Miliband denounces Starkey's "utterly outrageous" and "racist" comments

The Labour Leader, Ed Miliband, has called on all politicians to condemn the popular historian's con

The Leader of the Opposition, Ed Miliband, has denounced as "disgusting", "utterly outrageous" and "racist" comments made by David Starkey on the BBC's Newsnight last night.

During the panel discussion, which focused on the recent riots across England, the popular historian David Starkey went on what his co-panellist Owen Jones has described as a "racially inflammatory tirade." The third participant of the discussion, novelist Dreda Say Mitchell, said Starkey's comments were "random and confused" and showed "complete ignorance about the social dynamics of urban life in Britain."

Starkey, in reference to Enoch Powell's Rivers of Blood speech that saw him dismissed from the Heath's Shadow Cabinet in 1968, said "the Tiber didn't foam with blood but flames lambent wrapped around Tottenham and [...] Clapham." Blaming a "profound cultural change" for the riots, he said "the whites have become black."

In what Jones said was an equation of "white" with "respectable", Starkey claimed of the black Tottenham MP David Lammy that, "if you turned the screen off so you were listening to him on radio you would think he was white."

Jones said that this was "utterly outrageous. What you're doing is you're equating black culture with criminality."

In another controversial passage, Starkey claimed that "a particular sort of violent, destructive nihilistic, gangster culture has become the fashion. And black and white, boy and girl, operate in this language together. This language which is wholly false, which is this Jamaican patois that has been intruded in England. And that's why so many of us have this sense of literally a foreign country."

The BBC reported that Miliband, speaking at Haverstock School in Chalk Farm - a multi-faith, racially mixed state school - said that "there should be condemnation from every politician, from every political party of those sorts of comments."

 

 

 

 

31 comments

historybuff's picture

Perhaps people including Miliband should be much more careful and selective in the use of the words 'racist' and 'racism'. When they are overused they become redundant. These words are rarely if ever used in the United States and European countries by politicians or the media; they seem to be strangely British in their very common usage.

Nick's picture

@historybuff

'These words ['racist' and 'racism'] are rarely if ever used in the United States' - really?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2K8R2PDmbmA

ACMJ's picture

You won't see Cameron backing Ed Miliband's comments , as David Cameron has a tendency to pander to the Neo-Conservative right wing like David Starkey , and is desperate for support from the likes of Starkey . who is laughingly regarded as a "historian" .

Barry Ewart's picture

Good point by Sir Michael re Starkey's background - I meant he should do a GCSE in poliitics and sociology. He seems to have an homogenous view of black people. Also he called rioters feral - feral means human beings brought up by wild animals. By the way what happened 2 Grandmaster Flash - was positive rap.

Ultra_Fox's picture

Well done Ed!

It's time we took on the arguments of the far-right head-on and drive this bigotry out of mainstream politics for good.

kal hodgson's picture

Interesting that Ian Duncan-Smith wouldn't condemned these comments when asked to on Channel 4 on Saturday night.

historybuff's picture

Looks like being accused of being racist is the present day equivalent of being accused of witchcraft; accusation means guilt, one way or another. Just like being plunged into the local pond on a ducking stool or having your moles pricked with a needle to see if they bleed, anyone today in the UK accused of being racist will be condemned and subject to vicious assault, because there is no adequate response to it that will satisfy the accuser.

Nick's picture

@historybuff - The difference being that racism, unlike witchcraft, is not a crime for which anyone is being convicted, condemned and punished. Unless of course they disadvantaged anyone through discrimination, or directly incited violence, which isn't the case with Dr. Starkey. Ultimately people will have to decide for themselves about these comments and, on a generous interpretation, reasonable people will differ. Sounds quite unlike a witch-hunt to me.

Dan's picture

I live in Handsworth. What Mr Starkey has said is absolutely correct and I have seen this cultural change take place over the last twenty or so years. It's a shame our politicians are so out of touch with what's happening to parts of our society.

A meadows's picture

Labour's been doing so well lately with their denounciation of the Rioters as just "looters" not having to do what they do due to poverty ,plus Ed not backing teh strikers, I'd have more respect for Ed if he denounced that wally Owen Jones too.

Latest tweets