Return to: Home | World Affairs | Asia

Pakistan is failing but cannot be allowed to fail

Published 05 March 2009

The 3 March terror attack on the Sri Lankan national cricket team in Lahore was a tragic event on many levels. Above all for the families of the six policemen killed, men whose names we will not remember. When an “ordinary” person loses his life it never receives the same attention as that directed at the famous. But it is also a tragedy for Sri Lanka, whose tourism industry will suffer through association with this barbarous act, even though it took place thousands of miles away; and for cricket, a sport that was once a byword for gentlemanly conduct, until it became so beset by scandal.

But the deepest significance lies in the impact it will have on Pakistan, which increasingly resembles the “failed state” that many already accuse it of being. The attacks provide confirmation that India’s concerns about its northern neighbour’s inability to prevent the radicalisation of even more of its citizens are justified. These concerns were amplified by the Foreign Secretary, David Miliband, during his visit to India in January, when he called on Pakistan to show “zero tolerance” to its home-grown militant networks.

Pakistan is not yet a failed state: the phrase has an unwelcome ring of finality to it and bespeaks the politics of despair. Yet no one can be indifferent to the possible disintegration of a nuclear-armed country of 170 million. Pakistan simply cannot be allowed to fail. The Lahore attack only makes that resolve more urgent.

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

3 comments from readers

cjs2111
05 March 2009 at 18:07

Good analysis. I was just reading a long, rich, historical piece by Moni Mohsin who basically agrees - she notes the convergence of a 25 year Islamization process with Pakistan's recent economic collapse, which provide some heady and disturbing context for recent events on the subcontinent.

The piece is here, in the Boston Review: http://www.bostonreview.net/BR34.2/mohsin.php

Riaz Ahmad
07 March 2009 at 01:43

When IRA bombs became a monthly affair in UK, did the country become a failed state?

nawawimohamad
12 March 2009 at 05:43

Pakistan has never experienced normalcy since its seperation from India. The peoples of Pakistan are never united because of their various ethnicity and beliefs and there is no true statesman amongst them to unite and lead the country.Coupled by the country being poor and lack natural resources it is an impossible task to develope the country or to strenghten it. But this is of a great opportunity for foreign powers especially the US to meddle in the internal affairs of Pakistan. The present government in Pakistan is the most useless and with just a little amount of money and considerable threat from the US, Pakistan can allow the US to bomb an integral part of its sovereignty namely the Swat Valley and the areas around it as the US wishes. Pakistan is for sale.

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before you can comment on the website

Read More

Newsletter

Enter your email address here to receive updates from the team

Vote!

Will the next election produce a hung parliament?

Suggest a question

View comments

© New Statesman 1913 - 2009

Tracker