced out of their home towns and villages. Hundreds more men, women and children were murdered by bombs planted on buses and trains. Do not these people also have a right to justice, or at least that their government will try to ensure that the Tigers will never be allowed to re-group and start again?

There's another contradiction in what he writes. On the one hand he urges the Sri Lankan government to "plan for the future instaed of fighting the last war." Then in the next sentence states there should be an investigation into the conduct of the war, which, from his earlier comments, appears to mean only an investigation into the Sri Lankan government's conduct. It seems it's Human Rights Watch and Brad Adams who want to continue fighting the war against the Sri Lankan government, even though the Tamil Tigers have been defeated.

Desha
25 June 2009 at 22:34

Whats the problem with this writer? The plans for resettlement of IDPs are on the way and already commenced. Can't you have some patience. What you want is more suicide bombs?? Killing more people?Can you list some discrimination against Tamils in SL. I like to know. There are no minorities in US as priviledge as Tamils in SL. Tamils in Sl has more rights than Tamils anywhere in the world. Get your facts straight Sl has 3million Tamils not 300,000. 60% of them live in the South with Sinhalese and other and not in North and East. You sound like a idiotic moron barking for some money recieved by Tamil diaspora repeating thier misinformation propoganda. Sri Lnkans will decide about thier country you money hawks get out.

TAW
26 June 2009 at 14:28

Get a life Mr Adams,I am sure you got more interesting things to write about than sri Lankan for example Iraq ,Afghanistan and what the hell the american and british soliders are doing there.Leave Sri Lanka alone its not your problem if you feel so much for the tamil tigers,why dont you invite them to your country and give them assylum, not only will this solve Sri lankas biggest problem you'll also will be in peace knowing your tiger terrorist are safe to wage another war in another country.

TAW

Siri
29 June 2009 at 12:13

Mr. Brad Adams - You are not a Sri Lankan. You do not undestand what is happening in that country. You are a Westerner. As you may undestand them better, why don't you go and write about the Iraq situation or the Afgan war where Nato forces are killing civilians indiscriminately. Leave Sri Lanka alone. They know more about Human Rights than vultures like you who are trying to make a buck commenting on situations you know nothing about. I am sure the Americans will allow you in the swat valley where you can take your chances with the unmanned drones. You might even get lucky and survive to tell the story and then you can be a great Hero of your people who braved the Unmanned Drone hits to find out the truth. Truth is not an absolute term, but only a perception. Two independant people can look at the same situation and give very contradictory statements about what they saw. You and your Human Rights watchdogs never saw the killings perpetrated by the LTTE. You do not know about the number of women and children killed by the LTTE in their ethnic cleansing process. You have not said a word about any of this. Remaining quiet or ignoring some aspects of the fighting is tantamount to siding with the criminals and you deserve to be punished like them. Do not set foot in Sri Lanka as somebody who knows about you might decide to do something about it. The Hillarious USA State Department has given out a travel advisory to visitors entering Sri Lanka. They had people like you in mind when the did that. Please keep out of Sri Lankan affairs if you value your thick hide.

by Siri of NY, USA

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before you can comment on the website

Read More

Newsletter

Enter your email address here to receive updates from the team

Vote!

Will Baroness Ashton be an effective EU foreign minister?

Suggest a question

View comments

© New Statesman 1913 - 2009

Tracker