Return to: Home | World Affairs | Asia

Missing you already

Fatima Bhutto

Published 12 March 2009

Pakistan is at war with itself, with blackouts, corruption and terror attacks. Now there are calls for the return of the reviled Musharraf

Pakistan has become a very unusual place. In Lahore, the heart of Pakistani cricket, the Sri Lankan cricket team was attacked in broad daylight by masked gunmen carrying guns and rocket launchers, because you never know when a rocket launcher will come in handy during an urban attack. The government had been warned of a potential terror threat but, true to form, ignored it. After killing eight people, mostly policemen, and wounding several others including the foreign cricketers, the gunmen ambled leisurely away. They were caught on CCTV camera calmly mounting their motorcycles and surveying the scene before deciding they had other places to be.

Immediately the cacophony of ludicrous claims hit the media. “The attack is to ruin our [the ruling party’s] image,” bellowed Raja Riaz, a Pakistan People’s Party hack. Er, no. “The motive was to damage the state of Pakistan and end cricket here,” said Imran Khan, head of the Tehreek-e-Insaf party. Er, no. The Pakistan cricket team are perfectly capable of ruining the state of cricket in the country on their own; masked gunmen are not required, thank you very much. Incidentally, on Monday night local police attacked the offices of Khan’s party brandishing Kalashnikovs and pistols. It’s probably not a coincidence that Khan has been openly critical of the Zardari government.

It’s fear. That’s what it is. It’s the state of a nation at war with itself. When vigilantes armed with sophisticated weaponry can attack a team of cricket guests (and there are no guests more esteemed in south Asia) in the middle of the afternoon, what they’re telling you is that no one is above the reach of the terror that has taken over Pakistan. It’s startling how adept this government has been at losing control of law and order, leasing out Pakistan’s stability for an increased role in the war on terror in preparation for the troop surge in Afghanistan, and generally running the country to rot.

“Droned” is a verb we use now in Pakistan. It turns out, interestingly enough, that those US predator drones that have been killing Pakistani citizens almost weekly have been taking off from and landing within our own country. Secret airbases in Balochistan – what did we ever do before Google Earth?

The PPP-led government, hailed as being “democratic”, capitulated to the Pakistan Taliban’s demands for sharia law in the Swat Valley in February. There was no vote, no referendum, nothing. The government, tired of fighting those pesky militants who’ve been burning down Sufi shrines and local girls’ schools, just declared that a part of the country would be ruled no longer by federal law, but by a myopically interpreted and Taliban-approved “Islamic” code. And verily it shall be.

We’ve just had senate “elections”. Of course, there are no actual elections involved: the ruling party puts forward winners and they end up in parliament. On Monday, in a shock move, President Asif Ali Zardari’s former attorney, who defended the erstwhile criminal on corruption and murder charges, was made chairman of the senate. What a gas!

Meanwhile, with Delhi still beating war drums over the November Mumbai attacks, our former dictator/president Pervez Musharraf travelled to India recently, and there he warned our neighbours of an all-out war should they strike Pakistan. He also let us know that he is ready to return to the call of political duty. Outsiders might be confused at this change in the situation – what’s he doing there? Didn’t he resign in August? Here’s the beauty of it all: Musharraf’s re-emergence has many middle-class Pakistanis excited and hopeful. Is he back?! A series of op-eds in a local English newspaper (not highly censored because no one reads them) was titled “Why I miss Musharraf”. When a dictator tickles your fancy, you know something has gone very, very wrong.

So, the mood in Pakistan is one of confusion. How did we come to this? How do we get out?

On the eve of spring, it is the same problems that blight the country’s poor – there is no electricity, there is no potable water, and food inflation continues to rise. The newspapers warned us this week that “load shedding” in the summer will be some 15 hours long, which is not that bad considering the fact that we’re sitting in darkness for 12 hours a day now. Pakistan has long missed its millennium target goals of eradicating polio, largely because we can’t keep the electricity going long enough for the vaccines to be properly refrigerated, so they keep going bad. And we’re a nuclear country, a grossly corrupt one at that.

The press censorship continues unabated with future threats of an absolute blackout on any criticisms of the government safely enclosed within the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act that the parliament is currently sitting on. The bill, which imposes jail sentences from three months (for having an email account not registered in your real name) to the death penalty, and criminalises the acts of “spoofing”, “spamming” and “character assassinating”, will apply to the width and breadth of the country and to any person, regardless of nationality or citizenship. It will crack down on all objectionable – the definition of what is objectionable is typically vague – messages sent via, but not limited to, “electrical, digital, analogue, magnetic, optical, biochemical, electrochemical, electromechanical, electromagnetic, radio electric, and wireless technology”. So any subversive content found on cell phones, computers, or toasters will soon be illegal. Your head should be spinning by now.

Pakistan is in a dire situation. Religious extremism, violence and a faltering economy have made the state of affairs here decidedly grim. Joe Biden and John Kerry see American dollars as the only way of helping Pakistan stave off extremism; but Yankee aid donations and senatorial money will not help us now. It is estimated that President Zardari and his late wife, Benazir Bhutto, stole between $2bn and $3bn from the country’s treasury during their two previous stints in power. Now Zardari has claimed his personal wealth to be somewhere in the ballpark of $1.8bn. Nawaz Sharif, leading coalition partner and head of the Pakistan Muslim League, declared his fortune to be not as grand, at only $1.4bn. You do the maths.

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

11 comments from readers

mtma
12 March 2009 at 12:55

Well put, Fatima. But you fail to mention Gadari-Zardari's mockery of the judiciary and complete injustice that faces Pakistan. You could have given it a slight mention with long march right around the corner (in fact tomorrow)- just a suggestion.....

Otherwise, brilliant piece as usual!

swatantra nandanwar
12 March 2009 at 17:52

Just to stop the cricket? I am sure Imran would agree that there are things more important than cricket. Pakistan is a basket case. Musharaf certainly knew that the politcians like Bhutto/Zardari and Sharif could not be trusted. But neither can Imran. The only way to deal with failed states is to cut off aid and relations altogether and let them sink until they come to their senses.

swatantra nandanwar
12 March 2009 at 17:56

Imran should stick to cricket and not dabble in politics. The Bhuttos/Zaedaris and Sharifs make Musharaf look competant.

uvalawn
13 March 2009 at 00:27

There is hope. The lawyers defeated a military dictator, now they're up against zardari for the heavy-weight championship.

They're using non-violent resistance to fight for justice and they're gonna win. 8th round via knockout!

Zameer Hussain
13 March 2009 at 18:39

Thanks ma'am for an article of such reality and brevity.It is true that everyone in Pakistan is in shocked state after a year of controversial democratic process that has at present been ruined by the same pseudo-electoral s of Pakistan.It is true that middle class in Pakistan is looking-back Musharraf to back in system,but Miss Bhutto failed to describe the reasons for a such setback.Second is that Pakistani middle class has no money and back to get in famous newspapers to raise their voice and to participate in any decision-making process.Pakistan is under biggest threat not by terrorists but corrupt politicians who have key role in promoting fundamentalism and all -isms in Pakistan by filling their pockets and depriving the poor of their basic rights to live.This condition predisposed the poor of Pakistan whose majority are illiterate and unaware to get disconcert by traces of fundamentalists to use them for their heinous purposes. At present situation,biggest threat to America and all European countries who are the part of those systems by backing corrupt and incompetent politicians in 3rd world are the same grown dummies.After all,i will like to mention that by satging Mr zardari as forefront of corrpution,other big fishes in pakistan have succeeded to cover themselves to avert the attention of ordinary people .

by making assume the only criminal and corrput in pakistan is zadrai and they are all saints.Actually Pakistan has suffered from corrpution at different arenas by variety of corrupts.He is definitely the part of one of them and not a separate entity.So as being a part of pakistani community and citizen,it is a request to US and all western countries,it is not the fundamentalism (that;s off-course a threat)a true threat at 1st place but reasons behind them are 1st to address.People in pakistan are suffering inflation and many social taboos due to lack of education and awareness that is hindered by people sitting at apex of the system .bye,zam.

Sadia Qazi
13 March 2009 at 19:55

I often read articles of Fatima. She writes well but one thing that I have noted; she always ignores ground realities, fighting with everyone is not the good sign in politics. Politics is the art of compromise and you have to give solutions to the issues. Criticism over criticism is the policy of Fatima. However, I dislike Zardari but it does not mean that he has done everything wrong. He is not totally wrong or enemy of Pakistan.

I think personal attack on everyone is not the sign of a good leader. Fatima should understand. I am nearly 30 years older than her. She is like my daughter and I wish she should come into politics. I love my country and I see potential in Fatima.

Why Americans always trust upon same old faces Sharif, Zardari, Musharraf and vice versa. But, present situation of Pakistan and the ugly performance of politicians will force the Americans to look for some new faces like Fatima, Raja Naveed, Imran Khan, Aitzaz Ahsan etc.

Daughter you should not misunderstand, but I guide you to be polite and create room in your heart for everyone and whenever criticize must ensure the facts. You are our leader. I take one-step forward and advise you to get married with Mr. Raja Naveed and give Pakistan a great leadership. What’s wrong? You both are young, bachelor and handsome. A good leader’s couple, instead of George Clooney???

amhsirak rian
13 March 2009 at 20:15

Pakistan is not a failed state,at least not yet. And cutting aid and relations is not the solution to making anyone come to their senses. Look what happened in Afghanistan, when everyone just let it be, today you have a problem that everyone is pointing around without realizing it came in to creation by the same ones that now judge.Dialogue is the only effective channel. Politicians can never be trusted period!

Riaz Ahmad
13 March 2009 at 23:47

Fatima Bhutto, when the people of Pakistan have time and again displayed the same old suicidal tendency of electing the same old corrupt, tired and worn out political parties, what hope is there for the country and its people?

The police and the entire legal system have always sold justice like a commodity, how do you expect democracy to function in the absence of even a very basic rule of law, justice and fairness.

In the absence of any rule of law, corruption for decades has become deep rooted in the country and its culture; it is no wonder the state of Pakistan has begun to implode under the weight of such deep malaise. The very same lawyers and judges pretending to be champions of justice have been selling justice for years, even a poor illiterate man in a poor village in Pakistan knows this reality.

Pak Democrat
17 March 2009 at 17:26

Young Fatima Bhutto, through circumstances beyond her control, has largely grown up in Karachi and mixed with the urban English-speaking elite who have historically abhorred democracy in favour of military dictatorships.

Other than this urban elite no one, even those who loathe Asif Zardari and his corrupt cronies in power, wish for a return of Musharraf. A pox on both these lawless goondas is the cry from all the four provinces of Pakistan.

nawawimohamad
18 March 2009 at 05:43

Pakistan has never experienced normalcy since its separation from India. Until now, there is no true statesman who can unite and lead Pakistan to economic success, political stability and development. But this is the nature of the Pakistanis, they can't be helped. Pakistan is not a homogenous country. There are many ethnics, with various beliefs, culture and languages, with no real majority of any faction. Therefore there is no faction in Pakistan that can dominate the others, thus the quarrels, squabbles, quagmire and chaos will continue forever amongst its people. This is of course seen as an advantage to the west especially the US to make use of fragile Pakistan for its agendas. The most important tool that the US has is money which Pakistan has not. By using money, the US can use whoever in power to control Pakistan. Now the political struggle in Pakistan will be perpetual because the politicians and their cronies and the government of Pakistan is totally corrupt. The political squabbling in Pakistan is because of money that the US is giving and nothing else. The one in power will control the money, tons of money. There is no democracy in Pakistan, the US is also not interested in democracy or even the rule of law in Pakistan, and the US is only interested in using Pakistan. Pakistan does not need democracy, it needs decency in all respects but it will never have it. Pakistan must understand that it has nothing there of interest to the US, no oil, no nothing. Pakistan is only lucky or otherwise (depending on which way you look at it) because of its geographical position, no not democracy, it is geography. Knowing that Pakistan will be a failed-state, the US is now eyeing India and India has started to bite the lure. So long Pakistan, it is just pathetic.

Tahir
24 March 2009 at 12:40

Fatima did not call back Musharaf, she only cited disappointment expressed by certain people in newspapers, though insignificant in number, about the poor performance of the present democratic government. The abhorrence for Musharaf/dictatorship of the overwhelming majority of people of Pakistan notwithstanding, the way present government disregarded its promises with the electorate, makes it discredited as a democratic government. The conduct of government has bereft it of all credentials of people friendly government. It has lost its vote bank with unprecedented speed. Law and oreder situation is very dangerous and proves government incompetency. It is not even democratic government because the mandate neverr meant for the prsident Zardari because he did not contest from any constituency to become MNA. So electorate could not expect him to be calling the shots, given the understanding arrived at in Charter of Democracy regarding repealing of 17th amendment which empowers the presidency at the cost of parliament and prime minister. Power was hijacked with deceitful manoeuvring in utter disregard of the mandate of electorate.

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before you can comment on the website

Read More

Vote!

Will Baroness Ashton be an effective EU foreign minister?

Suggest a question

View comments

© New Statesman 1913 – 2009

Tracker