Registered user login:

TheFaithColumn

The Faith Column

Every week a different believer gives the inside track on their religion or philosophy.

The Faith Column Homepage

Shunned from her Amish family

  • Posted by Anna Dee Olson
  • 19 March 2008

Anna Dee Olson, who lived the Amish lifestyle until age 24, describes her journey from growing up Amish to be shunned by her family for sinning and acting against the Amish faith.

What does the world really know about the Amish, a population of over 300,000 throughout the United States? Amish are considered to be the most secretive culture in America. Basically unless you were born into an Amish family or joined them, you can only know the surface of this hidden culture. Much of what is written about the Amish is by people who did not grow up Amish. What I am saying is that unless you are part of that culture you cannot know the Amish as deeply as someone who was raised Amish.

I was born and raised by Amish parents who lived in Missouri, Wisconsin, and Minnesota in the United States. At 24 years old I made my first life changing decision for myself and walked away from the only life I had ever known. I went searching for a life filled with love, peace, and tranquility. One might say, “I thought that is what the Amish life is all about?” Well I am telling you that it was not for me. Certainly there are some things about my heritage that I will always treasure and I still practice today, but, we have to remember that Amish people are human beings just like the rest of us and they do have shortcomings.

My parents had ten children; four still practice the Amish faith and lifestyle today but six do not. I was the first female in my family to walk away. Today I am shunned from my family, community, and most Amish communities throughout America.

Shunning – you will find that this word has a varied meaning depending on the community you are in but I will explain what it meant in my community. When a member of the church (I was not a member until I was baptized at age 18) has gone against the rules of the church they are considered to be in sin. Your name is then announced to all members so they know to impose the shunning upon you. It is a requirement to shun sinners or you are in sin yourself. This means there is no buying or selling with the member being shunned. You cannot sit at the same table and have a meal and, in the case of a married couple, there are no martial relations during the shunning.

The above rules go across every Amish community but the following are some that were specific to my community. They cannot accept gifts from me (as the sinner), they will never visit my home, they can give me money but not accept any money from me, and I cannot attend a church service unless I want to rejoin the Amish.

All rules of the church are not written. The members are reminded of the rules twice a year. The Bishop, Ministers, and Deacon along with the elders of the church and parents are responsible to enforce the rules.

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • NowPublic
  • Reddit

7 comments from readers

Laura
19 March 2008 at 16:06

I live in Maine and have 11 children!! I would give anything to join the community here in Maine.

I would NOT listion to anything from anyone that has left the Amish!! THey are angry people!!

Laura Winters

Maine

JarleyHorse
20 March 2008 at 12:07

Dear Laura, it sounds like you are carrying a lot of anger too.

For more information on Amish, go to www.MapMinistry.org

growingupamish
22 March 2008 at 13:30

Laura it saddens me that you took from my article that all ex-Amish are angry people........It is very satisfying for me to know that this is only your opinion and not the real truth. I have great respect for my Amish family and all the people that are still Amish.

My writings are from the time that I was an angry Amish but since I have left I have had the opportunity to know that I don't have to live every day being angry.

We have to remember that everyone's experience is different and I know that you cannot know my situation because you have not lived it.

My view is that if you judge the ex-Amish as angry people then you are also judging the Amish as angry people and why would you want to join them unless you are also very angry.

You may not believe this but I would wholeheartedly support you if you decided to join the Amish.

In any case my writings were my true experiences and how I felt about that at the time it happened. Even though I would not wish anything bad on anyone I don't believe my experiences were in vein. I am a stronger person today because of my childhood experiences.

Unbeknown to me God was with me then, but today I know God is with me every step I take.

Blessings,

Anna Dee Olson

www.GrowingUpAmish.com

www.TheAmishLady.com

DBeach777
23 March 2008 at 17:54

Dear Laura,

You can hardly know what you're talking about unless you have walked in these shoes yourself. Certainly, some families appear to live a happy and peaceful life in the amish, but from first hand experience, this is often not true for everyone.

It sounds to me as if you're projecting your own anger unto us ex-amish. And while you're entitled to your opinion, it seems humorous to me that you even have such a strong opinion to start with! You are looking through a filtered perspective if you are looking from the outside, in. Certainly many that leave the amish, leave with hurt and anger, but by leaving, healing can start to happen... or it may not, It's an individual process. They are Human, not Aliens or Gods! For myself, I can certainly say that I am much freer and happier now then when I was amish. I am grateful, as Anna also has stated, for having grown up there, but as an adult I am thankful that I can make my own choices, and not remain a victim.

Dan Beachy

nawawimohamad
27 March 2008 at 09:08

But truly there has to be just one true and correct religion. If the Amish is right and are on the correct path then only about 300,000 people in this world are on the road to salvation and the rest of the world are doomed. How about people in Timbuktu can they be Amish? If not how can they get salvation? I believe that to be fair, a religion has got to be universal for everybody to practice no matter where they are or what they are.

Dorvid
08 April 2008 at 05:28

Any religion or lifestyle that practices exclusivity is a cult. God in inclusive, man's religions are exclusive. I choose God over religion.

JoshChicago
24 June 2008 at 16:13

Dear Anna Dee Olson;

I wanted to first comment that I truly admire your inner strength and tenacity. I've read alot of negative comments, and truly believe that their are just many many individuals that just have to complain about something/or anything and I hope you do not allow this to dictate your emotions when they direct their negativity your way. Hang in there. I secondly wanted to inform you that I'd like to help, I'd like to hire some former Amish, I want to play my role and help them financially get acclimated to their new lifestyle. Please advise. Respectfully, Joshua

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before your comment is displayed on the website

We want to encourage people to comment on our content and to exchange views with other readers and hope this will be done on a courteous basis. However, if you encounter posts which are offensive please let us know by emailing comments@newstatesman.co.uk and we will take swift action where necessary.

About the writer

Anna Dee Olson grew up Amish and left the Amish faith. She is the author of a book called: Growing Up Amish: Insider Secrets from One Woman's Inspirational Journey. Today Anna conducts tele-webcasts on a regular basis to help bridge the gap between the Amish culture and mainstream America and the world.

Recent Posts

Working to educate the youth

  • By Doug Harris
  • 03 July 2008

The social impact of cult groups

  • By Allen Tate Wood
  • 02 July 2008

Saving your family from the Manson Family

  • By Allen Tate Wood
  • 01 July 2008

Inside the head of a new cult member

  • By Allen Tate Wood
  • 30 June 2008

A spirituality to suit the times

  • By Paul Harrison
  • 26 June 2008

Loving life as a Pantheist

  • By Paul Harrison
  • 25 June 2008

Meeting spiritual needs naturally

  • By Paul Harrison
  • 24 June 2008

Also by Anna Dee Olson